Head work- $980!!!!!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I local dismantler had a whole engine (~120k mi) for $700 he offered me, and that was before bargaining. I'd tell the guy that you live paycheck to paycheck and since he said $500ish you were thinking no more than $650, and that's all you have in the bank. If he plays hardball you will likely win in small claims court.
 
Bit shocked when the machine shop called and the bill for my valve grind and head work is WAY more than quoted. Says he had to deck the head a bit and setting the valves was a bitch, seems like I may have picked the wrong shop..........
Or I am over reacting!

Cheers P

Who did the work?


Might as well spill the beans so others aren't burned by the same a-hole.
 
I provided the parts, no new valves. He asked me to re-install the cams so he could check and verify teh valve clearance. i told him the mud community recommends a valve grind and tip the valves to stay in spec.
He verbally quoted the 500 over the phone so I have no written or email quote and that is on me, im used to my word and your word meaning something. This is the only machine shop in south eastern BC and has a rep for quality, owned and operated by a classic old timer, hence I am surprised on the no call for the change.
Im not surprised it was difficult as he installed and reinstalled the cams to recheck specs ( not sure at all why he did it this way). Any way, now that im over the shock I will call him tomorrow to if nothing else let him know Im shocked at the change and see what happens from there, obviously he has the power here as the head is in his possession, along with the valve cover, upper intake and my FSM!!!
I just feel kind a stupid for not being more carefull on understanding the cost, if he had said it could be up to a grand with this and that I would have priced out taking it to a bigger center where there are more shops to see if it was worthwhile.
Just dissapointed at the moment
 
Around $500 means $450-550.00 to me all day long. I wish there was a simple answer. Sorry I hope he sees where your coming from. Ask him if a supplier told him his product would be around $500 and then he gets hit with a $980 bill. He would he expect the supplier to honor his quote.

Quote $500 =100%
Cost $980 =196% of the quote
That's a 96% increase over the quote.

That's expecting allot of fluff.

Good luck tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
on what planet? $1k for a head re-surface and valve adjustment is a highway robbery. Most folks pay $350~500 for this. The shop said it was 'harder than expected'. Tough nuggets. Maybe they shouldn't be running a machine shop.

well put, they are taking advantage of you......
 
He verbally quoted the 500 over the phone so I have no written or email quote and that is on me, im used to my word and your word meaning something.

I'm no lawyer or anything but in Georgia a contract can be written or oral. Depending on the state, after receiving an estimate, the cost cannot be more than 10% higher than the original estimate.
 
I was quoted between 800-900 by several shops in Houston.
 
These situations always stem from bad communication and mostly from a customer not knowing what the job entails and then comes back with "internet knowledge". Understand the job, ask the right questions and then you won't end up in this situation. Not defending the shop, but there are a lot of things involved here. People have to see the other side of coin as well.

If they did a valve job and cut the valves and seats, then the valves would have seated more, so the stems would be too long. So they have to grind the stems. This is a hit and miss as to getting the valve clearances right with the shims. If they don' t have access to a set of shims, then they have to remove, recut and reinstall the valves a number of times.

Maybe they did underquote the job and should have been more precise, but maybe his around $500 has a little broader meaning vs yours. Did you ask for a re-quote if things would appear to be more, or did you leave with the impression you just want the job done and done right?

Comparing with what other people pay or a forum says is irrelevant. It has to do with the instructions you gave and the expectation that was set. Discuss with the owner, make sure you want him to be compensated for the work he did, but you are a little surprised at the final bill. Learn from it and don't go in guns blazing saying the internet says it should cost you $400 to do the job. If the work was done to a quality standard it is fair to compensate him for the work. You can pay a little for the education experience and he can suck up a little for the learning time if he did not know the time it takes on a 1FZ head.
 
Christo i get what you are saying but if the owner f*cked up and he did not know the work involved in doing this how is it the customer's fault? Sounds like he should be the one getting a learning experience, no? If I under bid a remodel then it's my fault not the customer I am expert and should know what is involved.

The owner messed up twice one with the under bid and twice with not calling about the additional costs. He should at least meet you halfway between the original bid and the new total.
 
Last edited:
....mostly from a customer not knowing what the job entails and then comes back with "internet knowledge"..... Maybe they did underquote the job and should have been more precise, but maybe his around $500 has a little broader meaning vs yours. ...... You can pay a little for the education experience and he can suck up a little for the learning time if he did not know the time it takes on a 1FZ head.

