Electric Engine Conversion

Cost not being an issue, would you go Electric?

  • Yes, sign me up!

    Votes: 25 49.0%
  • OH HELL NO son!

    Votes: 20 39.2%
  • Only if Tesla makes the batteries :P

    Votes: 6 11.8%

  • Total voters
    51

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

The Torque Is Unbelievable, 2015 Tesla Model S P85D 'Ludicrous Speed' 0 to 60 time.....2.8 SEC. Any ? Thats faster than a Twin Turbo Porsch. Apply that technology, dialed Into off road specs. Oil co. don't want people to know about this tech. You don't believe It go drive a all wheel dr. Hybrid Highlander. How many people Know That Trains for 100 years are electric and use the diesels to charge the batteries. BIG time Torque, Read about battery dependability from something other than the American trade Journals before you make the mistake attacking them. Expensive but doable, small diesel to charge batteries would be awsum. Cool Post..!
 
No. Weight and space requirements for the batteries, plus a lack of range and a lack of charging stations in the middle of nowhere make this a non-starter for me. Also, if I decide to drop a bunch of money into replacing my drivetrain, you'd best believe it'll make some noise when I'm done.
 
Electric really isn't best way to go. It might make sense for a small car in an urban environment, but the best things about gas/diesel is that you can carry your energy around with you (the gas) and it is reasonably efficient at turning that energy into forward motion. For an electric vehicle, the electricity has be to generated somewhere, transmitted to your charging station, used to charge your batteries and the you can carry the energy around with you (like gas) to provide forward motion. The problem is that all this generating/transmitting/charging/storing/driving a motor has inefficiencies at every step.

Using gas/diesel engines to generate electricity to power electric motors also isn't very efficient. You're better off using the gas/diesel engine to power the vehicle in the first place.
 
I saw this several years ago and thought converting classics to electric power would be the way of the future:

As mentioned by others, range is the big problem with doing this with an overland type vehicle. But the battery technology is improving. 10-20 years from now when they can get a 300-400 mile range out of a decent battery pack, then I would have no qualms about making the conversion.
 
I'd bet that in 10-20 years 300-400 mile range out of a decent battery pack will be childs play, given the rate at which technology develops. They are already doing stuff with batteries in a lab environment that blow current expectations out of the water. No pun intended..
 
Using gas/diesel engines to generate electricity to power electric motors also isn't very efficient. You're better off usingthe gas/diesel engine to power the vehicle in the first place.

Train efficiency to truck comes out to about 350 MPG for the same payload, Its not even close. Battery tech has changed big time as well. Get a horse right ?
 
No. Weight and space requirements for the batteries, plus a lack of range and a lack of charging stations in the middle of nowhere make this a non-starter for me. Also, if I decide to drop a bunch of money into replacing my drivetrain, you'd best believe it'll make some noise when I'm done.

Weight is the hardest part.
Space requirements not to bad. They are flat. You could mount them under the vehicle for center or gravity.
Charging stations is a non issue. Tesla has them set up now where you can drive across country.

The new systems are coming online with good results. But the batteries are killing it. Then you have 6D tuning if the car is a hybrid. And the ecu can't process all this data fast enough. Give it time.
 
Using gas/diesel engines to generate electricity to power electric motors also isn't very efficient. You're better off usingthe gas/diesel engine to power the vehicle in the first place.

Train efficiency to truck comes out to about 350 MPG for the same payload, Its not even close. Battery tech has changed big time as well. Get a horse right ?

Yeah, but that is the "economy of scale" factor at work. Can you imagine if everyone drove trains to work?

I'm not anti-electric vehicles for sure. Heck, I actually work at a national lab where we are putting a huge amount of effort into this right now. At this point in time, though, EVs have some technical challenges to overcome.
 
Yeah, but that is the "economy of scale" factor at work. Can you imagine if everyone drove trains to work?

I'm not anti-electric vehicles for sure. Heck, I actually work at a national lab where we are putting a huge amount of effort into this right now. At this point in time, though, EVs have some technical challenges to overcome.
JDPower had to change their rating scale because Tesla recieved a 103 rating. That was "economy of scale" for 18 wheelers vs Train, Pound for pound. Da Nile. The last question about trains, what national lab is that you work at.
 
The 80 is an incredible expedition and off-road vehicle. It's not a prius. If you were to go that route, you really take away what it's intent/purpose is. If you want to go electric do it on a car or buy a plug-in. It doesn't make sense on a cruiser.
 
JDPower had to change their rating scale because Tesla recieved a 103 rating. That was "economy of scale" for 18 wheelers vs Train, Pound for pound. Da Nile. The last question about trains, what national lab is that you work at.

Oak Ridge National Lab.
 
The 80 is an incredible expedition and off-road vehicle. It's not a prius. If you were to go that route, you really take away what it's intent/purpose is. If you want to go electric do it on a car or buy a plug-in. It doesn't make sense on a cruiser.

So this is what I'm imagining. Fast forward 20 years and batteries that are good enough to net you a 400 mile range with the heater and the radio going are widely available and roughly the size of a suitcase, under 200lbs. Solar panel technology will also be drastically improved. Drive out into BFE in your electric-converted cruiser, bring your fold-up solar array and you have weeks worth of fuel without an auxiliary tank. Also a lot fewer tools and fluids to lug around since you no longer have an internal combustion engine. We're not there yet, but I don't think it's a pipe dream either. I think electric could feasibly be the highest expression of off-the-grid overlanding. Just not in the PNW :o
 
Using gas/diesel engines to generate electricity to power electric motors also isn't very efficient. You're better off usingthe gas/diesel engine to power the vehicle in the first place.

Train efficiency to truck comes out to about 350 MPG for the same payload, Its not even close. Battery tech has changed big time as well. Get a horse right ?

Modern locomotives all use diesel engines to power generators which in turn power electric motors which drive the wheels. Diesel-electric drive has been around for a long time (the US army actually used it to power some tanks in WWII) and is reliable and relatively efficient.
 
So this is what I'm imagining. Fast forward 20 years and batteries that are good enough to net you a 400 mile range with the heater and the radio going are widely available and roughly the size of a suitcase, under 200lbs. Solar panel technology will also be drastically improved. Drive out into BFE in your electric-converted cruiser, bring your fold-up solar array and you have weeks worth of fuel without an auxiliary tank. Also a lot fewer tools and fluids to lug around since you no longer have an internal combustion engine. We're not there yet, but I don't think it's a pipe dream either. I think electric could feasibly be the highest expression of off-the-grid overlanding. Just not in the PNW :eek:

The numbers don't work out for solar-powered recharging vehicles. Even if solar cells reached 100% efficiency, the sun puts out about 1000 watts per square meter. The tesla has an 85kW battery pack to go 250 miles, a landcruiser would need easily double that, 160kW of power. You'd need 20-30 square meters of 100% efficient, perfect solar panels in ideal sunlight conditions to recharge in a day and it would take all day. Solar panels in the lab are only reaching 44% efficiency, so you'd need double that, and if the sun isn't ideal in your area, keep adding more. You'd need to bring a very large solar array.
 
The Oshkosh L-ATV (Humvee replacement) actually has the option of a Duramax V-8 powered diesel electric transmission. A cool feature of this is you can park the truck and us it to supply up to 120kw of electrical power, apparently thats enough to power an entire hospital or an airfield.
 
My thought would be that I want my 80 as mobile geographically as possible, power charging points don't encourage this.

Ideally my 80 would be the last vehicle on the planet retrofitted to make for the most available number of charging points & the latest technology in battery power storage & consumption by the motor.

Between our updated drilling policy & Iran, with oil hovering @ $40/bbl it's not like this is an issue any time soon, in fact I'd more expect to see a rise in 80 demand as gas prices stabilize at lows we haven't seen for a long time.

It would end the number of PHH threads though, and the "which oil" ones too!
 
Using gas/diesel engines to generate electricity to power electric motors also isn't very efficient. You're better off usingthe gas/diesel engine to power the vehicle in the first place.

Train efficiency to truck comes out to about 350 MPG for the same payload, Its not even close. Battery tech has changed big time as well. Get a horse right ?

While it would help if you could form a cogent understandable sentence, I will try.

Diesel electric hybrids in trains has been possible since 1908. That's because trains are freaking huge and run on nearly perfectly flat tracks, so most of the tradeoffs that continue to be unacceptable in personal autos are overcome by those two variables.

Someday, batteries may be good enough. Today isn't that day, though.
 
Back
Top Bottom