Chevy or 2F motor???

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

When the F went on my 72, I bought a 2F for $300 from a guy going to a V8. I replaced all the rings, bearings, gaskets, oil pump, not really a rebuild, just freshened it up. A buddy did a little machine work on it, ground the crank, rebuilt the head. By the time it was all done I was into it about $700. It runs great. The adavantage though, is not paying for machine work. I don't think I could have bought an adapter kit for that much. I am happy with it.
 
rhino73 said:
I was in the same position as you are when i bought my FJ. I put the 350/SM420 all rebuilt for what i could buy the f rebuild kit for. The swap is really easy too. I say SBC all the way, for the same reasons that hawk and others have mentioned. just my .02.

This topic consistantly brings heated debates. Everyone seems top agree that cruisers are the best, but when it comes to the engine we seem to "agree to disagree".

Good luck!
So you did the whole swap for the about $700??

Can you itemize these prices for me please?
 
Nothing wrong with an F motor.
I just priced rings, main&rod bearings, and a full gasket set at OReilly, it was about $350...
Yours is still running right? So it's just tired, not broke...
Pull the motor, remove the head, pull the crank and rods, hone the cylinder walls, install new rings and bearings, put her all back together, and enjoy for another 200K miles...
 
Chef said:
Nothing wrong with an F motor....
Mark A. of MarksOffRoad.net has rebuilt an F in his FJ45 that he says runs pretty strong. He says it surprises some folks how peppy it is. Sometimes I think Cruiser owners judge whether to retain an F/2F/3F based upon the tired engine they have, rather than a fresh engine or rebuild.
 
Mace said:
So you did the whole swap for the about $700??

Can you itemize these prices for me please?

Mace,

Rebuilt SM420=$200
Rebuilt 350=$400 (I already had thecore)
AA transfer adapter=$200 (Used)
MOtor mounts=$100

Total =$900



The key to mine was that at thetime I worked part time at an auto parts warehouse, a good friend of mine worked in the machine shop in house and another friend of mine owns a salvage yard. When i looked at rebuilding the F in my cruiser i looked like it would cost about $1500.00 since the crank was banged up pretty bad. I am sure the F could have been done cheaper no that i know more but with the contacts Ihad the SBC seemed like the logical choice at the time. All my buddies are Hot Rod Chevy guys so they sort of steered me away from the F.

You can really cut out a lot of cost when your friends work for :beer: !!
 
rhino73 said:
Mace,

Rebuilt SM420=$200
Rebuilt 350=$400 (I already had thecore)
AA transfer adapter=$200 (Used)
MOtor mounts=$100

Total =$900



The key to mine was that at thetime I worked part time at an auto parts warehouse, a good friend of mine worked in the machine shop in house and another friend of mine owns a salvage yard. When i looked at rebuilding the F in my cruiser i looked like it would cost about $1500.00 since the crank was banged up pretty bad. I am sure the F could have been done cheaper no that i know more but with the contacts Ihad the SBC seemed like the logical choice at the time. All my buddies are Hot Rod Chevy guys so they sort of steered me away from the F.

You can really cut out a lot of cost when your friends work for :beer: !!
Kinda what I thought,
Did you take into account, driveshafts, radiator, gauges, new throttle cable, hoses, clutch, clutch slave cylinder adapter, etc etc etc..

The 350 swap part is not the expensive part. The rest of the stuff is.

And I was not even including the tranny ;)

If you are able to fab more the cost goes down. And if your buddies work for :beer: the cost decreases as well. But even if you do all the work yourself, a 350 conversion can get to $1500 very quickly..

thanks amigo :beer:
 
Good point on the hidden costs like the slave cylinder, etc. Most of them would have had to be repaired or replaced anyway. In the end my point was the same as Hawk. SBC parts are available and cheap.
 
what is the intended use of this machine going to be?

the F/2F is great, but it does'nt like extended miles, wound up on the freeway.





that being said, 2F all the way.
pick up a decent running example and just drop it in. it will fit with VERY little work
 
rhino73 said:
Good point on the hidden costs like the slave cylinder, etc. Most of them would have had to be repaired or replaced anyway. In the end my point was the same as Hawk. SBC parts are available and cheap.
And that single point is why I like SBC swaps :)

Course, I don't have one ;)
 
I couldn't do without the power.