It's not up to the customer to know how much work is entailed. He stated the job he needed done. The shop should know how long it takes. If they don't it's their problem and they'll know for future work. Charging double what you quoted isn't acceptable to any reasonable person. The only person that should be "paying for the education experience" is the shop. Maybe the customer would have chosen a different shop based on an accurate estimate.

Christo i get what you are saying but if the owner f*cked up and he did not know the work involved in doing this how is it the customer's fault? Sounds like he should be the one getting a learning experience, no? If I under bid a remodel then it's my fault not the customer I am expert and should know what is involved.

The owner messed up twice one with the under bid and twice with not calling about the additional costs. He should at least meet you halfway between the original bid and the new total.


Exactly my thoughts. I think we've all underbid a job a time or two. You learn from it and move on... not screw the customer.
 
So if I called up a certain shop and asked them how much a 4" lift would be for my Land Cruiser and they said "you're looking at about $1000". I say great, here's my ccard, please ship to my address.
3 days later I get a box full of parts for my 4" lift along with a copy of my receipt which says I paid $2000, guess who would be getting a box of parts shipped back to them:D
Explaining after the fact that 4" lift requires a lot more parts than originally thought wouldn't cut it, I am not the expert:p
 
He knew he needed to get his head done. He asked around and got the new parts together. Next he called the professional who does rebuilding heads for a living and explains what new parts he has and then askes for a quote. The professional quotes around $500 (which really means $450-550 plus tax closer to $550).

He drops it off and then gets hit with 196% of the original quote.

That's like calling up Toyota and ordering a new all black Land Cruiser. They tell you we'll order one in for you for around $68,000.00. It comes in and they tell you oh the black ones cost more because there harder to order in your cost is $133,280 plus tax of course.


196% of the quote? How is that ever reasonable to expect almost double?
 
Excellent conversation! I appreciate Christo and his comment and have some parts from his shop on my truck.
My biggest issue is the no call when things got out of hand, several of the posters have mentioned much higher quotes and some of the proffessionals have mentioned that it could cost a grand and one poster quoted a shop book expecting 18.5 hours for the job, and Im sure shop time is a lot closer to $50 an hour than $30 an hour. And Christo is right, I am not an expert I am a customer and have to rely on an expert to tell me what is needed and how much it will cost.
I am sure some of the headwork done on members trucks was different than what happened here, I just hope he did an excellent job, Hope for some relief on this when I talk to him, or at least a better explanation.
Kind of soured me on the whole experience which i was quite enjoying
 
I am sure some of the headwork done on members trucks was different than what happened here

Which would be what, exactly?

What you describe sounds like the typical head service job. You pull the head from your truck, and take it to a machine shop. You have them clean the head and do all the testing to ensure it's in good shape, then resurface/deck as needed. You ask for a full valve adjustment, AKA 'valve grind' and have them install the new valve seals which you provided as it comes with the OEM gasket kit. They grind the valves/seats and tip the stems so they are within spec.

At then end of the day it's your money, I'm just curious what that guy did differently. This standard job runs $300~500 as you've seen from multiple posts. I really doubt he's doing some strange wizardry different than every other machine shop in the world that warrants double the price. You're getting hosed, simple as that :)
 
Its against the law in my state to bill more than 10% without notification.

A head rebuild quote is not the same as a 1FZ-FE head rebuild quote. If he just quoted a generic head rebuild without knowing what it was, I could certainly see this happening, although he should have called to clarify. My machine shop did when he saw "the biggest 4 valve aluminum head I've ever seen"

A full valve adjustment is in no way the same as a valve grind. A valve grind does not equal valve stem guide replacement either. They are different jobs. All of these jobs is especially difficult on a 1FZ head. Twice as many valves and bucket and shim adjusters that require installation and removal of the cams, sometimes multiple times. Also if you don't have the assortment of Toyota shims on hand you have to order them. Not all of them are available. I had to make some on the last 1FZ head I did. Nothing is easy.

If you kept calling and giving him additional instructions, I could easily see him just saying OK and adding to the bill. That would qualify as approving additional work.

Tipping the valve stems is part of a valve grind.
 
Last edited:
Here's my quote, for what it's worth

picsay-1366302423_zps8b45aaea.jpg
 
Its against the law in my state to bill more than 10% without notification.

Yes, same here, and in our shop I would call the customer to talk it over. I don't want to discuss that issue here. All I want to point out is that there are two sides to the story.

