Hard top vs. Soft top?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 6, 2003
Threads
124
Messages
871
Location
Tomball, TX
Alright, here is the dilemma. Owned a factory soft top 40 years ago. Thought I wanted a hard top on the next 40 I bought, but now that I have one, I'm starting to reconsider. Looks cool, but is louder inside and kind of limits the fun factor in a southern climate. Am I crazy for thinking about unloading the hard top and just sticking with an OCD soft top? Not a daily driver btw, and mainly used for family and dog hauler on weekends. This 40 does have A/C but not sure how much i will be using it. Should I just store the hard top? Looking for thoughts from those that have experienced both for a while and the pros and cons from their perspective.

What does a good hard top and rust free set of ambulance doors bring these days?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
From the guy's I have spoken with who wheel their 40's, all say to loose the hard top - personally I like the look of a hard top on a built rig but that's just my taste .
 
I think if you live in the south, having both (assuming you have room to store it) would be great. I say that, although my soft top is still not installed on my truck yet. It may prove unrealistic to swap the tops out more than once a year (if that). As for value- on the west cost I've seen good condition hard tops go for as much as $2500- on my local southeastern craigslist I've seen them as low as $150!
 
I live in a climate where the seasons actually change. My 40 is not a daily driver, I currently use it for trail riding & have not run a top for yrs. I just use a bikni top & maybe soft doors now. I have run hard & soft tops when I did drive it on the street more. I ran a soft top for a yr & didn't really like it. I like the hard top because I could clean the windows w/o having to worry about scratching them & didn't have to worry about tearing the top out on the trail. I used to put the top on in the fall and took it off in the early spring. During the summer it was always off.
 
I disassemble and store my hardtop about 6 months of the year. I know a lot of people say you shouldn't take the top off the sides, but if you do it carefully you can put all the pieces in the top cap and hang it upside down from the ceiling. Reassembly does take a little more time (about 3 hours total), but the storage space trade off is worth it for me.
 
It really depends on your own personal taste. I have a 1970 trail rig with only an OCD soft top and I LOVE it, the quality is fantastic, it opens up easly and is light. I can take it off in about 10 minutes and it take little room to store. On the other hand my 1975 stock restoration has the hard top and I LOVE it, after I put new seals on doors and top, I think it is very quiet, holds heat really well and the look is second to none. I say have both for more options.. Good luck.
 
Thanks for the opinions guys. Would love to have a second 40 and just keep one set up each way, but don't have the space. I will probably just disassemble it and store for now. If a year goes by and I haven't used it then maybe unloading it will be the answer. We'll see how tight the OCD top seals up once I get it put on. Still need to gave the Real Steel bows test fit, welded up, and powder coated first.
 
I think you've got a good plan. If you sell it and then decide you want annother, it'll cost you double what you'll get for it. Your resale will also be better if you want to sell it down the road.:D

I hated the only soft top I ever had... It flapped, leaked, and was a PITA to take on and off (not factory). In the summer I run a rigid bikini top and 1/2 doors... It the top makes it off.
 
I would love a soft top. Had one on the rig before and I stayed wet during monsoon season but I liked it plus much cooler here. I only replaced it because thieves are rampant here. They will steal the steering wheel given a chance and I am not joking. 40 parts are like gold here.
 
I have a good hard top and hard doors for my 70 FJ40 and never use them. The only reason I keep them is for re-sale value of the rig if I ever decide to sell it (unlikely). I did advertise my hardtop and doors on the classified here, but got few responses. Put it on Craigslist and my phone was blowing up! I decided not to sell them, but they will probably never go back on my 40.

I dig the Bestop Soft top. EZ on/EZ off
 
Have hard top going to soft top

I have a Hardtop on mine, with A/C. I am taking the hardtop off because it's just too loud. I am replacing it with a soft top and half doors (locally made) . When it's not rainy season I think it will be much more fun (had a 82 CJ 7 with only a soft top in Fla.) When I gets nice here and I get too hot, I can turn on the AC and just let it blow on me..security is an issue but you don't have to worry about someone breaking your windows out..That said I have another car to drive when I want to lock stuff up or it's raining like pouring pee outa a boot. Lee
 
I live in "the south" (though not as far south as Houston) and I put my hard top on every winter and take it off every summer. Wouldn't want to be without it personally but YMMV.
 
I think you are making the smart move. Tear down the top and store it away. If you find that it is not in the way just keep it stored.
 
Thought I wanted a hard top on the next 40 I bought, but now that I have one, I'm starting to reconsider. Looks cool, but is louder inside and kind of limits the fun factor in a southern climate. Am I crazy for thinking about unloading the hard top and just sticking with an OCD soft top?

I've only had hard tops. I like the idea, but you're right, they're loud. I've got my soft top waiting in the wings.

You should be able to get $600-$750 for your top and amby doors.
 
I disassemble and store my hardtop about 6 months of the year. I know a lot of people say you shouldn't take the top off the sides, but if you do it carefully you can put all the pieces in the top cap and hang it upside down from the ceiling. Reassembly does take a little more time (about 3 hours total), but the storage space trade off is worth it for me.

I do this too, either way don't sell the hard top the value of it verses the replacing it down the road is well worth it.
 
Back
Top Bottom