3FE Runs Poorly in Closed Loop, Okay in Open Loop - fixed

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Threads
15
Messages
329
Location
Nova Scotia
Hoping for some help from 3FE gurus, and/or early Denso (Bosch) fuel injection gurus. I've attached a .pdf of the 3FE engine control wiring diagram for reference.

The Long Version: (Short Version to follow in next post)


Basically, my 3FE powered 80 had an intermittent running issue when I bought it where it would hesitate like it was lean in the mid-range, then it would surge ahead if you stomped on the pedal. It also had a low and rough idle, where the RPM would bounce significantly with the signal lights :confused:. A couple of times it also bogged down, popped and crackled and wouldn't accelerate. I had originally thought it was vapour locking due to heat from the header, as it seemed to get better in colder weather.

Eventually I found a big vacuum hose to the charcoal canister had popped off, putting that back fixed the poor idle, most of the fluctuation with signal lights and made it seem to run decent, but with poor fuel economy based on what I'm used to for a 3FE.

I started having issues again (which I later found out were due to that vacuum hose popping off again), but I figured out through trial and error that the hesitation would consistently go away above 2800-ish RPM or at/near Wide Open Throttle. I came to learn that these are some of the conditions where the computer goes from "closed loop" to "open loop" for acceleration enrichment etc.. With the vacuum line put back it ran pretty good, again with poor fuel economy.

Had a look underneath, and low and behold the custom exhaust had no O2 sensor bungs at all, so I had been running without O2 correction this whole time. No Check Engine Light. Welded in some O2 bungs and installed some new Denso O2 sensors. Now consistent hesitation/lean-feeling in closed loop, rough idle (600rpm-ish).

Did a long afternoon of troubleshooting. Pulled the glovebox, found the CEL wire coming from the ECU was clipped. Re-attached and there was indeed a Check Engine Light, codes 21 and 28 (open circuit/deterioration of O2 sensors 1+2). Got out the multimeter and verified continuity between OX1/OX2 at the ECU, check connector under the hood, and the plugs underneath. Verified +12V getting from ECU to O2 sensor plugs. Issues still present, code 21+28 still present. Thought the O2 sensor connectors might be corroded and dirty from dangling under the vehicle for God knows how long, tried cleaning them. No luck. Also wasn't sure if I was getting a reference signal from the sensors via OX1/OX2 (I know now that its a 0-1V signal, I didn't know that then so I can't say 100% that I was getting a signal or not) Got frustrated, unplugged the sensors.

On a road trip, I had issues with various other things, high beams, power windows, etc that I traced to the ground in the driver's side footwell. It also appeared that the shielding(?) for the OX1/OX2 signal wires were grounded there? Not sure how that works.

Another day of troubleshooting. Got somewhat reliable voltage signals at OX1/OX2 at the connector now. I managed to get code 21 to go away, but code 28 remained persistent. I tried swapping out for another 3FE ECU I had and code 28 went away. I'm guessing that circuit in the ECU was just tortured? I opened up the ECU case but saw nothing obvious. It still runs the same. Replaced all the vacuum lines, as well as both intake boots. Pulling 16-17inHg of vacuum at idle, which seems a little weak. Sprayed brakekleen and quick start all around the intake manifold joints and anywhere I could think of, no luck on any other vacuum leaks. Verified the TPS function as per the FSM, passed all tests. Checked fuel pressure and got 43psi (supposed to be 37-46psi). This 3FE was de-smogged and they deleted the fuel pressure-up VSV, so it sees the full pressure all the time. Going to put that VSV back once I figure this issue out. I connected the FPR hose to manifold vacuum and got 39psi (supposed to be 33-37psi).

I feel like I'm getting closer but I was hoping the TPS was it. Short version coming next post.
 

Attachments

Short Version:
3FE with questionable maintenance history and a running issue under closed loop. Runs great with O2 sensors unplugged and no obvious vacuum leaks. Plugging in O2 sensors introduces the hesitation issue.

Issues:
  • Hesitation/poor acceleration under moderate revs, part throttle. Feels lean.
    • This goes away like a light switch under open loop (over 2800rpm, or WOT)
  • Poor idle when warmed up, 500-600RPM and rough.
  • Intermittent very low idle/stalling issue (shut engine off and re-start and it starts/runs normal)
  • Poor fuel economy overall
  • Check engine light, codes 21-28 (code 21 solved with installation of O2 sensor, code 28 solved by replacing ECU, but issues persist as before)

Other factors with truck:
  • The custom exhaust had no O2 sensors bungs in it when I bought it
  • CEL wire from ECU was clipped
  • Obvious signs of the ECU having been pulled out/troubleshot (ECU connectors all marked up, brackets missing screws, wear, small hole in ECU B+ wire, maybe someone stuck a multi-meter probe through it in a previous troubleshooting effort?)
  • 80% of a de-smog done. Air injection rail and EGR valve remain, bottom pipe of EGR valve is welded shut.
  • Fuel filter has been replaced at some point

