Head work- $980!!!!!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Apples are not oranges :)

And that's what I'm trying to figure out. What are these mysterious "oranges" you guys speak of? Some say $1k is a normal price but what does it include? What do you get? What's different about a $500 head job vs a $1000 head job?

The expensive part is the valve job aka grind aka adjustment aka lapping aka grinding, whatever. At the end of the day the end result should be the same right? Valves adjusted to spec in accordance with the FSM. How can a machine shop worth its salt do a valve grind without checking the valves for adjustment too? Wouldn't that result in problems?
 
Last edited:
I discussed this with the owner of the shop as he was writing up my quote. He said they do the full valve grind; lapping valves & seats and tipping the stems until they are within spec. He said they don't mess with the shims because they're expensive and hard to find and it would be impossible for him to stock every shim size out there.

New valve seals will be installed which I provided.

A week later he called me and said the exhaust valve guides were slightly out of spec. He said they would be fine as is, but if I wanted them replaced it would be an extra $120 for parts and labor. THAT is how an honest shop operates. Not giving one price then charging double when the job is all of the sudden finished.

Your explanation in conjunction with the paper quote makes sense. However assuming what you wrote above to be all included in the one line on the estimate would be a bad thing.
 
And that's what I'm trying to figure out. What are these mysterious "oranges" you guys speak of? Some say $1k is a normal price but what does it include? What do you get? What's different about a $500 head job vs a $1000 head job?

California vs Nebraska :)

The expensive part is the valve job aka grind aka adjustment aka lapping aka grinding, whatever. At the end of the day the end result should be the same right? Valves adjusted to spec in accordance with the FSM. How can a machine shop worth it's salt do a valve grind without checking the valves for adjustment too? Wouldn't that result in problems?

You can't do a grind without an adjust, but you can do an adjust without a grind or valve lap. Not saying that 2nd is not like showering and putting on dirty underwear, but it can be done.
 
You can't do a grind without an adjust, but you can do an adjust without a grind or valve lap. Not saying that 2nd is not like showering and putting on dirty underwear, but it can be done.

Ok that's what I figured. Which is typically more expensive and more time consuming? Valve adjust using shims per the FSM or grind/adjust to get within spec? I found this old thread which has some good discussion: https://forum.ih8mud.com/80-series-tech/267180-valve-job-adjustment-tipping-vs-shim-replacement.html

Speaking of the devil, machine shop just called me, head is done :clap: $590 out the door with new valve guides on the exhaust side. Time to get this thing running again!
 
And that's what I'm trying to figure out. What are these mysterious "oranges" you guys speak of? Some say $1k is a normal price but what does it include? What do you get? What's different about a $500 head job vs a $1000 head job?

The expensive part is the valve job aka grind aka adjustment aka lapping aka grinding, whatever. At the end of the day the end result should be the same right? Valves adjusted to spec in accordance with the FSM. How can a machine shop worth it's salt do a valve grind without checking the valves for adjustment too? Wouldn't that result in problems?

I just looked at the receipt from the last 1HDT head job that cost me about $900 at a top machine shop in the San Diego area.
They

removed everything from the head
magnafluxed it
cleaned it, with brushing all passages
checked all valves, ground them as necessary, replaced 2
changed all valve seals, stems, all to spec
checked all springs for correct tension
checked the head for warping, planeness in all areas, planed it, including the manifold areas, polished the area
put all back together

You asked me quite impolitely on which planet that should cost about 1k, as it should be $300 to $500. Well, it's in southern California. Good for you if you can get all of that done for much less. I'd question the quality of the job.
There seems to be quite some variation, live with it.
 
Ok that's what I figured. Which is typically more expensive and more time consuming? Valve adjust using shims per the FSM or grind/adjust to get within spec? I found this old thread which has some good discussion: https://forum.ih8mud.com/80-series-tech/267180-valve-job-adjustment-tipping-vs-shim-replacement.html

Valve grind with valve stems cut is going to be more. You grind the valves and the seats, then either figure out how much you need to take off the stem to get it back in spec, or assemble the head, measure clearances and then go from there. So now you either cut the stems again, or swap shims until it is right. Or a combination of the items done.

It is not easy to determine how much to cut from the step based on how much was taken off the valve seat and valve itself.

As for adjusting, if you only have adjust a couple, you can do it with the cams in the head and use a special tool to remove the shims. If you have to do a lot it might be easier to remove the cams.

That all said, when that is all done, it is done with the head not on the block. If you receive your head back and all the clearances was checked, you should do so again after the head is installed to make sure they are still the same.
 
To be perfectly clear, when I called the shop I spoke with the actual machinist / owner / operator.
I specifically discussed it as a 4.5 L double over head cam aluminum 6 cyliinder head from a toyota Landcruiser lx450 1997, that is 24 valves, bucket and shim.
I asked for a valve grind, and I would provide new stem seals. If guides or valves where messed please let me now. Also check for cracks and flatness, pressure test and clean.
I told him it was dismantled with the cams off, he asked that I re-install the cams and caps ( not torqued)
I offered to lend him my FSM so he had all the specs. I was told to expect around $500. Again my beef is that if he found it difficult, and I believe it was, and I believe it was done right as he had to remove and install the cams a number of times to get the valves back in spec. Imagine removing valves and regrinding ( springs and retainers?)several times and I can see how the time would add up.
Just should have called me and said 'hey this is a bigger job than i thought'
 
I'd question the quality of the job.
There seems to be quite some variation, live with it.

