Engine Help high compression but need rebuild?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 6, 2010
Threads
27
Messages
148
I have a 77 FJ40 with stock 2F with about 170k miles or more. The engine runs fine, starts right up. Lately, I noticed I burn a lot of oil (approx. 1 quart 80 miles or so). I have no leaks. I notice especially when I coast downhill in gear I smoke excessively. I have changed the pcv valve but that did not do anything. I took it to Torfab to get other things like power steering but had them check the engine out. Compression test read 165-170 in all cylinders. Had them take the head off and inspect it, they poured oil in the cylinders and it past through in 5 mins so they said the rings are toast. Anyways, the cost to rebuild is $6500 plus $250 for shipping it to CA and $1500 for labor. So it will be $8250 before tax. This is a curve ball to me since I thought I may need a head gasket replacement with valve job etc.. What do you guys think I should do?
 
Torfab has a good reputation here.

Are all the facts in evidence?

Very hard to believe they took the head off without doing a top end rebuild. If your compression is what you say (and difficult to believe it is) I'd likely ask to have the valve stem seals replaced and see what happens.

A leak down test would give you more information before rebuild. $6500? That's on the high side and nearly double what's usually quoted. If it is that much, I'd be tempted to cut the 2F loose and use the cash to install a more modern motor.
 
The symptoms sound more like valve guide seals, not rings. Your compression numbers wouldn't be that high with bad rings, imo. Do a leak down test to confirm.

Does it smoke on start up?
 
I am having my engine rebuilt. Everything will be new except cam, lifters and oil pump. Cam has been reground and oil pump has been gone through. I think I will be in the 4-5K range. It adds up quickly.
 
I would also suggest to replace the valve stem seals and then see what happens.
 
I also say valve stem seals, as you go down hill oil under the valve cover will flow to the front and make the seals more likely to leak more. Compression that high also indicates valve stem leaks as that oil in the cylinder will help increase the seal and pressure.
 
If these guys are right and it's your valve stem seals, they've saved you thousands. IMO, you owe each one a case of their favorite brews.:beer:
 
engine is still making high vacuum, decel the carb butterflies are closed....even on the intake stroke....suck is going to suck were it can, so suck oil past the intake stem it will.
 
Another vote for valve stem seals, especially on decel in gear. We see this on air-cooled Carrera 3.2L engines. Then again, a quart per 80 miles is pretty bad. I wouldn't think bad valve stems and seals would let that much oil by.

I'm also a bit shocked a 2F rebuild would cost that much. I think decent runner engines are available for a few hundred bucks?
 
Don't know where the OP is located... In Vegas, I paid a mchanic $900 to have the 2F pulled, stripped to a longblock and redressed and reinstalled, after the rebuild... And an old school machine shop $2850 for the rebuild... Total $3750... New cam, new valves, rods and Pistons... Cylinders bored .025 over, crank turned deck milled, etc.

Find an old school machine shop, that's been in business for decades... Preferably 35+ years and ask if they have ever rebuilt a 2F... Ask for an estimate.

I can recommend a great machine shop in Las Vegas... And a great old school mechanic.
 
Wow, thanks for the replies. As far as start up it hardly smokes at all, it does spit out lots of carbon. They said there is a lot of oil in the cylinder so that is the reason I have high compression, still doesn't make any sense because if the rings are toast wouldn't my compression be low even with lots of oil? Only real noticeable smoke is going downhill coasting in gear can let out lots of smoke and I notice back fire as well. That was the only reason I want to have it checked out. They gave me 3 options. 1) rebuild, $8250 2) Machining of block. Honing out the cylinders, replacing crank shaft bearings and piston rings $2500. Machining of the cylinder head. Valve grind, valve stem seals, decking the mating surface, pressure testing for cracks $800. Total with labor: $5240. 3) used good condition short block $400. Machining of the cylinder head. Valve grind, valve stem seals, decking the mating surface, pressure testing for cracks $800. Total with labor: $3140. So sounds like I should just have the head gasket and valve stems and see how it does coasting downhill. It was driving great. I rather spend the money getting power steering. My little kids love going out on dirt roads especially in mud.

20170430_153724.webp
 
It is hard to believe that bad valve stem seals could suck up a whole quart of oil in 80 miles. You may have some really worn valve guides to go along with the stem seals. (Unless everywhere you go is downhill and using the engine as a brake). Normal compression for a 2F should be about 150 to 160 when the rings are new. Make sure your PCV is working correctly to vent your block.
That price quote for the overhaul is outrageous.
 
Perhaps honing the cylinders, new rings, valve job with seals. You may be able to go the next 100000 miles without further difficulties.
 
Stuck oil rings if PVC system is operating correctly.


Well all of my post did not make it. Here's the first part.

It would be easy to check valve guides and seals with head off. If they are within spec I say stuck oil rings.
 
Last edited:
Where are you located? There are cruiser knowledgeable mechanics all over. Get a second opinion.
 
Perhaps honing the cylinders, new rings, valve job with seals. You may be able to go the next 100000 miles without further difficulties.[/QUO
The only worry I have is that they said they will be using Chinese parts and can't guarantee it will last. I chose Torfab because of their reputation but they are so busy now. They said even their rebuilds haven't been lasting very long. Any other good mechanics in WA?
 
I don't believe that would be under the heading of rebuild. If the cylinders aren't too worn such as a significant lip on upper cylinder walls, There would be no cylinder boring, no new rods or pistons. they hone the cylinder surface to rough it up a bit, new rings, and a valve job.
I'd check other garages with good reputations and ask about it. These are not sophisticated engines.
 
Back
Top Bottom