One more battery question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I've had 2 yellow tops and both failed at 2 years or less (1 at a time). I still have a red top thats been going for 5 years. Because of the yellow top failures, I converted to Odysseys and haven't had one fail yet (2-1700s in the LC, a 1200 in the Heep, and a 545 in the Harley) - all fairly new at 4 years or less.
 
...
I have had first hand experience with hundreds of yellowtop batteries. They are the number one replacement battery for emergency vehicles. As a matter of fact, the San Diego County Sheriff's Department buys over a hundered a year for new vehicles. While I have seen many fail over the years, it still amazes me the amount of abuse they can take and still keep going strong.

All of my municipality fleet customers have now replaced the Optimas with standard lead acid batteries in mission critical vehicles. The last one was the city of Scottsdale, they just went to Interstate Megatons. The reason that I hear is way to many random, early failures and a lot of times the Optimas give no warning, start the motor fine, the next time dead, not a good thing on an emergency vehicle!

Their experience has been that standard lead acid batteries are much more reliable than AGM batteries. With a simple maintenance program, fluid check and load test once a month, they can pretty accurately predict when lead acid batteries are getting weak, going to die. They couldn’t find a way to predict it with the AGM batteries, even tried removing and weighing them attempting to predict when they are drying out. Came to the conclusion that the best maintenance program for them is to replace them regularly. The AGM’s are more expensive and they don’t get any more life out of them, so they switched back to lead acid.

YMMV. It very hot here and most emergency vehicles idle for long periods, driving the heat load higher. In other climates and uses these issues probably aren’t a problem, but after talking to them, my junk will have lead acid batteries.:D
 
Obviously everyone will have different experiences to share. The only Optima I have ever personally owned, failed in just under 2 years. I have not run another one since. However, when I do my dual set up, I will be running dual yellowtops.

When it comes to standard lead acid batteries, the Interstate Megatron plus is by far my first choice. It's what I run in my 4Runner.

One thing you did forget to address is what happens when you are being shot at, need to get out of the area and your lead acid battery takes a bullet? I know the Optima would still start your car. Since I cater to 90% plus law enforcement agencies compared to 10% or less fire vehicles my experience may be weighted:D
 
i don't get shot at but I do run into buildings on fire. I will look at at what the city of houston buys and I ainn't gonna get what they buy. Sale goes to the lowest bidder That sucks.

Been several times when our s*** won't start. Battery? Alt? Dunno. I want something that won't leave me s*** out of luck with my family in the truck.

6-7 years from a battery is not to bad, at least where I live. Y'all have been way cool on the input...that's why I am here, getting info on this site. Thanks again...

:beer::beer:
 
I have not been too thrilled with my Optima's. I had converted my cruisers to yellow tops and have had four failures in the past year--two of which have been in the last week. Three of the failures have been as the auxilary batteries on two different vehicles. I just replaced one today with an Odyssey and next week will add another. I don't know if the high temperatures over the past month or just bad luck accounted for the most recent failures.

I have one Odyssey as a main battery on one of the cruisers and have had no troubles. I am interested in seeing if the switch will help any.

My only option on getting Odyssey batteries is over the Internet.
 
How often do you drive those vehicle's? The one's with the failure's.

I too as previously stated believe mine failed due to heat, combined with lack of use.

Just curious.
 
Odyssey

I use the Odyssey PC2150, thus far no problems. Only took a couple of hours and a six pack to install. Lots of power to spare. I didn't get the one with the metal jacket. Had I know my wife would shoot the truck if I put any more money into it I would have spent the extra $.
 
How often do you drive those vehicle's? The one's with the failure's.

I too as previously stated believe mine failed due to heat, combined with lack of use.

Just curious.

They are in two different vehicles that get swapped around as DD's. They might go about a week without driving.

I had second thoughts on getting another Odyssey today and got the large Costco marine battery. It doesn't have the same power, it does have an OK warranty. If my luck with batteries continues, this may bankrupt Costco.:D
 
If u go with the Odyssey series, u will need the Ultimizer charger to keep these batteries in top condition. This charger is brand new and designed for the Odyssey series of batteries; and is one sweet gadget.

http://www.batterymart.com/p-odyssey-ultimizer-12v-25a-battery-charger.html


The voltage on these batteries is around 12.8 volts for 100% full charge. 80% is around 12.6 volts. Gell batts require PM, say every 6 months. A standard charger will not bring these batts to full capacity. The Odyssey batts require the correct charge algorithm; and the right charger does this.

The standard alternator will not do these batteries justice; its only designed to charge a standard lead acid battery, so u need to do Periodic Maintenance on the gell batteries to keep them in top shape. The way to test these batts (Odyssey) is to charge them on the right charger and then measure the voltage [the Ultimizer does all this] and see if the voltage holds at 12.81 volts over a few days time. If the battery only stays charged to , say, 12.5 volts (75-80%), then it is losing its capacity and is on the way out. I'm doing this at this time and my 8 year old MAIN battery is is only holding at 12.5 volts; time for a replacement.



http://homepage.mac.com/dfmorse/BattProj2/page1.html

...
 
Back
Top Bottom