Anti Trailer Thread continued

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 3, 2005
Threads
370
Messages
4,889
Location
Bay Area
Theres an interesting thread over on the Exped.Portal highlighting the basic idea that most trailers (700lbs not including cargo) are very heavy. For some....fj40 and smaller cargo capacity type vehicles....a trailer is really the only option to gain some serious cu.feet of capacity.
for us 80series bruthas- we are blessed with oodles of cargo space already..........and for me personally- a 700lb trailer- to carry 500lbs of crap is a bit overkill.

In an ideal world- we all should be a bit more friendly to our beasts drivetrain-brakes and suspension by becoming a bit more minimalist in nature.........but like many--we all have various situations(girlfriends/kids/etc) that end up pushing the 80 to its gills.

My solution in its early conceptual stage is to push the basic trailer hitch based cargo carrier idea a bit. Most of the traditional ideas are fairly low slung-tail dragging-wire mesh-non-mud friendly-wobbly nightmares when it comes to getting offroad.

Id like to get some 80centric feedback on what people think of the following idea:

-tire carrier mounted- slide over swing out carrier/modular/easy to get on off......much more stable than single mount hitch point

- sits taller but still gives rear visability.
-easier to store than roofrack or trailer
-swing out for easy hatch access.
-better aerodynamics than roof rack
-sealed container
-good angle of departure
-sits between tailights 58"width/ 40" height/depth tbd. (total anywhere from 12cu.feet up fairly easily at the same depth as a 35"tire on your avg. carrier.
-weight (only load with bulky lighter items and leave heavier stuff in cab for COG issues.
-modular to slide over carrier to eliminate hitch wobble
-58"width to give taillight visibility(between tailights)
-built around tube bumper and swingout carrier for lighter weight to offset the box weight and end up in the lbs of your avg- 4x4labs bumper/slee/hanna/arb bumpers.

Im curious if people forsee any other issues and how they like or dislike the concept???
View attachment 216514
 
Last edited:
If it is big enough for what you want. I would rather have that then a trailer or roof rack. I only use my trailer when I need it because it is a bit more of a pain then no trailer. Some times I load messy stuff to the back now. Like the charcoal grill.

265702530_X3Nrs-X2.jpg
 
To each his own for sure but the last thing I want is a couple hundred pounds of stuff hanging off the back of my rig to add to the stresses already on the rear suspension. Not only that but you can't get rid of it without unpacking it like you can uncouple a trailer. Opening the rear doors could be a pain as well. Thats a lot of weight for a spindle of any size to hold. I'm sticking with my trailer, thank you.
 
it seems like a trailer might put less strain on the drivetrain. Once it is moving it doesn't take much to maintain the momentum. I know it takes a lot less effort to transport my 20 lb daughter a mile in a 30 lb stroller than it does to just pick her up and carry her, even in a backpack.
 
To each his own for sure but the last thing I want is a couple hundred pounds of stuff hanging off the back of my rig to add to the stresses already on the rear suspension. Not only that but you can't get rid of it without unpacking it like you can uncouple a trailer. Opening the rear doors could be a pain as well. Thats a lot of weight for a spindle of any size to hold. I'm sticking with my trailer, thank you.

But a 1400lb trailer will easily have the same couple hundred pounds of tongue weight...........(ideally it would be bulky items(vs heavy) and stay well within the tongue weight that a trailer imparts).

Also in a situation where the cruiser is going up a hill--and the trailer is going down a hill----the tongue weight changes even more drastically as the trailer is shoving down on the rear end of the rig----and in effect increasing tongue weight. The rear cargo hold idea forces one to consider weight inside it---and possibly decide to load heavier items behind the front seats. Measuring tongue weight on a level surface isnt the same as the forces that the trailer applies in real world conditions. So that 10-15% level tongue weight of 120-150lbs quickly jumps up when you get offroad-----offering no less weight than the few hundred pounds of a cargo hold in real world offroad driving conditions that arent purely flat salt flats.

As far as accessing the rear hatch---it will be on a swingout.
 