What I want to point out is that you catch more flies with honey than vinegar. Discuss the concerns with the shop. And BOTH sides should ask more questions. If you call a machine shop and as for a head surfacing and valve adjust on a Toyota inline 6 head, they might have assumed an older style head with adjustments that can be made. Yes, bad on their part. Then you drop off a 24 valve head with buckets and shims and the ball game changes.

A head rebuild quote is not the same as a 1FZ-FE head rebuild quote. If he just quoted a generic head rebuild without knowing what it was, I could certainly see this happening, although he should have called to clarify. My machine shop did when he saw "the biggest 4 valve aluminum head I've ever seen"

Yes, that is my point so that people that read this can get some info out of this vs. just a pissing match about pricing. Explain what you have, explain what you want and make sure you know what you are explaining. You are assuming the shop is a professional shop, and they probably are, with anything than a 1FZ. Make sure the shops knows they are going to be dealing with something unusual. If they then tell you, head we are pro's and we know what we are dealing with, and it comes in different, then they have to suck it up.

A full valve adjustment is in no way the same as a valve grind. A valve grind does not equal valve stem guide replacement either. They are different jobs. All of these jobs is especially difficult on a 1FZ head. Twice as many valves and bucket and shim adjusters that require installation and removal of the cams, sometimes multiple times. Also if you don't have the assortment of Toyota shims on hand you have to order them. Not all of them are available. I had to make some on the last 1FZ head I did. Nothing is easy.

Exactly. That is why it is important for customers to know what they are asking the shop to do. And also why it is important to know how to compare apples to apples.

The quote listed above is a quote for valve adjust. Which means, read the caps, replace / swap shims if needed. Valve job is really vague. Does that include lapping the valves, grinding valve seats & valves, install new valve stem seals? If you took that quote and you assumed that all the above is included and you got it back and it was not done, how would you argue that?

If you kept calling and giving him additional instructions, I could easily see him just saying OK and adding to the bill. That would qualify as approving additional work.

Tipping the valve stems is part of a valve grind.

Yes, that is what I am trying to say as well. You call and ask for a head inspection and cleaning / surfacing. Again, these situations are due to bad communications on both parts.
 
What you describe sounds like the typical head service job. You pull the head from your truck, and take it to a machine shop. You have them clean the head and do all the testing to ensure it's in good shape

What does this mean? Is it pressure tested, magnafluxed, just measured for straightness. Be specific in request, and if unsure, ask what the "testing" includes. Various charges for each item. I am pretty sure there are very few machine shops that have the plates to actually pressure test a 1FZFE head.

, then resurface/deck as needed.

That is about the only simple thing, with the caveat that you spec how much is the max they can remote.

You ask for a full valve adjustment, AKA 'valve grind'

Valve adjust is not AKA a "valve grind". Valve grind is something different that requires a valve adjust after the fact. "Valve grind" has all kinds of issues with it in terms of angles etc etc. And how to set the valve clearance is also dependent on cutting the stems or / and having shims available to get it back in spec.

and have them install the new valve seals which you provided as it comes with the OEM gasket kit. They grind the valves/seats and tip the stems so they are within spec.

Again, don't assume the valve stems will be replaced unless ask for it. Be specific, that way you are assured of getting what you want.

At then end of the day it's your money, I'm just curious what that guy did differently. This standard job runs $300~500 as you've seen from multiple posts. I really doubt he's doing some strange wizardry different than every other machine shop in the world that warrants double the price. You're getting hosed, simple as that :)

Apples are not oranges :)

For the record, the price is not out of line what we would pay a very good machine shop that we use for a full "head reconditioning" as we specify it.
 
The quote listed above is a quote for valve adjust. Which means, read the caps, replace / swap shims if needed. Valve job is really vague. Does that include lapping the valves, grinding valve seats & valves, install new valve stem seals? If you took that quote and you assumed that all the above is included and you got it back and it was not done, how would you argue that?

I discussed this with the owner of the shop as he was writing up my quote. He said they do the full valve grind; lapping valves & seats and tipping the stems until they are within spec. He said they don't mess with the shims because they're expensive and hard to find and it would be impossible for him to stock every shim size out there.

New valve seals will be installed which I provided.

A week later he called me and said the exhaust valve guides were slightly out of spec. He said they would be fine as is, but if I wanted them replaced it would be an extra $120 for parts and labor. THAT is how an honest shop operates. Not giving one price then charging double when the job is all of the sudden finished.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom