Anti Trailer Thread continued

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Rethinking bugsnbikes original post and idea - what if you made an open rack design for the rear, similar to what the jeeps use, essentially a shelf instead of an enclosed box. Design it to hold two of the medium sized Rubbermaid Action Packers, or three larger Pelicans, and use a steel bar to lock the tops down. That way you have lockable, watertight storage, and the plastic boxes can be pulled off and left behind for campsite use. The rack itself would weigh considerably less, and the sightlines would remain open. It could swing away and even be made to fit above/around an external spare or jerry can shelf. If you had the room, you could make an enclosed, lockable box along the bottom edge of the shelf that could hold recovery gear like straps and shackles, flashlights; essentially the first items you grab when you're stuck.

If you can design it to accommodate a pre-made box like ActionPackers (cheap) or Pelicans (not-so-cheap), you'll have less weight and mass as part of the structure, and it becomes more modular and flexible instead of one huge steel box.
 
The main reason to avoid the roof for me is that:

I go offroad....COG.

A roof rack is a 120lb penalty before even getting 100lbs of gear up there(200lbs total easy). Id much rather have that 200lbs at bumper height than 4feet higher.

Not sure what roof rack we're talking about here but I'd estimate an easier 55 pounds for the African Outback all aluminum rack. As already mentioned, you could throw things up there that were bulky but lightweight and have a much more trail ready rig than towing the trailer OR than an extra extension to the rear of rig with this cargo container idea. I think that yer overthinking this thing and I don't mean that as an insult because I do that all the time too!!! I'm just saying, get a good lightweight all aluminum roof rack like the AO and then get some good water resistant cargo containers like rubbermaid action packers or pelicans if you can afford those things and call it good. You will have a much more maneuverable rig all around - keep in mind that there are trails that are so super tight you don't want any extra extension to the rig - there are times when backing up isn't an option so having that hangover is gonna screw you in those situations. As a general rule of thumb don't try to put things that are uncomfortably heavy to handle on the roof rack, pack things sparingly and pack things from heavy at the lowest to lightest at the highest and call it good. :cheers:
 
Interesting idea, though I'm not sold on it. The difference between tongue weight of a trailer and a rear carrier like that could be significant. The tongue weight will be right behind the bumper, while the weight of the rear carrier and cargo will be leveraged because it is hanging further off the rear, this leverage can have a significant effect.
 
Not sure what roof rack we're talking about here but I'd estimate an easier 55 pounds for the African Outback all aluminum rack. As already mentioned, you could throw things up there that were bulky but lightweight and have a much more trail ready rig than towing the trailer OR than an extra extension to the rear of rig with this cargo container idea. I think that yer overthinking this thing and I don't mean that as an insult because I do that all the time too!!! I'm just saying, get a good lightweight all aluminum roof rack like the AO and then get some good water resistant cargo containers like rubbermaid action packers or pelicans if you can afford those things and call it good. You will have a much more maneuverable rig all around - keep in mind that there are trails that are so super tight you don't want any extra extension to the rig - there are times when backing up isn't an option so having that hangover is gonna screw you in those situations. As a general rule of thumb don't try to put things that are uncomfortably heavy to handle on the roof rack, pack things sparingly and pack things from heavy at the lowest to lightest at the highest and call it good. :cheers:


And the ones like Dave DMC or Me who travel with a roof tent, what should we do ?:crybaby:
 
If you can design it to accommodate a pre-made box like ActionPackers (cheap) or Pelicans (not-so-cheap), you'll have less weight and mass as part of the structure, and it becomes more modular and flexible instead of one huge steel box.


Yeah- this is much more realistic----easier to fab and lighter. More modular- and can easily be removed if you choose to do a shorter trip requiring less gear.

In an ideal world, this is going to slide over the rear swingout for easy rear hatch access.

I really like the idea of a lower lockbox under the shelf for recovery goodies.

Weight shouldnt be a factor at all since the tube bumper should weigh similar to what Sickboy or Nay have come up with..........sub 60lbs which would give an easy 100lbs of storage capacity and still come under the 200lbs of your average aftermarket bumper like a SLEE /Hanna/4x4Labs/etc.

let me see if i can put together some better looking sketches than the original.....
 
i see people in 40's with their racks hanging off the back with there coolers and such. We have the same amount of space available. It just happens to be located under our roof and behind a hatch in the vehicle.
 
My bumper weighs less than the stock stuff I cut off/removed, including the spare tire winch. So yes, you can go light.

I am assuming you use your 3rd row of seats. If not, I cannot imagine why you need more room, just put light stuff on a roof rack (my Garvin is about 80 lbs) and heavy stuff in the huge cargo area.

Now if you use your 3rd row like me (four kids), what I have done is move the spare tire into the cargo area. Yes, a 35x10.5x16 SSR will strap down perfectly with no contact on the glass but still wedged between the lower part of the hatch and seats. The hi-lift lays on the floor between tire and seats, and tools/first aid and other goodies sit to the side and behind the tire.

Without having to deal with a spare, you could easily build some sort of system that is not so long but still holds a lot of stuff.

Of course, all of this is like guys who spend $4K on mountain bikes to shed two lbs of bike weight when they could lose 20. I think once you have committed to needing a refrigerator, for example, that the idea of a trailer being a problem is quite clearly an issue of the horse already having left the barn. The problem is in needing both a refrigerator and a hardcore rig at the same time, not so much where you put the fridge. :popcorn:
 
How much lift do you have? The mock-up rig you are using is on a 6" lift with 37's. This won't buy you that much space if your spare now has to go inside, if your spare is still in the stock location take a hard look at departure angle on 33's.

To my earlier post, though, this would buy me a lot of extra convenient space. I personally don't mind using a roof rack, and the 80 can handle the weight for sure. But it would be convenient for camping trips to put the cooler and some other stuff back there.

Good luck if you do it - will be cool to see how it turns out.
 
yeah spare tire definitely is out from underneath...........

hrmmmm....................roof?

or.............................hood!:eek:

255/85 would be skinny enough to see over----and would be just the right size to cover up my sun-baked green paint! Not to mention the redneckaliciousness that would go over so swimmingly with the Marin County Hottubbers.
View attachment 217073
 
Last edited:
that looks slick. just don't back into any trees....

That's why I just got all the stuff for my next week mod: a IR rear view camera hooked to my future new in dash HU which got the related input, of course triggered by the reverse signal.

Now it's a nightmare to reverse parking (and not make a dent on the car hood of the unlucky owners who just had to be there :D)

My wife and I have a contest of who have more marks on his/her gun..... sorry steering wheel, from counting rear backing victims and our insurance company is grilling us :crybaby:
 
Back
Top Bottom