Bib patch question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 14, 2011
Threads
29
Messages
689
Location
Seattle
I decided to cut the spot welds and remove this piece from the bottom of the bib, since it looked pretty suspect.

Sure enough, major rust flakes.

IMG_20180729_124256665.webp
IMG_20180729_124312846.webp


It's pretty close to rusting through the outer panel.

All due respect to the engineers who designed this, butw what a terrible design.

Shouldn't be too bad to fix and put back to original, but I'm hesitant to do that since it's just going to rust out again. This spot welded support piece will just trap moisture. Granted, it has lasted since 9/75, so I'll be dead by the time it needs replacing again.

The bib hinge bolts through this area, but it doesn't seem like the support is a necessary part. What do you think about just replacing the outer skin and throwing the support piece out?

The only thing I can think of is that the support is needed to prevent bending and twisting when you unbolt the bib from the fenders and use the hinge to fold it forward... Which is something I never do.

I'm doing a frame off, but this is a restomod. It had a small block Chevy and a ranger overdrive in it when I bought it. So originality isn't as important to me. I just want it to last a long time!

Thanks
Peter
 
All due respect to the engineers who designed this, butw what a terrible design.

Granted, it has lasted since 9/75, so I'll be dead by the time it needs replacing again.



I'm doing a frame off, but this is a restomod. It had a small block Chevy and a ranger overdrive in it when I bought it.


:hmm: poor design/ last since 9/75/engine changed to V8.

This doesn't add up to me. Only lasted about forty-three years. Engine change which I'm sure removed the splash guards in the engine compartment. Were those splash guards a terrible design as well? I have a bunch of bibs dating back to 1960 without rust in the them. I'm think it's more a matter of location and previous maintenance rather blaming a design from the the 1950s.

I do agree at the current prices if you have the skills repairing makes sense. Luckily in AZ rust is a rather small issue.

:cheers:
 
Last edited:
Fair enough, but don't take it as some kind of insult. Toyota wasn't infallible back in the 60's, 70's, and 80's. The rear sill is also a terrible design. Even Arizona rigs rust out in that area. The front body mounts- also a bad design. Does that mean I think FJ40's are junk? Of course not. I'm toiling for endless hours and spending tens of thousands of dollars I'll never get back restoring(ish) this rig. We're capable of holding competing thoughts in our minds, are we not?

I'm leaning towards just restoring it back to OEM... This rig will never go out in the rain again if I can help it. But now is a good time to stop and consider whether there's a better way. That's all.
 
The rear sill is also a terrible design. Even Arizona rigs rust out in that area. The front body mounts- also a bad design.

We're capable of holding competing thoughts in our minds, are we not?

The rear sill to be has a bigger problem supporting the weight of the hard in the corners. Assume the 1979 resigned helped this. My 68 is still rust free but I always kept it clean. The corners show a slight bulge after years of off-road use. The original owner cut the sill to install a trailer light socket. Still a clean hole with raw metal. I've owned it since July 74 so plug been there a long time. If I hadn't maitained it I'm sure even in AZ it would have rusted by now.

As for holding thoughts to ourself you opened the door when instead of a simple rust repair thread you had to make a point of blaming Toyota which seemed strange based on the age and removal of the splash guards that were there to help prevent this.
 
Why don't you repair it back to oem and then put some good urethane sealer across the top. That would keep water from running down into crack but prevent humidity from being trapped because bottom is not sealed. Weld through primer before spot weld. Chainsaw oil/Fluidfilm or LPS3 sprayed in crack after paint. Just some thoughts from a rust belt Canadian.
 
Sandblast. Then weld-thru primer.
Then re-weld, then epoxy primer, being sure to allow it to saturate the mating junction. Will last many decades.

Getting wet is fine, just needs to run down the road to get bone dry, after the rain, etc.

When rigs are parked in the back, not under cover, for the entire winter, and stay wet for months, is when the cancer works on the pinch welds, etc
 
Well said above. I just rebuilt my bib and did the exact same. Built the inside piece out of 14 gauge if my memory serves and follow the above steps you’ll be golden. Real steel makes a patch panel as well. Never seen it in person tho.
 
