Bad habit?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

So because you had a GM Vehicle that was notorious for blowing up transmissions, you have concluded that the failure was from using the transmission to engine brake?
No, I see it as a contributing factor to a weak design. My basis to this conclusion is 1 owner of the vehicle the whole time, knowing full well what happened to it and how/when the failures happened.

Concerning the torque converter locking up on the 80, it is always unlocked when you are off the gas. The torque converter only locks up in 3rd and 4th gear on the 95-97 80, and I believe the earlier years are similar.
So then, you do admit that the torque converter is absorbing the excess energy of the momentum of the vehicle that the engine cannot absorb by creating heat?


I'm with Doug, brake pads are cheap compared to a new transmission... don't downshift unless you have a good reason to.
 
Greetings,
I used to downshift on manual transmissions to get in correct gear for acceleration not to brake. The economics of pads verses clutches or auto trans is powerful.
Now, I normally hit the OD button on long descents on my LC 100 for engine braking. I never considered that it might hurt the trannie. Thoughts on using the button?
 
So then, you do admit that the torque converter is absorbing the excess energy of the momentum of the vehicle that the engine cannot absorb by creating heat?


I'm with Doug, brake pads are cheap compared to a new transmission... don't downshift unless you have a good reason to.

I never denied it. The torque converter is in the loop (so to speak) whenever you are in first or second and often under heavy throttle in third and forth. As I explained above, the amount of heat that is generated is minimal when the engine is used for speed control/braking on hills.

You need to differentiate between downshifting to brake the vehicle and using the engine to control speeds on descents. As I said above, downshifting will cause additional wear on the clutches, using a lower gear for speed control hurts nothing and does not put any additional wear on the transmission.

As far as your GM trannies, unless you were using them to control your speed on descents, stopped doing so, and with stopping doing so, had no further failures, you are just speculating.


Perhaps Doug can chime back in on using the engine for descending speed control as I believe his post simply addressed downshifting to stop.
 
SL,

Interesting you brought up the O/D. Years ago in a galaxy far, far away I was a District Sales Manager in the Western Region for Lexus. Prior to that I was a vehicle developer so I was always hanging with the tech guys in the Region. The tech guy (forgot his name) and I were talking about this exact thing - the O/D button. At the time, he was Lexus' top national tech guy - did all the training nationally. Great guy - was a track racer for Ducati.

Anyhow, I asked him if I was wearing anything by using the O/D button prolifically. Nope, he says. I say what about 10 times a day for the life of the car? Nope. What about 100 times a day? Nope. Other than literally wearing out the button itself, the relay, or the actuator there's no problem with the OD as it's either unlocking (which is no stress or heat) or you engage the OD again and the OD actuator won't move to re-engage until there's little/no load. So, play with it to your heart's content.

Gears are a different matter. And I agree it's important to differentiate between two things here.

1 - Downshifting for a grade and holding that gear all the way to the bottom - literally for hours and hours - without limit.

2 - Downshifting repeatedly as a habit where you're using it several times, or hundreds of times a day.

In #1 - you're wearing the clutches, actuators and fluid one time in an infinitesmal way and benefiting by having reserve braking capacity in that your brakes are cooler while on that grade.

In #2 - you're putting several months worth of wear caused by #1 in a single day which may decrease the tranny's life by a huge proportion - 50%? And in heavy use may even be creating hot spots in the tranny that fry the oil here and there causing deposits and interfering with the operation of the valve body years before it would happen in normal use. Tranny fluid only has to reach its max temp for an instant before it immediately and permanently loses its ability to operate your transmission. Do it enough times and the fluid as a whole has been seriously degraded before the miles of a service interval prompt a change in fluid.

Having said that, do I downshift? Absolutely. About 20 times a year there are places when I'm towing our 6000lb boat and get distracted and forget to downshift at the beginning of a bad hill and do it anyway as speed gathers rather than at a slower speed. It's braking insurance and the downside of having an elk step out right when the service brakes are already hot is too big to overlook a bit of wear on the tranny. Of course I am also hyper anal about tranny fluid changeouts, but you all know that......

DougM
 
I shift into neutral sometimes because the engine still pushes when I apply the brakes, and shifting to N shortens the stopping distance and reduces the needed brakeing pressure to stop the truck. I don't do this every time I come to stop, but sometimes it just makes stopping a little easier and smoother.
 
I suspect you are perceiving the engine is still pushing at higher speeds when it's not. Watch your tach the instant you let off the gas. It drops by the stall RPM of the torque converter and is slowing you nearly immediately. I agree that as I roll up to a stop it pushes a bit the last few MPH/feet but that's only a small portion of the speed the tranny's bled off for you in the previous 30MPH. So, I don't agree with that either.

What's going on, here? I'm disagreeing with EVERYTHING tonight! Heh....J/K

DougM
 
Question-
I've been shifting into neutral before coming to a stop at a red light. What I mean is the light is green 100 yards out and turns yellow then... So I'm traveling at a pretty good clip and need to stop at the light.
Seems as though the vehicle stops a little "better" when I take it out of gear.
Cause your not trying to slow the engine and vehicle at the same time.
Good or bad habit?