Last edited:
Depends on the camping experience objective. I tow a 3000lb tent trailer for the family of 5 at the state park, pismo, etc. If the goal is driving over extreme terrain then the trailer stays home and we pack like backpackers instead. Snow Weekend in Tahoe we will pack like we are staying in a motel because we are. If the goal is to traverse extreme terrain then I don't want stuff hanging off the ass end. Clearance issues aside, I was amazed at how much even some bicycles (5 in total) affected handling on the road when slung off the back. If you can live out of a kayak or bicycle for weeks then you should be able to pack the same way to fit everything in a cruiser.
 
it seems like a trailer might put less strain on the drivetrain. Once it is moving it doesn't take much to maintain the momentum. .
Weight is weight---Trailers add alot of weight- and rolling resistance. (again- if you need 25+cu feet of capacity theres no alternative) Im simply saying that after hemming and hawwing over a trailer--i realized that for 15cu feet of capacity and less than 300lbs-----a cargo hold saves you about 700lbs and appears to be a smarter solution than a trailer.

Trailer adds more rolling resistance....cargo doesnt if the rear wheels are properly inflated and able to bear the load.

If the rear axle can handle a 4x4labs bumper(200lbs)double swingout 35"tires (180lbs) Jerry cans (50lbs) Hi lift (30lbs?) Im sure it can handle a 75lb cargo carrier with lots of bulky and lighter gear inside.

Momentum of trailer is not different than the momentum of the cruiser......its just to step on the gas and pull an extra 700lbs of trailer with added rolling resistance is bound to be greater than a cargo hold............the only instance in which this isnt true would be a trip completely downhill where the heavier object will have greater momentum. (not realistic driving condition). What you gain on your trip downhill from Tahoe To Sacto---is completely negated on the trip up to Tahoe.(a more balanced look at driving conditions).
 
Last edited:
The only reason I see to pull a trailer is to carry a whole lotta weight in it. Otherwise its a PITA to justify.

bugsnbikes concept drawing is neat, but it will be heavy by itself, so if you only put lightweight things in it what's the point? External, heavy duty storage like that should be for spare tires, hi-lifts, jerry cans and other bulky, difficult-to-carry-inside stuff. The issue I see with your idea (which is a cool idea) is that essentially you are fabbing an all-purpose cargo bin. So you'll have a big metal box back there... but all you can really put in it is soft goods that won't beat each other to a pulp or implode. It greatly hinders access to the rear hatch, which may not be a concern for you. It's about the same size as a drawer system or box.

Its hard to design an all purpose cargo container without identifying the cargo. If it's going to hold backpacks, tents, propane stoves, sleeping bags, camp chairs... our Yakima Space Cadet holds 15 cubic feet of that kind of stuff. It isn't hardcore expedition style, but it weighs 35 lbs, is waterproof and lockable, and goes on and off in a few minutes.
yak.webp
 
Depends on the camping experience objective. I tow a 3000lb tent trailer for the family of 5 at the state park, pismo, etc. If the goal is driving over extreme terrain then the trailer stays home and we pack like backpackers instead. Snow Weekend in Tahoe we will pack like we are staying in a motel because we are. If the goal is to traverse extreme terrain then I don't want stuff hanging off the ass end. Clearance issues aside, I was amazed at how much even some bicycles (5 in total) affected handling on the road when slung off the back. If you can live out of a kayak or bicycle for weeks then you should be able to pack the same way to fit everything in a cruiser.

x3000678

If you cant fit it in,you need to take less or get a bigger truck. Trailers really stress your vehicle in heavy going and suck fuel. I would take one down a dirt road but not any further
I imagine having a basket hanging off the end could be a real hazad on a slippery road.

My favourite trailer offroad thread:D
Cape York - Be prepared - Australian 4WD Action Online Forums
 
I kinda like the idea. I'm not sure I'd buy one but it'd be worth building a prototype to try out. I've got a Slee rear bumper so the spare tire already makes access to the rear hatch more difficult on a regular basis. I personally like the roof top Rocket box solution for extended travel when you've got a family's worth of camping gear - then there's room in back of the spare tire for some bikes.
 

That right there is some funny sheit. A man's got to know his limitations!

Also, funny to hear an Aussi talk of not liking trailers. I think most of the ideas that are on this forum about camping in comfort are gleaned from the Australia market. Tons of great ideas. You guys really go in style.

If I were going to go really off road like your thread I certainly wouldn't take a trailer. I would take your advise and go light, and that would mean without my wife. She wouldn't put up with that for ten seconds. Her idea of roughing it is a Holiday Inn without a fridge in the room.
 
