Blown Head Gasket- Advice Needed

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 17, 2014
Threads
28
Messages
191
Location
Solana Beach, CA
Last Sunday I pulled into my driveway and when I got out of the truck I saw a good amount of pinkish fluid puking out from the transmission area. Uh oh. I had it towed to my local mechanic (John at SD Trux) and he diagnosed it to be a blown head gasket plus other potential repairs/complications due to the rust throughout the underside of the truck. He said I was looking at a repair bill of $5000 or more. Big Bummer.

My truck is a green 97 Collectors Edition, unlocked model and has 166,000 miles on it and has a very clean interior and exterior, unfortunately it was a mid-west car and I did not discover this forum until I bought it. In just shy of two years I've put 30,000 trouble free miles on it that have included trips to Montana, Colorado (twice) and a handful of trips to Mammoth Lakes in the winter and Baja for quail hunting. Its been a great vehicle and I'm at a loss for what to do.

Is there a market to sell it "as-is" to someone with the skills and know how to fix the issue? What's that ballpark value?

At best, from what I see this vehicle could be worth $7-8000 if it was rebuilt with no mechanical issues. Spending $5000 (or more) to repair it doesn't seem to pencil to me.

Is it perhaps cost effective to swap in another FJZ80 motor? Are rebuilt ones out there for sale? Is the overall cost for that in the same $5000 range all-in?

I welcome any and all advice. I already stated looking at new 4Runner's online today, after the news. This sucks..

Thanks,

Nick
 
well i have bought 3 trucks with blown HGs over the last year. 1 i fixed and 2 i parted out. paid no more than 650 for them if that tells you anything.
 
Look for a mechanic who specializes in Land Cruisers and get a quote from him/her. I can just imagine your regular mechanic over inflating the extent of the damage because they don't particularly want to do the work.

Also search on this site and determine whether you'd be willing to tackle the job yourself.

I will also say that transmission fluid on the driveway does not sound like a head gasket. And rust did not cause your engine/transmission problems... all the more reason to seek out a second opinion.
 
The pink fluid was coolant. It source was the rear of the engine near the transmission. San Diego Trux works on LC's but I think I will seek a second opinion for sure. The rust didn't cause the problem, I agree and John didn't say rust was the cause. He just said that he would be fighting with crappy bolts and corroded items which would run the price up from needing additional parts and labor.
 
Look for a mechanic who specializes in Land Cruisers and get a quote from him/her. I can just imagine your regular mechanic over inflating the extent of the damage because they don't particularly want to do the work.

Also search on this site and determine whether you'd be willing to tackle the job yourself.

I will also say that transmission fluid on the driveway does not sound like a head gasket. And rust did not cause your engine/transmission problems... all the more reason to seek out a second opinion.
I asked my mechanic what he would charge to do a head gasket job on one of these and he was in the $1500 ballpark. not a specialist, but he's done a few.
 
The pink fluid was coolant. It source was the rear of the engine near the transmission. San Diego Trux works on LC's but I think I will seek a second opinion for sure. The rust didn't cause the problem, I agree and John didn't say rust was the cause. He just said that he would be fighting with crappy bolts and corroded items which would run the price up from needing additional parts and labor.

sounds like a PHH

I asked my mechanic what he would charge to do a head gasket job on one of these and he was in the $1500 ballpark. not a specialist, but he's done a few.

that's about what i paid to my mechanic, plus i bought the gasket kit from beno or dan, can't remember which... been purring like a kitten for about 5k miles now, we'll see how she goes...
all my head needed was a resurface, though...
 
You could try James at the Truck Shop down the road for a 2nd opinion:

sdtruckshop.com

8660 Miramar Rd
San Diego, CA 92126
(858) 408-0314
 
Wow, $1500 vrs. $5000 is quite a difference. I'll drill down and see what he's estimating. I was on my cell when we spoke this AM and couldn't write any notes.