That's quite the assumption and based on nothing but dollars alone. I went to a reputable shop recommended by several local members (norcal). Just because you paid more doesn't mean the work is better. It just means you paid more. Like you say, there seems to be quite some variation, live with it ;)
 
And that's what I'm trying to figure out. What are these mysterious "oranges" you guys speak of? Some say $1k is a normal price but what does it include? What do you get? What's different about a $500 head job vs a $1000 head job?

The expensive part is the valve job aka grind aka adjustment aka lapping aka grinding, whatever. At the end of the day the end result should be the same right? Valves adjusted to spec in accordance with the FSM. How can a machine shop worth its salt do a valve grind without checking the valves for adjustment too? Wouldn't that result in problems?


Depends on the part of town. I've seen $50 head jobs, but you may not want one. Quality.


Oh wait. Wrong head job.
 
Depends on the part of town. I've seen $50 head jobs, but you may not want one. Quality.


Oh wait. Wrong head job.

So how much was it to watch?:grinpimp:
 
Christo, thank you. I wanted to clear up the assumption i had just dropped off the head without any thought or planning. I have actually been working up to this job since my HG went about 2.5 months ago. Taking my time with disassembly and the 'while you are in there' stuff.

Cheers P

PS- I have not called him yet as I wanted to better understand the situation and be in a better frame of mind, want to avoid the whole baby and the bath water go postal kind of thing
 
I just looked at the receipt from the last 1HDT head job that cost me about $900 at a top machine shop in the San Diego area.
They

removed everything from the head
magnafluxed it
cleaned it, with brushing all passages
checked all valves, ground them as necessary, replaced 2
changed all valve seals, stems, all to spec
checked all springs for correct tension
checked the head for warping, planeness in all areas, planed it, including the manifold areas, polished the area
put all back together

You asked me quite impolitely on which planet that should cost about 1k, as it should be $300 to $500. Well, it's in southern California. Good for you if you can get all of that done for much less. I'd question the quality of the job.
There seems to be quite some variation, live with it.

Jan:
May I ask which shop this was? Did you like their work? I am local to you. Thanks.



Bogart:
It sounds like you did the right things and were quite clear in what you had, and what you wanted. You could have demanded a written estimate, but the real world does not always work this way. The shop should have called you as soon as the job got substantially sideways time-wise. He probably did have to spend a lot of time on it, but it was not your responsibility to know that he might not know how hard it was going to be when he gave you an estimate. I understand Christo's original points, as I used to manage a few repair shops (for bicycles though, but the need to call first still applies). Maybe he forgot what his estimate was, got caught up in the job, whatever... He probably is generally an expert, hopefully did good work, and should be compensated fairly, but he should have called you first.

The suggestion regarding honey vs. vinegar is a good one. From your posts it does not sound like you plan (or want) to go postal. Call him and ask when would be good time to come in and talk to him. Then go in and calmly ask him to explain what he did and how long it took. Then consider his hourly rate. Then ask him then to put himself in your shoes considering what you were expecting to pay per his estimate, your clarity upfront, and that he failed to call you (and the lack of mistakes on your end). Now you have two dollar amounts in front of you. Ask him if he should have called you (he needs to say yes to this...). That was his big mistake here. Then ask him if he could work with you on the price. A discount on his hourly rate is in order since he failed to call; it is not reasonable that he should still get his full hourly rate in this case. Have in mind what you think is fair, and then ask for and defend that point.

Then please report back.

Thanks,

Jon
 
^^ This.

If the shop stands firm on the price, you may want to try to talk about terms of payment, perhaps you can pay the estimated $500 up front, and then make a couple of payments in a few weeks time? Bring your chequebook and make some post-dated cheques.

If they had called you to request authorization, you wouldn't have been surprised by the final price, and could still negotiate payment terms on a bill that's larger than expected.

FWIW, we pay about $4-500 for a 16-valve head with a carefully done 3-angle grind. But I supply a big box of shims to the machinist to save a bunch of time. I don't find $900 unreasonable for that work on the 24v. It's the $400 over the estimate "sticker shock" that seems to be the issue here.
 
Thx Brian and John, I left him a message today and will try him again over the weekend. I have a big box of parts on route from Cdan and some headstuds from ARP that I expect next week. I also took the injectors in for service and hope to pick everything up and move forward next week.
Both of your advice is appreciated, I do not want to 'overpay' and it does sound like there is justification for the amount ( which I need to verify) but the sticker shock comes at a bad time.

Again Thx for the good advice
 
Its a simple job when you grind the shims, not the valves, check your clearances, then remove whats required.

We never grind the valve stems.

Very rarely do we not do new seats, guides, and at least exhaust valves at the same time. Its a $3000-$3500 drive in drive out job over here normally to do it properly.

I think between Slee, and others there has been 2 sides of the coin to consider, and I think everyone agree's some change is ok, but not this big a swing, so the OP needs to now ask more questions of the shop than perhaps he did at the start, but only he knows his version of how the oral contact or estimate [quote and estimate arent the same] went down, so only he can deal with it as required.

The biggest point I think that has been made so far though, is if its done right, fixed issues, and it a proper job, then the extra $ to get it there is worth compensating the shop for.

There is aways the 2 parties versions, and the truth, not that either party was lying, but they are giving thier version of what they thought happened.

Me, I would ask him what beer he drank, then ask if you can come see him end of day for a chat, and take a six pack of something you can both tolerate, and run through the details with him in a casual chat over a beer, so some compromise can be found.

I would take some cable ties, race tape, and a shovel in the boot though, just in case he needed persuading :grinpimp:
 
Maybe you could ask the shop to meet you in the middle, like $750 worst thing they could say is no.
 
Back
Top Bottom