Sure, if we were talking about identical mint condition, but in this case you have the same car restored, and one with rust, funky pin striping, the wrong wheels and tires and while a nice driver, is in no way mint OG condition.
The cruiser mania of years ago is past, and as boomers die prices for classic cars are dropping. The kids don't want grandpa's muscle car or Landcruiser. If I wanted the best price for something I would sell yesterday, it's not going to get better tomorrow. Maybe in 10 years but I doubt it.