Does this seem reasonable?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 19, 2009
Threads
13
Messages
48
I took my Cruiser to ToyotaPro over a year ago when I moved to Vallejo, and was happy with the work that they did. However, I went there this past week and the all the people there were different. The mechanic that worked on my rig was not there, but I had them do an oil change and inspection. They said that the fluids were dirty, and quoted $180 to change the transmission oil, and $220 for the differentials. Does that seem reasonable?

Willing to look for another shop if there is a recommendation, maybe on this side of the bridge. i.e. Napa, Fairfield etc. Any suggestions?
 
At least it wasn't thread asking if a certain fj80 for sale was a reasonable deal lol. Op are you asking if $220 total is reasonable for those services or $400 total for everything. I think $220 sounds like a good deal for everything you mentioned but $400 is a bit high. But prices could be a lot different in between the states where I live and you live.
 
Why don't you do it yourself. These are as easy of a task as you can get. And since you're doing to diffs and trans, do the transfer case too.

Question for the group: Does the transmission fluid get "dirty"?
 
Why don't you do it yourself. These are as easy of a task as you can get. And since you're doing to diffs and trans, do the transfer case too.

Question for the group: Does the transmission fluid get "dirty"?

Yes it can and does get dirty/worn out over time. On every vehicle I've owned (manual and automatic) the transmission fluid that came out was much dirtier than the fresh stuff I put back in.
 
So what is Toyota's recommended change interval? I know you only get some of the fluid out when you pull the plug. I believe more comes out in a A442.
 
Do a search for transmission fluid exchange. I'm not sure what the specified interval is but I'd say every 60k can't hurt. Its an easy DIY job but you'll need a bucket, clear hose and about 4 gallons of ATF.
 
Diffs have a plug drain. I drained mine and pump some 90 weight back in.

I’d let a Toyota dealer change my transmission fluid if/when I ever decide to be concerned about that.
 
I do a passive drain/refill of the transmission fluid every year. It's about 4 quarts and doesn't take much time or effort. Fluid is always cherry red and smells delicious.
I tend to do all fluids once a year, but it's a daily driver and sees a lot of road time.
 
Why's that? Drain and refill, just like the diffs? Maybe easier since you just pour in with a funnel?
Not if you’re changing the transmission filter. I’d rather pay “more” (see pic) and know a Toyota mechanic is torquing the pan bolts properly, using the factory filter, etc...

image.webp
 
Not if you’re changing the transmission filter. I’d rather pay “more” (see pic) and know a Toyota mechanic is torquing the pan bolts properly, using the factory filter, etc...

View attachment 2079209

For the 80 series its easy to replace the transmission fluid where the hoses connect to the transmission cooler. As for the filter its not like an oil filter that clogs up over time, bur rather a strainer. Assuming the transmission fluid is kept in decent shape the "filter" doesn't require cleaning or replacing over time.
 
These are all very easy DIY items. I guess it just depends what your time is worth. I for one like doing these things myself...one, to save money and two, so i know exactly whats being done.
 
Carve out a couple hours and figure out how to do it yourself. Ive been doing a trans drain and fill every 2k miles, engine oil at 3k. Overkill but I know the status. Gear oil is just as easy, drink a beer while it drains and pump some new gear oil in, new drain plug gasket, torque it. Have another beer.
 
I do a passive drain/refill of the transmission fluid every year. It's about 4 quarts and doesn't take much time or effort. Fluid is always cherry red and smells delicious.
I tend to do all fluids once a year, but it's a daily driver and sees a lot of road time.

Just do as Jon has suggested with frequent changes. It is safer to make the incremental drain and fill regularly on a higher mileage/older vehicle with unknown history of any previous fluid changes.

Just a notion the 95-97 will drain 4 quarts with the A343 transmission where the 93-94 models will drain 6 quarts with the A442F transmission. Not sure about 91-92 models with the A440F trans but most likely 6 quarts.
 
I am willing to bet they are just doing a drain and fill on the transmission. 4qts

Drain and fill on the differentials even including the transfercase 5qts.

Transmission fluid - $32/gal
Gear oil - mobil 1 synthetic - $9/qt = $45

So $77 in raw materials. Add a funnel and a gear oil pump - $20

$97. Only you can answer if your time is worth the extra money.
 
Back
Top Bottom