What I've done so far:
  • Installed O2 sensors
  • Repaired a ground in driver's footwell (helped with the signal light/idle fluctuation, may have helped O2 sensor issue, not sure)
  • Replaced every vacuum hose (no change)
  • Replaced both big intake boots with new (no change)
  • Tested TPS as per FSM (good)
  • Adjusted valves
  • Compression is 150-148-140-137-130-158 (crappy old compression tester)
  • Pulling 16-17inHg at idle, can't find any leaks, but it does sound almost like there is one (I'm at sea level, seems weak)
  • Checked spark plugs (seem unremarkable to me, will post pics)
  • Checked fuel pressure (43 psi without vacuum, 39 psi with vacuum)

Things I still need to do:
  • Replace fuel filter (have a new one)
  • Check timing, set base timing as per FSM
  • Check fuel pump/replace fuel sock (have a new sock)
  • Make a smoke tester for vacuum leaks
  • Test AFM
  • Test coolant temp sensor
  • Test IAC motor??
 
Last edited:
Misc. thoughts:
  • If it runs well with the O2 sensors unplugged, it must be lean under closed loop (O2's plugged in), as O2 unplugged must be a rich (safe) map? How rich I wonder?
  • As I understand, there is a fuel pump resistor that is sometimes bypassed byt the ECU, sending more voltage to the fuel pump under some conditions. Is open loop acceleration enrichment one of those conditions? If the fuel filter or pump were compromised, maybe that extra voltage is supplying enough fuel for it to run properly?
  • Am I getting too much air or not enough fuel? Is there anywhere that might not be obvious where 3FEs love to leak vacuum?
  • Hard to say if the de-smog was done by dummies, who deleted the O2 sensors and clipped the CEL wire because they thought they were emissions related, or if a previous owner troubleshot this issue, got frustrated, realized it ran fine with the O2's unplugged, clipped the CEL wire and was "done with it".

Anyone have any ideas?
 
Some good info on how the 3FE's injection system works in the 1988 New Car Features Manual: 1988 New Features
 
The 3FE doesn't have a fuel pump resistor. The only interaction between the fuel pump and the ecu is the VSV for the fuel pump regulator which you say has been removed.
The FP is run by the flap in the AFM and the starter circuit.
 
The 3FE doesn't have a fuel pump resistor. The only interaction between the fuel pump and the ecu is the VSV for the fuel pump regulator which you say has been removed.
The FP is run by the flap in the AFM and the starter circuit.
Glad to see you’re still posting Jon. Read many of your posts on the 3FE subject.

With the VSV removed (as it was on my last 3FE, which ran great), this would have the engine tending slightly rich due to the added fuel pressure, no? One would think that the O2 sensor correction, if functioning properly, would dial back some, if not all, of that extra fuel?

The weird thing is, even with the O2 sensors unplugged and the extra fuel pressure, all it takes is one medium sized vacuum like to pop off and it runs lean in open loop as well.

I’m wondering if delivering the specified fuel pressure at idle is no problem, but then starves due to a plugged filter when under load? Still doesn’t explain the poor idle.

Going to replace the fuel filter and sock, set the timing and report. If that doesn’t fix it, I guess I’ll build a smoke tester.

Anything I’m missing?
 
Poor/rough idle is almost always due to a vacuum leak somewhere. Any unmetered air getting into the system will cause a poor idle. The top half of the motor wants to be air tight. I would start with that and a good tune up using OEM parts. Have a look my tune up document.
 
Also be sure that the water temp sensor (green connector) on the thermostat housing is functioning correctly.

3FE StatHousing.webp
 
Keep in mind that this is first generation fuel injection on a tractor motor, designed in 1986. While the ECU does control injector timing, ignition timing, etc, it's only as reliable as the sensors feeding it. The ECU has very narrow windows of operation for each sensor, and all mechanical adjustments need to be done FIRST.
 
Also be sure that the water temp sensor (green connector) on the thermostat housing is functioning correctly.

View attachment 3452435
I'll second this recommendation. The water temp sensor with the green connector (8942220010) tells the ECU whether to run in open/close loop based on water temp. Make sure it & the wiring to it aren't toast.
 
Time to get to work!
 
90202A0F-30E3-4E8F-8D5F-69F1E1FB28CE.webp

533A67C6-ECEB-47A4-A01D-B07F50DAA760.webp

6455E7FC-0A61-48F7-9D4C-7F4C95E81CA9.webp
 
Hallelujah! Seems I’ve fixed it.

- New fuel filter
- Timing was way out. Looks like someone timed it without jumping TE1 and E1 pins and so it was very retarded

And, most importantly:

The O2 sensors were backwards.

This thing has a custom exhaust, and the pigtails had to be dug out of the harness. Wasn’t clear which went where, and the only time I switched them was when I was troubleshooting with an unknown large vacuum leak, and a bricked ECU, so it wasn’t obvious that it made a difference. Clearly with a batch-fire EFI system this is quite important.

So there it is. From the start:
- big vacuum leak
- no o2 correction, then backward o2 correction
- toasted ECU
- very retarded timing

Surprised the thing even ran, let alone decent enough to have driven the past 10,000km I’ve put on the truck.

Thanks to those that chimed in!
 
sorry to bother again but what type of pressure tester is that and what types of hookup, banjo bolt or what? Can you show me what you used
Look at the first picture on page FI-48.
 
Back
Top Bottom