Gearing Suggestions

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 30, 2005
Threads
32
Messages
151
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
I have done searching, but I wanted another round of quick inputs....

Statistics: 71 FJ40, stock t-case, tranny, and diff gearing (4.1). I am running 33x12.5's.

I will run these tires for another year or two. When I regear, I will be installing ARB's.

On the trail, gearing seems ok, but on highway (especially any sort of incline), the truck dogs bad. This may also be related to my carb issues.

Questions..

1. I am thinking of going to 4.56's - would this help on the highway? I want a good mix of road performance and trail performance.
2. I am also thinking of getting a crawler box - how would this influence what gearing I want?
3. I heard (from Whatley and others) that getting into those bigger ring sizes can cause issues because of space in the differential? Could I hear more? At what size does this become an issue?Solutions?

Thank you!
 
Hi All:

I would say before you spend any $$ on re-gearing the axles or adding a "crawler box" you address the basics of your powertrain.

Is the engine tired (i.e. low compression numbers) and in need of new rings or perhaps a complete re-build?

Does the carburator need a re-build? Do the "secondaries" open-up under load?
If you do not know if/when the carb was last re-built it is probably time for that service! Either Mark A. @ Mark's Off-Road or Jim C. @ TLC Off-Road can provide you with a quality Aisen "F" or "2F" carb re-build.

Has the engine had a tune-up in recent history? Have you checked the timing of the engine? Is it still running a points-type ignition?

Be aware that by running 33 inch tires (stock tires were about 28 inch diameter) you have altered the powerband of the engine by the overdrive affect of the larger than stock diameter tires. So, the engine runs at lower RPMs at a given speed then when using the stock size tires.

4.56 ratio R&P gears will compensate well for the difference between the stock diameter tires and those 33s, and help your gearing off-road as well. The engine RPMs at higher speeds will be higher, of course.

Adding a "crawler box" gives great flexability off-road gearing-wise, but is an involved (and not cheap) process to install.

You will only have clearance issues in the differential housing when running really low R&P ratios, like 5.13 or lower. Which would only be used in a rig that A) is used off-road only; B) runs huge tires; or C) both of the above! :D

As I stated above, getting the engine running well would be the first step IMHO to solve this issue. Then look to the carburator re-build.

Good luck!

Alan
 
I'm actually going to jump onto this thread because it is so relevant.

My situation:

'72 FJ40, F engine, runs excellent, fresh rebuild on the carb and motor, etc.

3 speed on the floor, stock everything. 33"x12.5 BFG AT's

I want to slow her down for trail use. Highway is not a concern other than getting from trail to trail (it would have to do 55, which she does now, but is revving pretty good).

What would you guys recommend? I'd like to go to 35"s max in the future. I like the idea of dual cases and it looks like Marlin Crawler has a setup for about $1400. That is reasonable for me but I would rather not have to swap the tranny on top of that. Lockers would also come in the future (lockright or ARB depening on how much $$$ random people want to donate to the poor Iglu fund)

Opinions? Recommendations? I think I also have the stock 4.11's.
 
1973Guppie said:
start your own fing thread, but don't be a thread hijacking bitch.....

Noah

I was actually thinking that this would be so similar that the both of use (thread starter and myself) would benefit from responses.

I didn't mean to upset anyone. Perhaps once his engine issues are resolved he'll ask the same questions I did since our vehicles are nearly identical.
 
For JGM, I wouldn't regear for 33's. I run a 2F, 4.11's and 37's and can run 80+ down the highway. No mountain passes here, but can still hold over 70 on hills.

To TheIglu -- SM420. It's the perfect swap for your year rig and it's cheap.
 
Thanks for the responses! Your thinking is right along with mine, so that is a good thing.

In fact, I have a complete official project plan and budget for this build (yes, in MS Project) that includes the items you mentioned (engine diagnostics, carb issues, crawler possibility, etc). I am probing to fill out that plan looking forward.

My hope is that the F engine is fine (and I think it probably is). I would hate to put in a new powerplant. If I did I would not go with a 2F (nor would I EVER go with non-toyota). My dream would be a 3.4L from a Taco or 4Runner. We'll see.

TheIglu, no prob with the hijack from me...
 
1973Guppie said:
start your own fing thread, but don't be a thread hijacking bitch.....

Noah

whoa :eek:

i hope you are friends
 
I had the same problem with my rig when I got it. After I did some PM's and replaced the carb it went away. So I would guess gearing isn't the problem.


Just to share what I have been through in the past year. The $1400 for a Marlin box dosen't include, new or modified drivelines, new cross member, the "while your at it" stuff, new clutch, SOA, etc. etc.

The SM420 is a faster, cheaper, easier, and almost as effective gearing option. The guys I ride with are split about 50/50 SM420 and 2nd t-case (Toy Box or Rock Box). They seem pretty evenly matched. Something to consider is you will have to shorten your rear drive line when you add the 2nd t-case. Most of the 2x t-case guys I know run a V8 so they have moved the drive train forward which compensates for this. With a F/2F you wind up with a really really short rear DL, ask me how I know.;)
 
Good stuff to note, Rusty. I have jotted down notes to most of that in my plan. I was not aware of the SM420 opinions versus the rockbox. That will be interesting to dig into.

The necessary "indirect" mods you mention are worthy of note. I haven't done too many changes to my cruiser, but I put a dana 44 under my 96 4Runner (using landcruiser parts, no less) which required an idiotic amount of these indirect changes (like new crossmembers, new driveshafts, entirely new steering and front brake system, etc...). It can get complicated and painful fast.:crybaby:

I am starting simple - get the engine diagnosed and up to speed, replace that stupid weber card with a Toyota and let'er roll and see how she does.:cool:

Thanks again, all!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom