O2 Sensor Debug...

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 17, 2008
Threads
6
Messages
28
Location
Erie PA
I am trying to debug what I believe to be a combo of a bad O2 sensor and a plugged up cat.

96' LX-450. 151k Stock...
Are the 2 O2 sensors (One before and one after the 2 cats) interchangable? I believe my first one to be bad. The truck runs "rich" (strong exaust smell... poor gas milage) but it does not pull a check engine. (Could be bulb burnt out... ) I had the O2 sensor unplugged at one point and did not pull a check engine.
I also believe the first cat to be fairly clogged because it runs rough occasionally. Idles fine but at about 2k rpm on acceleration up inclines it will shimmey and shake sometimes. *Not all the time* feels like a back-pressure issue. Also it is not consistant. I am thinking of taking it off and punching a hole thru it to see if it runs better. If it does I know I have to do somthing with it.
Any help is appreciated..
Thanks,
Nick
 
I am trying to debug what I believe to be a combo of a bad O2 sensor and a plugged up cat.

96' LX-450. 151k Stock...
Are the 2 O2 sensors (One before and one after the 2 cats) interchangable? I believe my first one to be bad. The truck runs "rich" (strong exaust smell... poor gas milage) but it does not pull a check engine. (Could be bulb burnt out... ) I had the O2 sensor unplugged at one point and did not pull a check engine.
I also believe the first cat to be fairly clogged because it runs rough occasionally. Idles fine but at about 2k rpm on acceleration up inclines it will shimmey and shake sometimes. *Not all the time* feels like a back-pressure issue. Also it is not consistant. I am thinking of taking it off and punching a hole thru it to see if it runs better. If it does I know I have to do somthing with it.
Any help is appreciated..
Thanks,
Nick

Your check engine light should come on before you start your truck.
 
sparkplug,
With the keys in and on on( i think it is.. or acc cant remember) the check engine light does NOT come on.
 
The O2 sensors are different part numbers.
 
landcruising,
Thanks. Does that mean they will not function if they are swapped?
I am just looking for a quick check...
Thanks,
Nick
 
landcruising,
Thanks. Does that mean they will not function if they are swapped?
I am just looking for a quick check...
Thanks,
Nick

I think you will find those O2 sensors harder to swap than just going down to a Autozone, Pepboys, or any other car parts store and having them pull codes for you if your check engine light is not working.
 
When you first start your car, the check engine light should come on.

If it doesn't, you have a burnt out bulb.

Go get codes pulled from an auto parts store, and see if you have any.
 
I am trying to debug what I believe to be a combo of a bad O2 sensor and a plugged up cat.

96' LX-450. 151k Stock...
Are the 2 O2 sensors (One before and one after the 2 cats) interchangable? I believe my first one to be bad. The truck runs "rich" (strong exaust smell... poor gas milage) but it does not pull a check engine. (Could be bulb burnt out... ) I had the O2 sensor unplugged at one point and did not pull a check engine.
I also believe the first cat to be fairly clogged because it runs rough occasionally. Idles fine but at about 2k rpm on acceleration up inclines it will shimmey and shake sometimes. *Not all the time* feels like a back-pressure issue. Also it is not consistant. I am thinking of taking it off and punching a hole thru it to see if it runs better. If it does I know I have to do somthing with it.
Any help is appreciated..
Thanks,
Nick

I recently changed the O2 sensors on my LX. Although the physical O2 sensors appeared the same, one O2 sensor had a longer wire. This is due to the location of the connectors on the vehicle, in relation to where they are located on the exhaust and where they connect to the vehicle. That was the only physical difference I saw.
I was told by a mechanic that my Cats were bad. He said he conducted a temperature test for that analysis. However, after changing my O2 sensors (original sensors), cleaned EGR, VCV and vacum lines, I haven't had the CEL come back on. Lots of threads on here about that.
Although your O2 sensors may not correct the problem, they still may need to be changed (that's what C Dan told me).
 
Thanks,
It seems its hard to get the guys at autozone to understand the burnt out bulb issue...
Mike,
What issues did you have that led you to change the O2's other then the CEL? Anything you noticed when driving... etc?
 
Thanks,
It seems its hard to get the guys at autozone to understand the burnt out bulb issue...
Mike,
What issues did you have that led you to change the O2's other then the CEL? Anything you noticed when driving... etc?

The first O2 is checking the mixture (lean etc) the second checking if your cats are working.

