Let's play whats that engine noise....

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 7, 2005
Threads
92
Messages
3,726
I think I've got a connecting rod bearing goin south on my 97 lx450. Got 240k on the odo. Head gasket, valve seals, fuel injectors, radiator, TB cleaning, etc was done last Feb. I cant say how long the noise has been there, because from the inside you can barely hear it over the radio :D, and my daughter has been driving it over the winter. Motor performance has not degraded, and oil pressure is fine.



How difficult is it to replace the con rod bearings from underneath while the motor is still in the truck?

Here are my options:

1. Replace the con rod bearings from underneath, and see if it goes away. Look inside both oil pans for any other bad junk that would indicate a problem.

2. Pull the motor and have it rebuilt. If I were to go that route, it would be the full meal deal, and I'm sure would get spendy. I dont have the tools, time, and talent to do it myself.

3. Source a rebuilt motor and swap it in. Again, probably spending given the rarity compared to other platforms.

4. Write a big check, and have an LS heart transplant.

5. Upgrade to a 2006-07 LX470 and park the 450 while I figure out options.


Feel free to throw out some armchair diagnosing.
 
You forgot this option:

0.5) Leave it alone

Your list looks like it is organized in a best to worst case or $ to $$$$$ format. So I have numbered the above option to where I think it should fit.

Have you tried a heavier oil? I mean seriously I wouldn't do a damn thing with it, save up money for a complete rebuild eventually don't throw money at a sound just because its a sound.

In all likelihood if properly maintained I would bet that engine will keep chugging along well into the 300k's
 
I think I've got a connecting rod bearing goin south on my 97 lx450. Got 240k on the odo. Head gasket, valve seals, fuel injectors, radiator, TB cleaning, etc was done last Feb. I cant say how long the noise has been there, because from the inside you can barely hear it over the radio :D, and my daughter has been driving it over the winter. Motor performance has not degraded, and oil pressure is fine.

It doesn't sound that bad to me. I would try this: Get a used spark plug. Now unplug cylinder #1 spark plug and put the used spark plug on it, set it on something metal, this gives a path for the spark to dissipate. Start the motor and see if the sound is gone. If not, re-connect #1 and try #2. Do this for all six cylinders or until the sound goes away. If the sound does not go away, it probably isn't conn rod issue. Without firing, there is very little pressure to make the sound, so if you isolate it in this way it tells you several things, #1 that it actually IS a conn rod problem, #2 which cylinder it is on, #3 if the sound doesn't go away on any cylinder, it is probably something else.

You'll find videos of people doing this on youtube (search troubleshoot rod knock) and they just grab leads and disconnect them while it's running. I'm not a fan of 20K volts, so I tend to do it one cylinder at a time, and I also like to make sure that voltage has somewhere to go instead of chancing it bouncing around in the distributor and into igniters and other circuitry it doesn't belong.
 
Last edited:
I've had the same sounding noise.. it drives me nuts but the truck runs GREAT. No loss of acceleration.. that being said it makes me nervous driving it into the middle of nowhere.. I've been told it may run like this for a long time and basically to not worry about it. I've driven it this way for 1500+ miles.. love to know what you figure out if u dig into it a little further.
 
Sorry for not being to constructive with my last post but I have a cheap stethoscope that I use for certain noises. I have mine insulated with some latex because it is too sensitive normally. I also use long vacuum hose with one end at the ear and the other floating around the area I think noise is coming from. Between using the two...I can get close. Then I start investigating that area and normally discover the problem. I have seen people put a camera in the cylinders for bearing noises and they crank the motor by hand. If the bearing is really bad they can see the play in the piston travel while feeling the motion and applied pressure to crank.
 
Thanks for the replies. Im going to do some more diagnosing. Got a stethescope and will poke around some more too.

My plan for the weekend:
1. listen for the easy stuff, idler pulley, ac compressor, power steering pump. It would be nice if it were one of those.
2. Pull 1 spark plug at a time, and see if I can isolate it to a particular cyl.
3. Change oil to thicker weight, change filter. Filter is new napa gold 1515 (2 weeks old, i dont think i'll get anywhere there).
4. mount my gopro under the hood and take a drive.
5. post up new video for more armcharing.
6. Go to the local ONSC LC Club dinner Tuesday night and let those guys listen to it.
 
