wantatlc said:
so, what is really the difference and what makes it "suck ass" versus a Holley? I had my Edlebrock 'properly jetted' (and adjust mixture, timing, advance curve, etc) by a specific carb guy for this exact reason, had him set my carb up just for my engine, etc.. didn't make a bit of difference for MPG as people said it might. that was one of my sepcific goals - I even posted about it last year - and no improved mpg as you claim.
Short answer: You got me.
I theorize that the Edel has poor design at the seats. I installed the off-road springs and it still lets too much fuel past the seats under bouncing. I installed the OR springs before I first installed the carb, but I've read on boards that without the OR springs, the carb floods some over speedbumps. Not much of an exaggeration, either.
I also think that the Q-Jet's smaller primary bores help it produce better mileage than Edel Perfs that I'm pretty sure have larger primary bores (I haven't personally calp'd 'em). I'm sure I picked that tidbit off someone else. Common Q-Jet factoid that the small primary bores with the good size secondary bores make the carb easily adaptible to various engine displacements.
And I posted, I have no experience with the Avenger. Just that they're adv as for off-road trucks. When I said properly jetted, I was referring to the Q-Jet, not the Edel Perf. You're jetting experience refers to the Edel and speaks for itself. Even a professional couldn't get it to produce just a little better mileage.
I read a 4W&OR article comparison between the Q-Jet, Edel Performer, and either the Avenger or a Demon. IIRC, the Q-Jet won in off-camber, mileage, idle crawling, hill climb, but not all out power. The Edel's Performer won that category. My guess is because the Performer is made for racing, not multi-scenario street and off-road driving.
Lol. I often forget the *E*.
if you work regulary on a 2F.. it likely seeems like cake to you.
That's a laugh! Considering my mechanical abilities.
I do hate changing the rearmost sparkplugs on my SBC trucks. Or removing the valve covers. Or getting at the fuel pump bolts. Or adjusting the power steering pump between the pump bracket and the engine crossmember. Or blah, blah, blah....
I'm with you on the perception thing. I like hearing others' opinions even if I disagree or they aren't necessarily well supported (like many of mine). I usually learn something even if only to refine my own views. I've changed my mind and I've been *schooled* many times since I first joined BBs. Web wheeling eliminated many false assumptions I had and greatly expanded my mechanical *horizons*. It also helps that I've been simultaneously working on a project truck and a few runners while web wheeling.