When my front sensor went (they usually go at about 100,000miles) - in terms of driving I got this.......

idle - no problem - because the ECU doesn't reference the sensor

wide open throttle (WOT) - no problem because the petrol is dumped in and agin ECU not referenced

part throttle - ahh where it gets interesting - huge engine shudder, very poor or no acceleration, feels like the throttle is knackered - this is due to the ECU referencing a faulty signal from the O2 sensor. It doesn't know how much petrol to inject.

I could get some sort of normal operation only by blipping the throttle until it would start to accelerate smoothly.

NO ENGINE CODES THROWN DURING THIS TIME!

New TPS did not solve problem, garage took it back off at no charge (labour only). I fitted a new O2 sensor and completely resolved the issue.

Hope this helps - although you don't seem to have exactly the issues I had, they do sound similar (just re-read your post) constant acc. would always sort itself out
 
Last edited:
the second checking if your cats are working.

That is not the only thing it does. It also does long term fuel trim (LTFT). Wouldn't surprise me if there's other things it effects as well.
 
Thanks,
It seems its hard to get the guys at autozone to understand the burnt out bulb issue...
Mike,
What issues did you have that led you to change the O2's other then the CEL? Anything you noticed when driving... etc?

I spent a lot of time reading threads about the emissions and when I was told my CATS were bad I did more research.

After reseaching the threads the census was change your sensors at approx 100k. I was at 150k and mine looked like they were the original. Although I was aware this might not fix my 0401 code, it was something that needed to be done in order for the vehicle to run as it should. I didn't really have any idling issues, but I had nothing to compare it to.

I did it more as preventive maintenance, kind of a baseline after I got the vehicle. I can't say if changing the senors was the fix b/c I cleaned the EGR , VCV and hoses also. Maybe a combination of all three.
 
For what it's worth, Oxygen sensors are a "wear item" and the FSM recommends replacement at 80k miles (Both Schedule A and B in the Maintenance Section) . That, I am guessing is what CDan is alluding to. It's like a tune-up item. Your engine is using data from your sensors for fuel management. Bad data = bad management.

If they have never been done, it's way past time. As Mike says, it's a maintenance item.
 
Funny thing. My LX450 sat a good part of the summer because of a combination of an EGR code, an exhaust leak on the front O2 sensor, and rusted hangers on the muffler section. I fixed all with parts from CDAN and passed inspection about 3 weeks ago. Now, on the way home from work, another CEL. I just knew it was O2 and I was right.;-) I have 148000 on her and the O2 sensors looked original when I worked on the exhaust so I was expecting this. I was just surprised that it occurred so soon after the EGR and exhaust work.

I'll be calling Dan in the morning.
 
With 150k miles the cats are probably ready to be replaced. Cat's usually need replacement around 100k-150k miles on most vehicles. Depending on how you drive, what kinda gas you use, the condition of the motor, etc...

If it was me, I'd fix the check engine light first. Change both cats after that. And IF you're getting a check engine light after you replace the cat's then start looking at other things like O2 sensors, vacuum hoses, EGR valve, etc...
 
With 150k miles the cats are probably ready to be replaced. Cat's usually need replacement around 100k-150k miles on most vehicles. Depending on how you drive, what kinda gas you use, the condition of the motor, etc...

If it was me, I'd fix the check engine light first. Change both cats after that. And IF you're getting a check engine light after you replace the cat's then start looking at other things like O2 sensors, vacuum hoses, EGR valve, etc...

FWIW my second cat is nearly perfectly clear. There are a few "cells" that are plugged, but on the order of 1% or so. This is with ~150k.


The cats on the 80's are very large for their purpose. While the 100k-150k rule might hold true for other vehicles, I wouldn't automatically apply that here.
 
FWIW my second cat is nearly perfectly clear. There are a few "cells" that are plugged, but on the order of 1% or so. This is with ~150k.


The cats on the 80's are very large for their purpose. While the 100k-150k rule might hold true for other vehicles, I wouldn't automatically apply that here.

There's always the option of just unbolting them and inspecting them. Takes just a few minutes.
 
That is not the only thing it does. It also does long term fuel trim (LTFT). Wouldn't surprise me if there's other things it effects as well.

You sure about that?

I'm in the UK - we do not have the second O2 sensor fitted after the cats as there is no Government requirement (sniff tests etc)

I thought the second O2 was more a California (and a few other states) kind of thing?!?

So either my truck (ok, ECU) doesn't have any idea about LTFT or......
 
Curious.

From what I've read on MUD, yes, it does. Look at LT's MAF mod there, there is a lot of discussion on it in there.

How is your rear O2 sensor harness terminated?
 
Back
Top Bottom