350 Chevy, Vortech Heads, Comp 262 Extreme Energy Cam, Edelbrock Air Gap intake, Holley Truck Avenger carb 670 cfm.

Still lots of torque. That's all about the cam. You can get a cam do make a SBC do anything you want. Torque @1500 rpm or scream at over 7000 rpm.

For me, it was my best decision and money I've ever spent. I wish I had just went with a TBI but I didn't realize it at the time.

Tire shredding power with 32" tires.

Motor will spin 39.5" violently in the mud. Power is never a problem.

Just my .02

JR
 
I keep hearing all the bad about the "F" motor but I dont get it? If an engine gets 300,000 miles and still runs like a champ, How bad can the oiling problem be? Is the 2F that much better? I have both and just dont see the power difference. All I see is what the 2F costs me in gas is killing me.
Anyway I vote stay Toyota because they are just that dependable.
 
I love the 350. Not a fan at all of the 2F.
darkside.webp
 
eddybear said:
How many man hours would it take a decent mechanic to replace an F motor with a 2F? Thanks!


depends how deep you go. maybe a day, probably less with a helper.
just the motor or the 4 speed with it, along with any driveshaft flanges that differ.
everything just bolts right up, with just a few small wiring mods(alt and oil pressure) done in the engine bay.


i have an F in a 2F truck....
 
brian said:
depends how deep you go. maybe a day, probably less with a helper.
just the motor or the 4 speed with it, along with any driveshaft flanges that differ.
everything just bolts right up, with just a few small wiring mods(alt and oil pressure) done in the engine bay.
Is this true for all years 2F? I have a 74 F motor (with 4 speed transmission) that either needs a rebuild or replacement and have been weighing my options, rebuild the F, replace with 2F or replace with SBC. Difficulty (I'm an amateur) and price are the two main considerations, in that order.
 
though most of the good points have been covered, one of the things I like about my 350 is that I can work on it.

That is, though I did not put in this Chevy and I have not ownd an F or 2F (but I have driven both many times over the years and know friends that have both), I find I can find my way around the more compact and easier to navigate 350.

So, for an average (or below average) weekend mechanic like me, it just seems a lot easier to work on than a 2F. And, as people have said, getting parts is a snap, but more important to me is the ability to really make the effort to put said parts on myself and my sense (just visually alone) is that it is easier on a SBC 350.

my .02 cents...

BTW, no one really mentioned the 200 or so pound savings by going to a lighther weight 350 than a 2F? I have read a lot about this elsewhere, so that 'might' be a consideration.

my only complaint is the crap 10MPG I might get on a good day with my Edlebrock 4 barrel carb :)
 
wantatlc, Edel Performers suck @ss. I know. I own one that I'm getting rid of when I rebuild the tired engine it sits on. Switch to a Q-Jet or maybe Holley Truck Avenger (haven't tried that one, but they're advertised as made for 4x4s). Properly jetted, you'll definitely gain some mpgs.

The extra weight of the F/2F/3F lends the front end traction and better hill climbing stability.

What's all this talk of 2Fs being difficult to work on? Everything is more accesible and little needs replacing once properly set up and maintained.

2Fs are practical with few mods available and great crawling but need rotating assy balancing to be 75mph capable all day long.
SBCs are practical with many mods available and fun on road but are a little lacking for crawling but great for mud runs.

sebo4wd, I say resolve the F motor's oiling system concerns and rebuild it. Shoot, pull it yourself with a rented engine lift and truck ship the motor to a talented F rebuilder and get a worry free engine back. IIRC, you have one such Cruiser mechanic in GA. Pulling it yourself saves some serious dough. And you can send the carb out for a rebuild yourself. Maybe do the manifolds locally to save shipping weight. Plenty of advice here for that.
 