The PHH was replaced fairly recently so that's probably not it. He sounded pretty confident in his diagnosis.
 
Wow, $1500 vrs. $5000 is quite a difference. I'll drill down and see what he's estimating. I was on my cell when we spoke this AM and couldn't write any notes.

The PHH was replaced fairly recently so that's probably not it. He sounded pretty confident in his diagnosis.

then maybe it's the rear heater hoses... because head gasket failure generally doesn't cause coolant to spill out on the ground.... a break in a line somewhere does, the loss of coolant can in turn overheat your vehicle and CAUSE your head gasket to fail...

those rear heater hardlines have been known to corrode in rusty areas, too...

another question, was this the same mechanic that replaced the PHH?
 
Just spoke to John. He said he anticipates that I will need a new cylinder head, so the $5K is for the HG, and a top-end rebuild. It said the head may be OK, but he kind of doubts it. He also said that things he removes to get to the block may not go back on so easy because of the rust. He said a HG job is typically $2200 for reference.
 
Just spoke to John. He said he anticipates that I will need a new cylinder head, so the $5K is for the HG, and a top-end rebuild. It said the head may be OK, but he kind of doubts it. He also said that things he removes to get to the block may not go back on so easy because of the rust. He said a HG job is typically $2200 for reference.


No, the PHH was replaced prior to my ownership, and he does think the heater hardlines are an issue due to the corrosion.
 
Just spoke to John. He said he anticipates that I will need a new cylinder head, so the $5K is for the HG, and a top-end rebuild. It said the head may be OK, but he kind of doubts it. He also said that things he removes to get to the block may not go back on so easy because of the rust. He said a HG job is typically $2200 for reference.
usually don't need a new head, unless you overheat it really really bad... but including head, that price sounds a lot more like it...

2200 is fair for doing everything from the HG up... especially if he's doing all the stuff you SHOULD be doing while in there, like water pump and new head bolts and etc... ebay has aftermarket heads from down under for around a grand, but i've not heard of anyone's experiences with them... people around here generally like to stick to toyota
 
I don't know but I don't think I overheated things much at all. I didn't notice my temp gauge reading hot, no steam...
if you caught it early enough and just took it to him because of the coolant on the ground, i'd definitely get a 2nd opinion... if it's not running rough, you don't have milky oil, and weird pressure issues in your cooling system, your head gasket may be just fine...

you can always buy a test kit to be sure...

if i were you, i'd want a more compelling reason as to why he thinks the head gasket is blown...
 
NickPsy said:
The pink fluid was coolant. It source was the rear of the engine near the transmission. San Diego Trux works on LC's but I think I will seek a second opinion for sure. The rust didn't cause the problem, I agree and John didn't say rust was the cause. He just said that he would be fighting with crappy bolts and corroded items which would run the price up from needing additional parts and labor.

Ah, I see. Misunderstood your post.

The more I hear from this mechanic's diagnosis, the more it sounds like this mechanic is trying to doom and gloom you to either A) dissuade you from getting the work done or B) make a really handsome profit if you do go ahead with the work. Either that or he just approaches everything with an absolute worst case point of view in the hopes you will be happy with a smaller bill in the end. But my strong suspicion is that he just doesn't want to work on your truck.
 
I twice had overheated my truck. Neither time did I notice the temp guage move till it was way too late but did get a rough engine and check engine light both times. Neither damaged (warped) the head appreciably and did not impact the gasket. I rebuilt my engine recently, head had a mild warp which is expected on a head this long. The reason I rebuilt was it was eating too much oil and since I had the heads off anyway I may as well do everything else.

So where I am going, don't jump to conclusions. Find the leak, repair it. Make a decision from there.
 
Just a heads up: John at SDTrux is an honest guy and a very good mechanic with lots of Land Cruiser experience. They are certainly not a cheap shop, but they are not crooks. I assume the 5k is a worst estimate, which is not far off for doing the job right, including labor and a new head (potentially).
 
Back
Top Bottom