Almost none of what you are saying is true or makes any sense. It sounds like your Moab friend set up his system poorly and did not understand the underlying principles.
In most VSR (ACR in BlueSea speak) systems like ours, it makes the most sense to run your Aux loads off the aux battery, and also to run your solar to the aux battery. That allows you to use a real starting battery for starting, and a deep cycle to to run your loads. This also makes certain your starting battery is always fully charged, since no loads are coming off of it and the VSR keeps the batteries separate except under charge.
It makes no sense to run solar directly to your main battery, unless it is your only battery and responsible for aux loads as well. However if you did run aux loads off your aux battery but set up your solar on your main battery, I could see the potential for hysteresis, which is addressed by most VSR/ACR type systems by building in a time delay to prevent rapid cycling. So if your system is set up incorrectly, and you have a short time delay in your circuitry, this is a theoretical possibility, but extremely unlikely in real life.
In a dual battery system based on a voltage sensing relay, your batteries do not need to match. And since most VSR based systems are dual sensing, if either battery has a charge current, once the battery being charged can hold a specified voltage(usually above 13.5), the VSR will close anyway and top the other battery too. Since your starting battery will be basically full, the idea that somehow the VSR closing will drop the voltage of the aux battery significantly does not really make sense.
Plus the voltage differences between the 2 batteries are tiny-less than 1 volt typically, there isn't going to be much battery to battery current. If you think about it, an aux battery being charged will be 13.5 volts, the isolated starting battery will be near 12.8 volts. When the VSR closes the .7 volt difference is not enough voltage to cause a "rush" of current anywhere.
Deep cycle batteries can work fine as starting batteries, but real starting batteries work better. It's all about the specs and what you need. MOST AGM batteries seem to be both starting and deep cycle capable because of the low internal resistance, but you need to decide if you want to run $250 batteries (Lead Acid AGM) or $100 batteries(Normal flooded lead acid).
I could not agree more, though I use the 7610s in 3 of my Land Cruisers. It's a nearly perfect system, easy to install, inexpenisve and 100% reliable.
Pump your brakes there drew, no need to come at me teeth out. I'm not spreading untruths. I'll address you point for point.
Almost none of what you are saying is true or makes any sense. It sounds like your Moab friend set up his system poorly and did not understand the underlying principles.
Yes I stated that
In most VSR (ACR in BlueSea speak) systems like ours, it makes the most sense to run your Aux loads off the aux battery, and also to run your solar to the aux battery. That allows you to use a real starting battery for starting, and a deep cycle to to run your loads. This also makes certain your starting battery is always fully charged, since no loads are coming off of it and the VSR keeps the batteries separate except under charge.
Sure thats fantastic perhaps you can expound on this for my dumb mind. Are you suggesting the individual relocates all of their rigs stock and future accessories to an AUX Deep Cycle Battery? So the Starting battery has nothing but the starter on it? Jesus that sounds like a PITA, fantastic concept and if you do that then gold star for you.
It makes no sense to run solar directly to your main battery, unless it is your only battery and responsible for aux loads as well. However if you did run aux loads off your aux battery but set up your solar on your main battery, I could see the potential for hysteresis, which is addressed by most VSR/ACR type systems by building in a time delay to prevent rapid cycling. So if your system is set up incorrectly, and you have a short time delay in your circuitry, this is a theoretical possibility, but extremely unlikely in real life.
I understand the concept behind having a dedicated starting battery. I'm an engineer.
It does make sense and it does WORK to have the solar float the main (starting) battery in the way that mine is set up, once it floats the battery it will float the others (But my solar isn't on my main if you read my post).. Even with my 'dumb' relay it doesn't rapidly cycle.
In a dual battery system based on a voltage sensing relay, your batteries do not need to match. And since most VSR based systems are dual sensing, if either battery has a charge current, once the battery being charged can hold a specified voltage(usually above 13.5), the VSR will close anyway and top the other battery too. Since your starting battery will be basically full, the idea that somehow the VSR closing will drop the voltage of the aux battery significantly does not really make sense.
Again perhaps you should have more closely read my post. I do not experience the issue my friend did for the reasons previously stated. Not sure why you are hounding this.
As far as matching batteries thats my personal preference. I like having dual DCB's because it gives me the ability to stick weld off of them more safely than starter batteries. Unless you want the possibility of having a battery explode hot acid all over you, whatever floats your boat I guess.
Plus the voltage differences between the 2 batteries are tiny-less than 1 volt typically, there isn't going to be much battery to battery current. If you think about it, an aux battery being charged will be 13.5 volts, the isolated starting battery will be near 12.8 volts. When the VSR closes the .7 volt difference is not enough voltage to cause a "rush" of current anywhere.
Again read my post and focus on the words. You say this but my real world experience indicates otherwise. IDK what battery you have the rest at 12.8v, thats fantastic buy more, almost ALL 12v batteries I have had experience with rest at around 12.6v. 12.7v is 100% charge state (2.12v per cell)
And perhaps what you aren't considering is a charge source like solar on a cloudy day only putting out 30%, lets say 2.1 amps. This 2.1a floats up the aux battery to about 13.6v then the Blue Sea 7600 links to the main battery... One that is aged some and rest around 12.5v, if I've used any interior accessories it may be lower than that by a couple tenths. When the relay closes there
is a rush of current to the main battery as the two batteries attempt to equalize and in some cases when the solar output isn't sufficient it
can cause the relay to cycle.
Deep cycle batteries can work fine as starting batteries, but real starting batteries work better.
And you are basing this statement off of? just the name of the battery, what the internet has told you or have you actually looked at the discharge curves??
It's all about the specs and what you need. MOST AGM batteries seem to be both starting and deep cycle capable because of the low internal resistance, but you need to decide if you want to run $250 batteries (Lead Acid AGM) or $100 batteries(Normal flooded lead acid).
.
Agreed, I'm not saying my way is the best way, the right way nor the way everyone should be doing it. Only that its working well for me. Sure there is a cost factor, but with the extra $150 and some 6810 rod I purchased the ability to field weld / repair items that others can't. And yes I've had to do this before.