- Joined
- Jul 20, 2004
- Threads
- 274
- Messages
- 23,204
- Location
- Chandler, AZ
- Website
- www.tontorecreationalliance.org
At one time I would have agreed, but have fully switched.
Agree, get what you are comfortable with.
You forgot steel, the best mount material. On the copper radiator the mount sides are often steel, doesn't solder well, common failure point. Solid metal radiators suffer from vibration/flexing failures, cracking. At one time composite units were pretty poor, but have come a longways, why do all new cars come with them, like for three decades? The crimps, plastic, bolted design allows for the best materials to be used for each part, allows for flex, cushioning protection for the core.
Almost no one runs copper, so all common coolant is biased to aluminum, at the expense of solder. Often see solder bloom clogging, corrosion, thinning, failure of the solder joints. Copper can be more easily repaired, maybe, the last two we have taken in, the repair quote was way more than replacement, mainly due to overall solder loss.
The bottom line, all radiators are consumables, all are going to die. Fortunately they are now cheaper than ever, so not worth repairing. Plastic is much better than it was, likely not as durable as brass, but likely as good or better than solder. We work on older rigs, are seeing accelerated failure rate on their copper radiators, much more so than just a few years ago. For us, all but full classic restorations get replaced with aluminum.
Can, or if the advantages of aluminum are taken into the design, can be more efficient than copper. I don't need an article, we often travel with a caravan of '80's, most equipped with OBD2 gauges. As you say, depends on what you are trying to achieve, agree, in normal use not likely to note any difference. We travel in the desert, so fully stress them, one of the goals is to have as much capacity, efficiency as possible. A row of rigs, say a dozen, climbing ~8% grade at 110F and call the coolant numbers on the radio, the copper radiators are always the hottest, by a significant margin, repeatable, like every time, dealer or aftermarket. All of them have now swapped to aluminum, for this reason. The last one was a couple of months ago, the old radiator was in good condition, noted reduced temps, eliminated the pinging that it had, etc.
"Better" of course depends on what you are trying to achieve, yes?
Agree, get what you are comfortable with.
...
I would remind everyone that when comparing an 'Aluminum' radiator to a Brass/Copper radiator (for an 80 series) you do NOT have a 100% Aluminum structure! The article you provided compares an ALL aluminum radiator against a Copper/Brass/Lead Solder radiator.
The radiator for an 80 series (and 100 series) is Aluminum, Plastic and Synthetic Rubber. The area I had trouble with in BOTH of my radiators was not with the aluminum. It was with the plastic caps (split) or the rubber seal (hardened and leaked).
You forgot steel, the best mount material. On the copper radiator the mount sides are often steel, doesn't solder well, common failure point. Solid metal radiators suffer from vibration/flexing failures, cracking. At one time composite units were pretty poor, but have come a longways, why do all new cars come with them, like for three decades? The crimps, plastic, bolted design allows for the best materials to be used for each part, allows for flex, cushioning protection for the core.
Almost no one runs copper, so all common coolant is biased to aluminum, at the expense of solder. Often see solder bloom clogging, corrosion, thinning, failure of the solder joints. Copper can be more easily repaired, maybe, the last two we have taken in, the repair quote was way more than replacement, mainly due to overall solder loss.
The bottom line, all radiators are consumables, all are going to die. Fortunately they are now cheaper than ever, so not worth repairing. Plastic is much better than it was, likely not as durable as brass, but likely as good or better than solder. We work on older rigs, are seeing accelerated failure rate on their copper radiators, much more so than just a few years ago. For us, all but full classic restorations get replaced with aluminum.
Since the article admits BOTH radiators ultimately cool the same (though different in design) I chose to rid myself of easily broken plastic and seams that rely on a crimped metal part with a rubber seal.
Can, or if the advantages of aluminum are taken into the design, can be more efficient than copper. I don't need an article, we often travel with a caravan of '80's, most equipped with OBD2 gauges. As you say, depends on what you are trying to achieve, agree, in normal use not likely to note any difference. We travel in the desert, so fully stress them, one of the goals is to have as much capacity, efficiency as possible. A row of rigs, say a dozen, climbing ~8% grade at 110F and call the coolant numbers on the radio, the copper radiators are always the hottest, by a significant margin, repeatable, like every time, dealer or aftermarket. All of them have now swapped to aluminum, for this reason. The last one was a couple of months ago, the old radiator was in good condition, noted reduced temps, eliminated the pinging that it had, etc.