You can pull the idler pulley completely to eliminate that option. Just reinstall the bolt as it serves as a plug as well

My guess is if the power steering pump has not been off, or more accurately if the gear has not been off the pump shaft, then my guess is that is not your noise

2 and six seem like solid options.

And what is the status/age of your belts. I had a terrible knocking develope come Ming home after GSMTR and feared the worst. Was blown away all that racket was made by a bad acc drive belt. New belt and all better. Just use oem here or at very least don't use a cogged belt but belts from mr t are reasonable $
 
you can definitely replace con-rod bearings in the truck provided the rods and crank are in good shape, but I would be suspect that is the problem. sounds like you take great care of your truck and those bearings are robust. I inherited a 80 with a suspected con-rod bearing noise, did the bearings in the driveway during a snowstorm, and they were fine. was just the power steering pump gear ticking against the intermediate shaft gear.
 
@quasi had your power steering gear been off the pump shaft before?

Just trying to learn and make sure I gave good info before. Just had not heard of this pump developing the tick without the gear being off and back in. Usually the issue from the gear being pressed too far on, or not far enough. Good to know if it can happen otherwise.
 
Power steering pump hasnt been off it that I'm aware of, unless it was removed during the HG repair last year. Belts are oem, maybe 12-18 months old. tension doesnt seem to be too tight. Ive only used oem belts.

If it werent pourin down rain, Id slip under and pull the idler pulley.

Noise seems to be louder from the passenger side than drivers side and low, which might be the idler pulley. Maybe I'll get lucky...
 
Low pass side would also warrant listening to the ac compressor/clutch/pulley as well.
 
Power steering pump hasnt been off it that I'm aware of, unless it was removed during the HG repair last year. Belts are oem, maybe 12-18 months old. tension doesnt seem to be too tight. Ive only used oem belts.

If it werent pourin down rain, Id slip under and pull the idler pulley.

Noise seems to be louder from the passenger side than drivers side and low, which might be the idler pulley. Maybe I'll get lucky...

Tuesday is on your calendar? If so we'll give it a listen.
Rice
 
If it werent pourin down rain, Id slip under and pull the idler pulley...

I can fold up my garage and loan it to you if you need :D may be easier to swing by a DIY car wash for a dry space though. Both idlers can be out in a few minutes.
image.webp


Bring it out to dinner if you can make it or send a message and I'll swing by if you can't.
 
Man, water was overpowerin our gutters, our yard, and the streets out front for about 30 mins what that nice chunk of yellow and red passed over. i was stuck on a conf call with one dog asleep (the little one that wouldnt care if we were being carpet bombed), and the 75 lb scaredy cat border collie. he was shaking, running around the house trying to find his happy place......that was after 2 benedryl this morning, and 2 at lunchtime for him. Thank goodness there was no thunder an lightning, or I'd be cleaning the carpets. Wife and daughter were goin window to window telling me how much i need to clean out gutters... LOL

I definitely plan on coming Tuesday. I'll drive it. Cant drink beer, but I can eat a big giant burger and onion rings from Mack's.

I appreciate all the help. You get spoiled driving an 80 series...up til my HG last year, the only other big ticket item mine has needed was a birf job that my daughter and I knocked out in the garage with the FSM and Romers birf thread.
 
why not take the belts off the truck and see what it sounds like? takes only a few minutes. will tell you really quick if it is something internal or an accessory.
 
thats the plan for the weekend. That silly thing called work keeps gettin in the way. I get behind, cause guys named Chris call me when I'm supposed to be working and get to talking about Land Cruisers, 4runners, and Sequoias.... Ever had that hapen? :grinpimp:
 
i know right, who would do such a thing :flipoff2:

let me know what you find out. weather is looking sunny and cool for the weekend so i might stuff that engine in if you dont buy it lol.
 
Back
Top Bottom