Bad habit?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 5, 2003
Threads
298
Messages
3,661
Location
Saratoga Lake, NY
Question-
I've been shifting into neutral before coming to a stop at a red light. What I mean is the light is green 100 yards out and turns yellow then... So I'm traveling at a pretty good clip and need to stop at the light.
Seems as though the vehicle stops a little "better" when I take it out of gear.
Cause your not trying to slow the engine and vehicle at the same time.
Good or bad habit?
 
Yup, these tranny's are supposed to be bullet proof. I'm sure this is a good way to find out!
 
By doing this you will actually get less braking due to the reduced vacuum boost. Will it hurt the transmission? No. Transmissions are supposed to be able to shift. Is it a bad habit? Well it's not the best habit IMO as I like the downshift method much better.
 
Downshifting an auto tranny is a good way to destroy the transmission.

All that forward energy has to be transferred somewhere else to stop you, usually to tons of heat on your rotors. Guess where a good bit of it goes when you downshift with your tranny... heat is just about the quickest way to kill an auto tranny.
 
Downshifting an auto tranny is a good way to destroy the transmission.

All that forward energy has to be transferred somewhere else to stop you, usually to tons of heat on your rotors. Guess where a good bit of it goes when you downshift with your tranny... heat is just about the quickest way to kill an auto tranny.

But, the question was about shifting into neutral. Bad?
 
But, the question was about shifting into neutral. Bad?
Sorry, I was replying to jonheld.

Shifting into neutral isn't a great habit, but don't expect it to destroy your trans in short order like solely engine breaking downhill all the time would.

Now if you are disengaging it while loading it, then you are starting to get malicious again :ban:
 
Sorry, I was replying to jonheld.

Shifting into neutral isn't a great habit, but don't expect it to destroy your trans in short order like solely engine breaking downhill all the time would.

Now if you are disengaging it while loading it, then you are starting to get malicious again :ban:

Go BUCS!:crybaby:
 
The only times I use the tranny downshift is if I am on hills offroad or on a LONG hill. I try not to do it on a day to day basis in stopping. That I use brakes only for, leaving it in drive.
 
Downshifting an auto tranny is a good way to destroy the transmission.

All that forward energy has to be transferred somewhere else to stop you, usually to tons of heat on your rotors. Guess where a good bit of it goes when you downshift with your tranny... heat is just about the quickest way to kill an auto tranny.

So let's see here. I'm driving downhill at say 50mph. Red light at the bottom. I drop the tranny into 3rd and the RPMs kick up, the truck slows due to the massive compression braking of the all powerful 3FE. While I would agree that it's putting a load on the transmission, please tell me how this differs from the load that I place on the transmission when I accelerate from the green light back up to 50 mph.
 
So let's see here. I'm driving downhill at say 50mph. Red light at the bottom. I drop the tranny into 3rd and the RPMs kick up, the truck slows due to the massive compression braking of the all powerful 3FE. While I would agree that it's putting a load on the transmission, please tell me how this differs from the load that I place on the transmission when I accelerate from the green light back up to 50 mph.
Because when you convert the energy of your engine into your forward progress, you get movement! This comes from the energy stored in your fuel.
When you do the reverse, you do not create fuel (wouldn't it be nice...) but instead that energy of your forward motion goes into heat and noise... into the engine and more importantly the transmission. I'm sure it will last a good long while even if you downshift to every light; I'm just saying it wasn't designed to do that and it is eventually going to cause problems.
 
Because when you convert the energy of your engine into your forward progress, you get movement! This comes from the energy stored in your fuel.
When you do the reverse, you do not create fuel (wouldn't it be nice...) but instead that energy of your forward motion goes into heat and noise... into the engine and more importantly the transmission. I'm sure it will last a good long while even if you downshift to every light; I'm just saying it wasn't designed to do that and it is eventually going to cause problems.

I'm all about the conservation of energy theory, but are you implying that I will use NO fuel during engine braking? I will use LESS fuel than during acceleration, but I am using fuel. The transmission is driving the engine during my downhill example, and the cooling system is still very functional. In fact during engine braking I would hazard a guess that the load on the motor would be less than during acceleration so there would be an increase in heat dissapation.

While I do agree that excess heat will kill a transmission, motor, what have you, I can't see any real world or theoretical problem associated with engine braking.
 
Shifting into neutral isn't a great habit, but don't expect it to destroy your trans in short order like solely engine breaking downhill all the time would.

Sorry but you are incorrect here. Downshifting regularly to slow the vehicle will accelerate wear on the clutches from shift. Using the transmission to engine brake on long or steep descents will not cause any damage or harm. When engine braking, you are only getting the amount of resistance against the transmission that the engine can provide, which is very little (perhaps 40-50 horsepower worth). This is far less energy than would be put through the transmission climbing the same grade, consequently far less heat. In fact on long decents, the transmission is far better at dissipating heat than the brakes which can absorb a lot of energy over a short period, but don't do well at absorbing continuous energy.

The only time that you would have a concern with using an automatic transmission to assist in engine braking would be with a diesel engine using a compression brake (Jake Brake). These make the engine act as a compressor and provide tremendous assistance in braking on long descents, hence their use in tractor trailers. When installed in applications like a 1 ton pickup with an automatic transmission, there are potential issues with overheating the transmission when hauling heavy loads and using the jake brake on a long descent.
 
I speak from experience here having personally dealt with a suburban that went through 4 transmissions in 100k miles because they could not stand up to the demands of engine braking in the mountains.

I agree, you cannot apply the brakes for an extended period of time and expect them to cope with the heat load (if you try it you'll boil your brake fluid and lose your brakes) but you can't substitute your transmission from your brakes and expect the same longevity from it. If you had a manual transmission and knew that your drivetrain was fully engaged, you'd be better off... these are auto transmissions, and although I'm not as fluent in Toyota's drivetrain principles, I'm sticking to my guns that it is a stupid idea to engine brake all the time instead of using your brakes; do any of you actually know for certain that the torque converter is locking up in all gears while engine braking?
 
do any of you actually know for certain that the torque converter is locking up in all gears while engine braking?

TC lockup is based on vehicle speed. It doesn't care who's driving who.
 
To reconsider the original question I'm not sure that "coasting" is legal but I could be wrong. The drawback I see in coasting as described in post #1 is if for some reason you need to apply power in an emergency situation, say for example to avoid something, you are going to be SOL when you mash on the gas pedal after forgetting to shift back into gear because you didn't have enough time to react to the danger.
 
To reconsider the original question

My head was whirring with thoughts of slipping clutch packs, fluid dynamics, cooling system design, drive train layout, and you had to come along and crush it all. Fine. I gotta go back to work anyway ;)
 
:lol:
 
I speak from experience here having personally dealt with a suburban that went through 4 transmissions in 100k miles because they could not stand up to the demands of engine braking in the mountains.

I agree, you cannot apply the brakes for an extended period of time and expect them to cope with the heat load (if you try it you'll boil your brake fluid and lose your brakes) but you can't substitute your transmission from your brakes and expect the same longevity from it. If you had a manual transmission and knew that your drivetrain was fully engaged, you'd be better off... these are auto transmissions, and although I'm not as fluent in Toyota's drivetrain principles, I'm sticking to my guns that it is a stupid idea to engine brake all the time instead of using your brakes; do any of you actually know for certain that the torque converter is locking up in all gears while engine braking?


So because you had a GM Vehicle that was notorious for blowing up transmissions, you have concluded that the failure was from using the transmission to engine brake? What is your basis for your conclusion? Have you considered that there might be other factors that lead to 4 transmission failures in 100k miles? Overloading the transmission by towing too much weight? Defective design? Improper rebuilding? You have leapt to a conclusion without any factual basis for the conclusion.


Concerning the torque converter locking up on the 80, it is always unlocked when you are off the gas. The torque converter only locks up in 3rd and 4th gear on the 95-97 80, and I believe the earlier years are similar.
 
Coasting by putting the tranny in neutral: I wouldn't do it because merely applying the brakes without doing this uses the 40-50 hp mentioned above to slow you as Toyota intended and will assist the brakes, but putting it in N gives this up and will increase wear/load on the braking system. It's also wearing the shift mechanism and whatever other parts are involved in the shift to N, then the subsequent shift back to D at the light/stop sign.

Downshifting for lights, etc: Definite waste of money. You're wearing on the expensive tranny that was not designed for constant use of this feature. Much cheaper to use the braking system which has simply replaced wear parts - brake pads.

DougM
 
Back
Top Bottom