oil

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 7, 2003
Threads
402
Messages
13,956
Location
lebanon,pa
Website
www.facebook.com
is 15w-40 too much for a 1fze, that makes good pressure now, with what i'm assuming is 10w-30?
i ask only due to i keep a bunch of it around for everything else.
 
15w-40 will be fine. In fact, I've run 15w-50 quite a bit in my 80. Rotella has a good rep, I like Chevron Delo, but not for any scientific reason, maybe it's the blue bottle.

I am surprised more people do not run the heavy duty oils. Delo or Rotella have to be about the best bang for the buck in oil out there.
 
I run any type of HD Diesel oil, Castrol Tection, Rotella, Delvac 1300, Delo... Same with yard equipment and motorcycles/ATV's. Doesn't get cold around here so heavier is better.
 
10-30 and later 5-30 were specified because those oils were used in EPA testing (fuel economy) and the manufacturer is not supposed to use one oil for testing purposes and another for general use. The heavier oils are listed in other markets, IE OZ where I believe the charts list up to 20-50.
The lighter oil in theory provides better fuel economy.
 
is 15w-40 too much for a 1fze, that makes good pressure now, with what i'm assuming is 10w-30?
i ask only due to i keep a bunch of it around for everything else.

In virtually any climate that you're likely to be in, you want to use a lower "cold weight", such as 0wxxx or 5wxx if you can't fine a 0wxx.
Unless there is a specific reason (which requires an oil temperature gauge and an oil pressure gauge to determine) you should use a 30 for the for "hot weight" such as a 0w30 or a 5w30 if you can't find a 0w30.




Fred
 
In virtually any climate that you're likely to be in, you want to use a lower "cold weight", such as 0wxxx or 5wxx if you can't fine a 0wxx.
Unless there is a specific reason (which requires an oil temperature gauge and an oil pressure gauge to determine) you should use a 30 for the for "hot weight" such as a 0w30 or a 5w30 if you can't find a 0w30.




Fred

I think 0w30 and 5w30 are way to thin for the 1fz. 5w40 and up to 20w50 as dan specified. Cold months I like 5w40 Rotella, hot months 15w40 Delo (CHEAP at Costco).
 
I think 0w30 and 5w30 are way to thin for the 1fz. 5w40 and up to 20w50 as dan specified. Cold months I like 5w40 Rotella, hot months 15w40 Delo (CHEAP at Costco).


This forum is the only one, out of a half a dozen or so that I visit, that people seem to have a had time understand oil, how it works and why.

Please, post up SPECIFICALLY WHY you, or whomever, believe that the thicker oils are better and/or why the 0w30 and/or 5w30 are "too thin".
After that I'll repost with the corrections ;)

You do understand, don't you (though obviously not ;) that oven 0w (as in 0w30) is too thick at startup (assuming the engines cooled down) 0w is too thick at even 100*F, so why in the world would anyone want to use/recommend anything thicker, as in 20wxxx for any climate conditions.......

:)
Fred
 
then why do car makers recommend 5W-40 or 10w-30 etc instead of 0w-40?


They're several reasons:

- In the case of 5w-40 (who recommends that anyway these days ?) or 5w-30, it's because the 0w, as in 0w-30 or 0w-40 is hard to find. 5W-xx is easier to find.

- They assume that most people are going to use regular oil, not synthetic. In the case of multi-weight, regular oil (lets say 10w-30), the oil starts as a 10w oil and viscosity improvers/enhancers (VI's) are added to make it behave as a 30w at operation temperature.
The problem is that the VI's are a "wear item", that is they wear out and as/when they do, the oil stops behaving as a 30w at operating temperatures (the VI's are gone) and it's now a straight 10w and that is too thin at operating temperatures.
So they're trying to protect the engine from the most likely damage (over time) that will happen to it and that is people will use regular oil and a lot of the clowns won't change it as often as they should.
If they recommended (and people used) say a 0w-30 and the oil wasn't change properly, it'd act as a straight 0w oil when the VI's wore out and that would hurt the engine more (they believe) than the excessive cold start wear that occurs when running the 10w-30 in the vehicle.



:)
Fred
 
Every 4/5/6 cylinder diesel engine out there...(i.e., every VW TDI has 5w40 as the recommended weight).


Mmmm, last time I checked we were on the page regarding gasoline engines....

Diesels, clearance wise, running temperature wise, etc. are different (obviously).

Still note the 5w for the cold weight (again note many choices for 0w40). The oil flow characteristics are the same regardless of the type of engine ;)



:)
Fred
 
And you know the 80 "likes it" by how ?? :)




:)
Fred

To be honest with you, sometimes experience trumps scientific, hard data.

I am not saying that is the case here, but I think that is the distiction you are trying to make.

While interesting and enjoyable to banter back and forth like this, the evidence suggests that our engines (specifically the 1FZ-FE) like a somewhat heavier oil and has been discussed here ad infinitum if you search through the archives.

If you search under the user name "cary" or "Raventai" you will see why some of us do use a heavier oil, even though scientific data suggests that we should not or that a lighter weight oil might lubricate better (and I'm not saying that they don't).

There are plenty of "do this" and "don't do that" types of threads in the 80 section. We are slightly factional here--and in the other sections of MUD as well. As a large, diverse community, there are bound to be different opinions, sources of data, as well as methods of testing that data, and even different definitions of what each of those might mean.

Anyway, I see what you are trying to impress onto the conversation started by the OP.

Regards.
-o-
 
Back
Top Bottom