OEM Radiator Question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 28, 2015
Threads
79
Messages
834
Location
Tacoma, WA
I need to buy a new radiator and I'm wondering which one I should go with. From what I've read it seems that the radiators from 93-94 are brass/aluminum 3-core and then in 96-97 Toyota moved to aluminum/plastic 3-core. I have a 97 but I'm curious if the 93-94 radiator is:

A: Better cooling and more durable?
B: A drop in replacement in my 97? Did brackets or anything change other than material?

Thanks guys
 
I just replaced mine with the 93-94 version. Everyone has an opinion on which cools better but no real evidence. Mine was less than $400 and each model will fit any truck 93_97.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RFB
@ewillis, did your 93-94 OEM new buy version come with the gap foam by chance (to fill in the gaps around the rad to better direct airflow to the fan/engine)?
 
@ewillis, did your 93-94 OEM new buy version come with the gap foam by chance (to fill in the gaps around the rad to better direct airflow to the fan/engine)?
yep...and new brackets. Very well built, packaged, and quite heavy duty.
 
the aluminum version of our radiators cools better. While brass conducts heat better than aluminum, the solder used in manufacturing a brass radiator counters any potential benefit from the brass and makes it poorer performer.

I always use the Koyo variant when I replace a radiator.
 
IIRC, none of the current OEM-design radiators have metal tanks, they're all plastic.

Be sure to take care around those nipples or you will be sorry.
 
... Better cooling ...

Our experience, the least efficient are the brass units, all of them. The best, among the "disposable units" by a significant margin has been the TYC.

... more durable? ...

Likely dealer, but at the aftermarket price, see them as disposable, so don't really care. The Koyo seems, feels, slighter better than the TYC, but we have had two Koyos die, none of the TYC have died, yet. At ~$100ea, swap them as needed and always have a fresh core?:meh:
 
I faced this question recently. I have records on my truck going back to birth. The original rad lasted 16 years and 188k. The aftermarket (unknown brand) lasted 7 years and 67k. So, in my case, the OEM is worth it at twice the price. Just my $.02.
 
I faced this question recently. I have records on my truck going back to birth. The original rad lasted 16 years and 188k. The aftermarket (unknown brand) lasted 7 years and 67k. So, in my case, the OEM is worth it at twice the price. Just my $.02.

And we had a 2yr old dealer one die, lower tank seam split, out of warranty so no help. Swap in a new one and go.:meh:
 
Brass cools mine just fine, I will never have that plastic on mine again.

IF the aluminum is 'better' it must be by a mighty small margin.

CSF 2517
 
Just replaced my 93 brass alloy (heavy bugger!) with a lighter alloy plastic. From all the research i did its really comparing apples and oranges. The OEM version are sturdy as and may last a little longer than aftermarket but really just go grab yourself a Koyo alloy. cheap as chips and plenty of cooling capacity with trusty red toyo cooolant
 
I need to buy a new radiator and I'm wondering which one I should go with. From what I've read it seems that the radiators from 93-94 are brass/aluminum 3-core and then in 96-97 Toyota moved to aluminum/plastic 3-core. I have a 97 but I'm curious if the 93-94 radiator is:

A: Better cooling and more durable?
B: A drop in replacement in my 97? Did brackets or anything change other than material?

Thanks guys
My '94 had as the original radiator the plastic top unit. Could be that the production time of the build at the factory made a differnece in what radiator went into mine. I replaced mine at 180K miles due to leaks with aluminum/ brass after market unit from a local radiator supply house where I live. It works great and I have 241K on it now.
 
Here's a link to a web site that may answer some of your questions as to what's better.
Aluminum VS. Copper-Brass Radiator: Final Thoughts


"Better" of course depends on what you are trying to achieve, yes?

Thank you for the link, it contains some good information but I found the article seemingly biased toward 'Aluminum'.

I would remind everyone that when comparing an 'Aluminum' radiator to a Brass/Copper radiator (for an 80 series) you do NOT have a 100% Aluminum structure! The article you provided compares an ALL aluminum radiator against a Copper/Brass/Lead Solder radiator.

The radiator for an 80 series (and 100 series) is Aluminum, Plastic and Synthetic Rubber. The area I had trouble with in BOTH of my radiators was not with the aluminum. It was with the plastic caps (split) or the rubber seal (hardened and leaked).

Since the article admits BOTH radiators ultimately cool the same (though different in design) I chose to rid myself of easily broken plastic and seams that rely on a crimped metal part with a rubber seal.

The article did make some other points that were valid (less weight, less expense), but neither of those attributes were what I was looking for in a radiator.

So in the end, it is best....for the customer to do their own research, consider their needs and goals and then purchase accordingly.

Again, thank you for your contribution,

Flint.
 
I reread that article and my take on it was it was focusing on the core construction and the cores build differences and cooling ability. Personally I haven't seen any tank leaks on OEM of Koyo radiators, others yes but no those. But they were all brass units which don't stand up to our environment any where as good as aluminum.
 
I reread that article and my take on it was it was focusing on the core construction and the cores build differences and cooling ability. Personally I haven't seen any tank leaks on OEM of Koyo radiators, others yes but no those. But they were all brass units which don't stand up to our environment any where as good as aluminum.

But did you read the ENTIRE article? Most folks will not. Real all of it...and see if you don't detect a bias toward an aluminum radiator.

Aluminum VS. Copper-Brass Radiator: The Great Debate



Aluminum VS. Copper-Brass Radiator: Construction Differences



Aluminum VS. Copper-Brass Radiator: Corrosion Susceptibility



Aluminum VS. Copper-Brass Radiator: Price and Maintenance


They clearly are not talking only about the 'core'.


From their literature...Quote:

"That leaves us with an all aluminum two row radiator and a copper-brass/lead and tin soldered four row radiator. Why is the number of rows important? Take a closer look at these pictures of aluminum and copper-brass cores that we used in our previous discussion.

Since the wider aluminum tubes provider greater surface contact with the fins, it can conduct heat more efficiently than the copper-brass. The brass tubes and copper fins have significantly less contact between them due to the spacing between and curved edges of the tubes. So while copper may conduct heat better than aluminum, both the solder used in its construction and the decreased surface contact with the fins reduces the radiator’s ability to transfer heat. When you combine all of these factors together, the end result is that both a two row aluminum radiator and a four row copper-brass radiator have about the same cooling ability."

Even after disparaging the brass/copper radiator and making speculative claims (never any research cited), they finally admit BOTH units have about the same cooling ability. The brass/copper unit uses MORE material and different design to do that, so what?

I don't really care which radiator a person chooses. Just take the time to consider YOUR requirements and then purchase accordingly.

 
Back
Top Bottom