Some progress this evening.

Welded up a patch for the outer section:
IMG_20180803_174156481.webp


All fixed up:

IMG_20180803_193112468.webp


Sandblasted the inner support thingy. Crappy pictures, but this thing looked like what I imagine the surface of the moon to look like:

IMG_20180803_194348548.webp


Cut out a few sections where the pitting was horrible.

IMG_20180803_194336075.webp


Another shot of how bad those pieces were:

IMG_20180803_194355638.webp
 
And welded in the patches. It's been a long time since I've been able to rip off some beads. I've been patching so much sheet metal... pretty sick of the old tack, tack, tack routine. Got to do a little practice on this piece. Yes, I need more practice. I played around with doing lots of rapid tacks right next to each other. seemed to work pretty well- better than doing continuous beads since i got some burn through here and there.

IMG_20180803_195839589.webp



IMG_20180803_201300597.webp


I warped the piece a little bit, but not enough for it to be a problem. sorry, forgot to take a pic after the welds were ground down.

I have a few more patches like this to do, then weld-through primer and some spot welds, and bob's you're uncle.
 
Given I live in the land of rust... and the ship sailed on stock long ago... I plan to recreate the lower 4” out of 10 gauge and weld the upper section to it. I’ll skip the area for water to sit and rust it away. A quick splash of paint and it’ll be good for at least the 44 years the original lasted.
 
Same problem on my '76 from the Indiana rust belt. ANY place where two pieces of steel are layered and not completely sealed (impossible) has rusted through on mine. I removed the brace piece from my bib and threw what was left away. I repaired the whole bottom section of the bib and mounted it back up. It is well supported when mounted to the fenders and all. Just be careful if you intend to use the hinge function, as the bib would likely bend. If you wanted it stronger, I would use a thicker single piece to rebuild the bottom as mentioned above.
 
Nice work patching. It is one of the things I have enjoyed on my projects. Don't take folks responses on here personally - we all love each other (for the most part). The other thing is - we are always quick to criticize other peoples work - but you are the one posting pics and doing the work, so remember that. As a purist myself, I have pulled a few V8's out to put original 3B diesel and 2F's back in. To me, nothing beats the sound, feel, and smell of original FJ40's. Nice job.
 
Totally agree on the V8. Pretty interesting how my views have evolved over the course of my ownership. When I bought this rig, it had 35's, cut fenders with flares, an auxiliary gas tank that required the exhaust to route under the rockers, etc. Aside from the janky exhaust, I thought it was totally bad ass.

I drove it for three years, then parked it for 4 and worked in it slowly. The more blood, sweat, and tears I invest, the more I want to make it more original. I replaced the rear quaters, ditched the aux tank, redid the Po's crappy rear sill repair, got 33x10.50,s on stock steelies, etc. Still will be far from oem, but I'm definitely more biased towards stock.

But an engine swap is just not in the budget... The SBC does have some virtues that I appreciate, but if I had a genie in a bottle, I'd have a 2F in it.

I'm still super thrilled with what I have though!
 
When I was 20 I did up a BJ40 in the rust belt of North Queensland. My bib repair consisted of a piece of 3mm angle iron welded in place. That was in 2000. Recently probed for the truck's whereabouts on one of the Facebook groups and lo and behold it was alive! And the angle was still in place. It didn't have the charm of the all the factory pressings but boy did it last.
 
@Awl_TEQ

Kevin, could you make a replacement piece for the “front sill”... I’m sure there’d be a market for a beefed up piece to replace the bottom of the bib... perhaps with optional early bib lights.

I can envision a thicker piece that combines both pieces into one... simply cut off the bottom and weld on one new piece. It could be done in a way that would make it virtually indistinguishable from OEM.
 
Last edited:
I made the inner and outer rear replacement pieces on my son's '76 out of stainless. If it rusts through that, we are all in trouble. I wish I had done his bib the same way, but just used steel and we are getting some bubbling after only 6 years.
 
Back
Top Bottom