That right there is some funny sheit. A man's got to know his limitations!

Also, funny to hear an Aussi talk of not liking trailers. I think most of the ideas that are on this forum about camping in comfort are gleaned from the Australia market. Tons of great ideas. You guys really go in style.

If I were going to go really off road like your thread I certainly wouldn't take a trailer. I would take your advise and go light, and that would mean without my wife. She wouldn't put up with that for ten seconds. Her idea of roughing it is a Holiday Inn without a fridge in the room.

Each time I come back I take note of the gear I didnt need or didnt use and think twice about taking it next time.
Gone from a full vehicle to one that I can easily find things and be loaded/unloaded in half the time.
I can enjoy myself more now:D

Most of the motoring groups and the police recommend no trailers offroad in central Australia if your doing the desert tracks.
If you have to leave a trailer behind they track you down and give you the $7k clean up bill.

It also tears up fragile tracks with all the extra wheel spin.

I cant rough it for too long though. I can probably do 4-5 nights in the bush then need 2 nights at the Holiday Inn to recover:D
Im a sucker for air con and swimming pools with palm trees and drinks service:grinpimp:
 
I'm trecking round our Lake Superior this summer and the trailer is going along because I'm camping every night and need to take my camp kitchen and all my photo gear. I'm going to try my hardest to resist temptation for a roof over my head. Going to break in the RTT. Got the hot shower and the cold beer in the fridge and a few good cigars. What else is needed?!

I agree with the "tread lightly" philosophy! Leave it like you found it, or better. :cheers:
 
But wouldn't you drag that thing if you did this:

47b7d606b3127cceba1c3e0ba70700000026108EatWzFu0cO
 
I think that a roof rack, trailer or cargo back like you suggest all depend on where you are going, what and who you are bringing, and camping style among other things. I use to think a trailer was a PITA but now:
I have voluminous space
Don't have to search for things (lots of organization)
Don't have to unpack everything when I get to camp or get home
Don't have to repack valuables when I leave camp (lock the trailer)
Have room for many people and their gear without feeling cramped
Have a sink, running water and multiple horizontal space

I also have a roofrack but don't actually use it much because its a pain to load and unload all the time. When I had limited space it seemed like the truck gets more abused because things get stuffed in every corner and people are always digging around for s***. If you have a fairly streamlined camp then maybe your idea provides sufficient space but I know from my experience if I am setting up a camp for over a week this would not give me enough space if I was carrying 3 other people. That being said 10 years ago my camps were spartan and I could do without certain luxuries:D. As others have also pointed out having quick access to the back hatch is also important for me which is why I am not to fond of swingouts.

Just out of curiosity why not run two large cargo boxes on the roof? I always thought this was one of the easiest ways to deal with extra space and seems to have an equivalent amount of space.
 
The main reason to avoid the roof for me is that:

I go offroad....COG.

A roof rack is a 120lb penalty before even getting 100lbs of gear up there(200lbs total easy). Id much rather have that 200lbs at bumper height than 4feet higher.

Trailers are the same impediment---700lb barrier to entry for 200lbs worth of gear. (i just dont carry enough to get to where a trailer makes sense) Offroad i end up moving campground daily or every few days. Rarely do i make a basecamp for days on end and come back to it. So dumping a trailer doesnt do me any good---it HAS to come along---and it isnt going to be as friendly to the overall weight situation as well as offroadability (in my case).

The Cargo box in an ideal world shifts bulky lightweight items which tend to take up the bulk of the 100cu ft of space in my cruiser.

The heavy items: dual deep cycle Lifelines(130lbs)
Compressor (40lbs) tank(10)
Jerry Cans (80lbs/2)
Water (100liters- 160lbs)
Food/fridge (100lbs)
Wood(sometimes-40lbs)
----these just dont take up a ton of space frankly. 500lbs of it is currently residing under my full length (no seats) bed/storage/sleep platform which sits just 10" of height from the floor of the vehicle. Thats 500lbs of cargo---at or below the front seat height in the vehicle. Awesome for COG.