If I understand the situation correctly, you are driving along and see a stop light in the distance. You remove your foot from the throttle and put the transmission into neutral (from drive). You then proceed to apply the brakes.

My first thought is that you are putting less stress on the drivetrain and more stress on the brakes. I figure this because the engine is no longer turning the drive shafts and, thus, is not actively turning the rotors. The wheels (and the rotors and the drive shafts) are rotating purely due to the forward momentum of the vehicle. The engine output is completely independent of the rotors at this point and is therefore not being resisted by the action of the brake pads on the rotors.

To put it simply, I believe that this separation would keep the force of the brakes from resisting the engine's output. Perhaps I am incorrect, but it would seem that the opposing forces (the brakes wanting to stop the car and the engine wanting to propel the car) would put stress somewhere in between the engine output and the brakes, possibly on the transmission.

The reason it feels like your car is stopping better is because the engine is not propelling the car as you try to brake. One-hundred percent of the braking force is going to stopping the car, whereas if you hadn't shifted into neutral, some of the braking power would be put to counteracting the force delivered by the engine.

When I approach a distant stoplight or stop sign, I shift into neutral and do not brake. I let the natural friction of the drive train and the force of gravity slow it down. I know that the friction offered during coasting is not great, but it does exist. As I get closer to the stop, I will apply the brakes, but I have already slowed down a bit, so the force needed by the brakes is not as high.

I hope I didn't just make a fool of myself! :hillbilly: :cheers:
 
When I approach a distant stoplight or stop sign, I shift into neutral and do not brake. I let the natural friction of the drive train and the force of gravity slow it down.

Next time you do that, shift back into D in the middle of your coast; your passengers will assume you stepped on the brakes. Or am I missing something?

Curtis
 
The reason it feels like your car is stopping better is because the engine is not propelling the car as you try to brake.

Ok, that's just incorrect.

Suppose you're driving along at, say, hiway speed. If you take your foot off the skinny pedal, the engine is certainly not trying to propel you forward anymore; it's (engine) braking you until you auger down to a speed at which the engine idle would maintain that speed; namely, 3-5 mph.
 
So then, you do admit that the torque converter is absorbing the excess energy of the momentum of the vehicle that the engine cannot absorb by creating heat?

I'm with Doug, brake pads are cheap compared to a new transmission... don't downshift unless you have a good reason to.

By this reasoning we can also conclude that driving up hills will also shorten the life of your transmission, so you should only drive on level ground.

Helooooo. During acceleration through the gears the TC is locking, unlocking, clutch packs are slamming into each other, heat is generated. OMG, quick, shut off your motor.

These are big heavy trucks with overbuilt heavy duty transmissions, large fluid capacity, and external coolers. When I'm in the woods climbing up a rock face and letting the TC bring me up in a controlled manner by riding the throttle, do you think I'm generating a bit of heat in my TC? Engine RPMs are from 800-1500 and the wheels are just starting to turn. Where does the transfer of energy go? Right into the TC. You're telling me not to downshift and use engine braking to slow the truck because of heat load? Gimme a break.
 
CJF said:
Next time you do that, shift back into D in the middle of your coast; your passengers will assume you stepped on the brakes. Or am I missing something?

Curtis

Yes, that is true. I acknowledge that. That is why I have shifted into neutral, to remove the engine from the equation.

CJF said:
Ok, that's just incorrect.

Suppose you're driving along at, say, hiway speed. If you take your foot off the skinny pedal, the engine is certainly not trying to propel you forward anymore; it's (engine) braking you until you auger down to a speed at which the engine idle would maintain that speed; namely, 3-5 mph.

Alright, I admit that I was incorrect. When we consider going from around 30-50mph to a stop (the situation presented by the original poster) however, the car is slowed first to 49mph then to 48mph, and right on down through 5mph, 4 mph, 3mph, all the way to 0mph. It's those last couple of seconds before you stop that it's noticeable.

Try it for yourself; go out somewhere and bring the car up to speed. Brake using normal foot pressure. The car will slow as usual and stop as usual. Now try the same but while the car is in neutral. Near the end of the stop, the brakes will feel as if they are biting in and really grabbing the rotors. It will take slightly more pressure on the brakes (due to the lack of engine braking) but I, as others have said, imagine it would be more cost effective to replace the brakes than the transmission. The brakes were designed to brake. The engine was not.
 
To reconsider the original question I'm not sure that "coasting" is legal but I could be wrong. The drawback I see in coasting as described in post #1 is if for some reason you need to apply power in an emergency situation, say for example to avoid something, you are going to be SOL when you mash on the gas pedal after forgetting to shift back into gear because you didn't have enough time to react to the danger.


This is the old motorcycle rule as well.
Better to be in gear to escape if needed, especially at stop lights.
 
Back
Top Bottom