Koyo vs CSF - another rad thread

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 4, 2011
Threads
22
Messages
209
After watching so much discussion about radiators, I thought I would add my recent experience going from a Koyo 1917 to a CSF 2715.

First up Koyo. 7 years ago I had to replace the rad in my '94. Went on EBay and luckily chose the Koyo - this was prior to my exposure the excellent advice of this forum. The rad performed flawlessly even after the accident that forced its replacement.

First pics are of the truck after the accident.

image-2681875746.webp

Anyway, fan was pushed into the radiator and radiator was bent. I love the truck so I decided to fix her - replaced or fixed just about everything from the water pump housing forward.

Here are pics of the removed Koyo


image-2146454412.webp

Under the direction and wisdom of ACC here in Atl I decided to run the CSF 2715. The point of this thread was for me to first sing the paise of the Koyo. I remain impressed that the Koyo managed to survive the accident bent and leak free. I think it is a super solid radiator almost as tuff as the 80 itself. Personally, I also like the plastic top section over the metal top of the CSF (keeps me from continuously burning myself when I inevitably rest my hand there-I never seem to learn any better).

In comparison, the brass CSF seems lighter and in general more delicate, certainly more delicate on install. I was disappointed that when I installed the CSF I also needed a new cap and prior to getting one some coolant escaped and removed the black finish on the top of the rad. Trivial, yes but annoying that it was so easy to do.

Overall, it appears that the CSF has better cooling capabilities but I also have to say that the temp differences I'm seeing could be associated with the fan clutch oil being replaced with 10k cst.

The main reason I went with the CSF is, to my understanding, that it is more easily repaired by a rad shop if it does develop a leak. Either way both rads are great and just wanted to spew fodder on the great and never-ending radiator debate.
image-3837485989.webp
image-2681875746.webp
image-4071696747.webp
image-127582611.webp
image-2146454412.webp
 
Yeah, we'll see if it stands the test of time. I hope you are wrong though.
 
Koyo is better
But I have CSF replacement in my 80 and it has been fine for the last 3 years or so far.:meh:
 
My experience was from quite a few years ago. Started leaking like a sieve from too many places to even bother getting it repaired.

I won't touch them, but maybe/hopefully their quality has gone up over time.
 
Anyone want to stand up for the CSF? Beginning to wish I went with another Koyo.
 
Bueler...Bueler...anyone else?
 
Just run what you have you will be fine
I lot of the folks on here are going to poo poo the CSF rad
If you have it installed you cant return now it anyway
 
Can I link back to this thread when people ask what a Damage Multiplier is?
 
I installed a Koyo a few weeks ago and that will be what I use from now on. And for the price of it I can't see even considering the inability of repairing the rad as a deterrent.

Agreed. I've been very pleased with my Koyo replacement I installed last October.
 
Anyone want to stand up for the CSF? Beginning to wish I went with another Koyo.


CSF in mine...no problems at all. And the model # is 2517 by the way.

No more plastic crap for me.
 
Had a csf in mine had that is until at some point me or my son dropped a socket into the shroud. I didn't know that's life anyway it bounced up into the fan and well you can guess what happened 5 tubes ruined. I tried to find a shop to repair thinking hey it's brass. Uh no closest shop was 2 hours away and in another state. Point is radiator repair is a dying art , people just toss old rad and get new nowadays.I finally conceited to the fact that it as gonna cost at least a hundred bucks our more to ship and have it repaired plus the wait time while my rig was down. It's my dd and couldn't wait 2 weeks. Stop leak in until my koyo came in and took a week to get here. Love it will buy a koyo again cools fine and It's lighter and cheaper. My 02
 
Running the CSF 2517 for 14 months now and it's perfectly fine. I'm no radiator expert but the CSF looks robust right out of the box. The fit was dead on. CSF is supposedly an oem supplier and not just some second rate replacement supplier.

The whole point of getting the CSF was to ditch the plastic radiator tanks. Not to mention, copper transfers heat nearly twice as efficiently as aluminum. I don't think many people know that auto manufactures went to aluminum in order to save weight not because it has magical cooling powers.
 
Last edited:
It's decision time for me, the OEM radiator in my 1996 FZJ80 developed a hairline crack in the top plastic tank. Not bad, 20+ years and 353,000 miles. Holding it together (barely) for the last few months using multiple layers of woven fiberglass fabric and two part epoxy for reinforcement. I figure if I install another TRAD it should last another 20 years, maybe longer if they've developed a better plastic since the original radiator was produced.
 
I did right here runnning it with out any problems
you will be fine


Just looked at my receipt and I put my 2517 radiator in my 80 series in March of 2013, so its been over 4 years and its still doing great. CSF is NOT a cheap aftermarket radiator folks.

I also put one in my LX470 about 6 months ago instead of going with a Denso. It is doing just fine.
 
Back
Top Bottom