The light items: tent/sleeping bags/chairs/stove/clothing bags/ biking
gear/ biking tools-parts/ thermarests/pillows/
backpacks/ biking backpacks. These all weight much less---but end up taking up the 34"x60"x70" space above the full length rear bed.....................so sleeping in the rear entails shifting all this light STUFF out of the vehicle///under tarps in case of rain///off ground in case of mud/// generally a PITA when all you want to do is grab some shuteye. Even if this stuff is 150lbs........added to a roofbox--or roofracks.....quickly gets up to that 200+lb COG issue.

A cargo for me would start to eliminate this---so that the majority of bulky stuff goes in the cargo hold----a few things get tossed into the front seat space............and theres no worrying about securing gear from overnight/rain/mud/bears/outside the vehicle. 150lbs+75lb of cargo box of gear hanging off the rear is just not much different than a 200lb bumper which no one seems to worry about.........and seems like the no brainer solution for those with sub 250lbs of stuff and maybe 12-15cu feet of space needs.

GRanted it will make the rear end look like a Unimog Camper rear end..................but such is life.......if it looks funny------but doesnt worsen COG-or add a few 100 unnecessary lbs.....im happy. Id much rather free up a few hundred pounds for underbody protection/ a few 100 more amp hour batts/ or 100lbs more of water/food/etc.
 
Last edited:
After 30 years of trips to our rain forest paradise camping place were we stay up to 2 weeks, driving on very narrow roads, when sometimes we need to cross mud traps which can be up to the door handle, (with my roof tent) there is no way I will pull a trailer.

I saw others rigs pulling trailers but next year they came without them. The only ones who keep pulling trailers are the ones who carry a couple of motorcycles.

Since I have a reinforced custom hitch receiver at the OEM 4 bolt location (with inside braces to the frame) I tried a couple of trips with a 500 lbs cargo carrier hooked on it, but it was pain in the ass because I had to remove it to access the tailgate.

So I went to the swinging idea, cutting in half a aluminum cargo carrier, making with the 2 halves a removable double deck hooked to a modified tire carrier on which I welded two hitch receivers to hold them. Okay It can't hold too much weight but we carry many items which take a lot space but doesn't weight a lot.

I got the aux gas tank and have to use a tire carrier so for me is the same if I have to swing the tire carrier and also the dual deck cargo carrier to open the rear lift window.

By the way I use a single drawer and on top of it my 60 qts Engel refrigerator leaving the right side of the rear cargo area to all the remaining stuff.

One thing by sure, every year I carry less and less items, seems the "what if" disease is cured. LOL
 
Last edited:
With so many people owning roof boxes, I personally would love to see a very simple and strong frame that uses the powerful trailer hitch receiver and creates artificial "roof rails" back there. Then, you can attach a Thule roof rack to it and your rocket box. So, it's kinda like sliding the roof rack off the roof where it causes clearance and COG issues, but allows you to use a dustproof, rain proof box many of us already own to store extra gear. Interestingly, this setup would also permits you to mount one of those flexible cargo bags behind the cargo door.

Overall, I think this is a good idea and further I think as vehicles shrink in the US in response to the fuel prices there will be more needs for external temporary storage solutions like this on all sizes of cars. Everyone's going to downsize and we 'mericans are notoriously resistant to packing less.


DougM
 
There are some nice trailers around and one like this would be hard to leave at home:D Thats it fully erected in the back ground;)
79 series 016 (Small).webp
 
Doug idea is quite interesting cause so many people own the roof box but unfortunately there are some cons regarding it's big odd size, the hitch rack support should hold it in a high position as to avoid any trail clearance and some people noted their concern about anything hanging in the rear that could limit the rear lift gate opening, meaning that this hitch roof box support should have also some kind of slide hinge.

It would be interesting that Dave DMC could chime in, after his real life, in site experiences on his expedition from Panama to Chile. He could provide many tips on what items we should carry and what let at home and from there we could learn and decide which is the best way to carry our stuff based in our own specific needs but without wasting money in something that after a couple of trips will end on our garage or ebay.

I recall a couple of years ago we made a 7 day trip on which I was the only one with a battery powered freezer / refrigerator and the other 4 cruisers had coolers. They were making fun on me because they were counting on a small town ice machine to buy ice for the last 3 days of the expedition and guess what: the machine was damaged. Lo and behold we had to eat as fast as possible all the others unfrozen food, set my Engel to freeze temp as preserve all their remaining food because it was impossible to me to make ice on time to fill the other's coolers.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom