Electric Engine Conversion

Cost not being an issue, would you go Electric?

  • Yes, sign me up!

    Votes: 25 49.0%
  • OH HELL NO son!

    Votes: 20 39.2%
  • Only if Tesla makes the batteries :P

    Votes: 6 11.8%

  • Total voters
    51

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

As for future development of EVs into society as a whole, it should be the way of the future. There's no way "markets" will run to develop these systems in our current technology level as the "market" doesn't have a moral compass. People need to look forward and aim higher than the "oil will last forever" outlook. It pulls society backwards and with that kind of attitude, technology will never develop past what these stubborn people want.

"..it should be the way of the future."

Why? Because you said so? I have no problem with EVs being A way of the future, but nobody should be telling anybody else what should be THE way of the future. I prefer to choose my own methods of propulsion and let others do the same.


"There's no way "markets" will run to develop these systems in our current technology level as the "market" doesn't have a moral compass."

And thank God the markets don't because your idea of a "moral compass" and my idea of a moral compass are probably two different things. The market supplies what people want, and people want what works, and what works is a function of cost. When we get to a point where we need alternate sources of fuel and propulsion, the market will adapt to the demands, assuming its allowed to by governments and people who want to tell everyone what they should or shouldn't do.

What pulls society backwards is the restriction of an individuals freedom to choose what is best for him or her and their own family. What pulls society backwards is making broad decisions for society as a whole that does not benefit everyone equally.

The stubborn people that you speak of are a factor in what would trigger a move to EVs, should it ever come to pass. There will always be some demand for oil/gasoline/diesel by people who want to drive their 2Fs. If oil gets really scarce, this demand will drive up the price. Then others may decide the cost isn't worth it and maybe buy an EV.

Don't take your personal utopia of everyone driving around in EVs and spin it into something that everyone should share because of some "moral" reason.
 
EV charging infrastructure for long distance/remote areas just does not exist and there's no way to take it with you either. Same with fuel cell, lpg etc etc. There's a LOT to be said for a fuel that is essentially safe to handle/transport and transfer with a hose.

If I'm heading into a remote area, I can load an extra jerry can or two or three or... of fuel and that's another 80-100 miles of range (in a diesel). Once used it weighs next to nothing - just the can. Takes a few minutes to transfer.

Until I can find a power cord connected to the grid out in the bush, what good is an EV out there. I run out of fuel, I can borrow a jerry can of fuel from a co-traveler. Hard to borrow some electrons... I guess a solar panel or two will do the trick given a month or two parked in the sun or maybe a genset towed behind :)

EV is just one powertrain option and obviously it works fine in/near civilisation, of course where are we going to get all those terawatts needed to charge 10's or 100's of millions of EVs if they become the defacto powertrain? Won't be happening for a while... As soon as I see the military move to an EV based ground vehicle fleet, that might be the time.

EV converting an 80 or any other behemoth is an amusing thought. If I ever get thrown long term into a padded cell I'll be sure to give it more attention at that time.

As an EE, my greatest concern when heading out bush is that some electrical/electronic life critical component will fail. I love my old school diesel in oz, if the starter can be made to crank (or it's parked on a hill for a roll start) it will start and keep running until the fuel supply is cut off. Even old carbi petrol 4wd's were reasonably reliable (repair kit with a couple of new plugs, spark plug lead, coil, points etc). Now we've gone down the path of EFI (even modern CRD engines have ECUs to operate the electrically controller injectors) we have reduced reliability (by that I mean we've introduced many additional components that can 100% strand you). An EV with all the additional electronics, power supply, power train etc etc... Again, fine near civilisation or within cell range, but beyond that, not in my vehicles. And thankfully the choice of what I drive and what powers it is still mine to make.

cheers,
george.
 
It definitely should be a market choice. It is like any tool and it has a designed purpose and limits. The Outback is obviously not the place for a pure battery electric.

That could change in the future. Let's say an advance in fuel cell technology allows you to fill a tank (perhaps diesel) and get a higher conversion efficiency than an internal combustion engine. No plugging in required. At that point the electric drive has a great many advantages. No belts, no transmission, no high pressure pumps, no oil changes ever. Instant torque, easily configirable acceleration tables for varying terrain, high fording capability with sealed components. Most modern A/C driven cars are already water cooled and have a radiator. There's another advantage - the motor could be allowed to continue to run at decreased output to limp home after a holed radiator. A/C motors have 2 bearings to wear out, very few moving parts and even fewer wear parts.
I also work in the electrical field. Our facility has hundreds of A/C motors that are nearly 70 years old. Many have only had new babbitt bearings after testing. Most in conditions far more demanding than any vehicle will ever see.

It could go either way, but i do enjoy considering the possibilities. I've been a diesel nut for a long time. My toes are just now dipping into electrics, but so far I really like the technology. It's almost luxurious to have diesel torque with near zero sound.
 
Back
Top Bottom