4x4Poet said:
wantatlc, Edel Performers suck @ss. I know. I own one that I'm getting rid of when I rebuild the tired engine it sits on. Switch to a Q-Jet or maybe Holley Truck Avenger (haven't tried that one, but they're advertised as made for 4x4s). Properly jetted, you'll definitely gain some mpgs.

so, what is really the difference and what makes it "suck ass" versus a Holley? I had my Edlebrock 'properly jetted' (and adjust mixture, timing, advance curve, etc) by a specific carb guy for this exact reason, had him set my carb up just for my engine, etc.. didn't make a bit of difference for MPG as people said it might. that was one of my sepcific goals - I even posted about it last year - and no improved mpg as you claim.

4x4Poet said:
The extra weight of the F/2F/3F lends the front end traction and better hill climbing stability.

hmmmm... I guess I can see pros and cons. maybe the extra weight is not so good for mpg as mentioned above? BTW, what is a 3F?

4x4Poet said:
What's all this talk of 2Fs being difficult to work on? Everything is more accesible and little needs replacing once properly set up and maintained.

was just my 2 cents. when looking into the engine bay of a 2F or the engine bay of a 350, the 2F fills the compartment and seems like my car where everything is a bit tigther and there just seems to be more to it than a 350. thus, my opinion was that for me, it seemed easier to work on as less in the way to work around and areas easier to get to and less 'going on'. I freely admit I have only worked on the 350, but my percption is my perception and if you work regulary on a 2F.. it likely seeems like cake to you.
 
wantatlc said:
so, what is really the difference and what makes it "suck ass" versus a Holley? I had my Edlebrock 'properly jetted' (and adjust mixture, timing, advance curve, etc) by a specific carb guy for this exact reason, had him set my carb up just for my engine, etc.. didn't make a bit of difference for MPG as people said it might. that was one of my sepcific goals - I even posted about it last year - and no improved mpg as you claim.
Short answer: You got me.
I theorize that the Edel has poor design at the seats. I installed the off-road springs and it still lets too much fuel past the seats under bouncing. I installed the OR springs before I first installed the carb, but I've read on boards that without the OR springs, the carb floods some over speedbumps. Not much of an exaggeration, either.
I also think that the Q-Jet's smaller primary bores help it produce better mileage than Edel Perfs that I'm pretty sure have larger primary bores (I haven't personally calp'd 'em). I'm sure I picked that tidbit off someone else. Common Q-Jet factoid that the small primary bores with the good size secondary bores make the carb easily adaptible to various engine displacements.
And I posted, I have no experience with the Avenger. Just that they're adv as for off-road trucks. When I said properly jetted, I was referring to the Q-Jet, not the Edel Perf. You're jetting experience refers to the Edel and speaks for itself. Even a professional couldn't get it to produce just a little better mileage.
I read a 4W&OR article comparison between the Q-Jet, Edel Performer, and either the Avenger or a Demon. IIRC, the Q-Jet won in off-camber, mileage, idle crawling, hill climb, but not all out power. The Edel's Performer won that category. My guess is because the Performer is made for racing, not multi-scenario street and off-road driving.
...BTW, what is a 3F?
Lol. I often forget the *E*.
if you work regulary on a 2F.. it likely seeems like cake to you.
That's a laugh! Considering my mechanical abilities.
I do hate changing the rearmost sparkplugs on my SBC trucks. Or removing the valve covers. Or getting at the fuel pump bolts. Or adjusting the power steering pump between the pump bracket and the engine crossmember. Or blah, blah, blah....

I'm with you on the perception thing. I like hearing others' opinions even if I disagree or they aren't necessarily well supported (like many of mine). I usually learn something even if only to refine my own views. I've changed my mind and I've been *schooled* many times since I first joined BBs. Web wheeling eliminated many false assumptions I had and greatly expanded my mechanical *horizons*. It also helps that I've been simultaneously working on a project truck and a few runners while web wheeling.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom