- Thread starter
- #141
With older vehicles, knobs worked great because they were directly controlling things. If the fan knob was on “3”, the fan was on “3”.
The difference with this system is that it’s electronic and state-based. The HVAC ECU is constantly making decisions on its own (especially in Auto mode), and things like fan speed and airflow can change in the background.
That creates an interesting problem:
If you use a traditional knob with fixed positions, it can end up showing something different than what the system is actually doing.
Example:
Same idea applies on startup. The system may already have a stored temperature or mode, but the knobs don’t know where to “start” from.
So the question becomes more about:
Do the controls represent a fixed position?
Or do they simply tell the system to go up/down/change state?
Modern vehicles have mostly moved away from fixed-position knobs for this exact reason, they use things like up/down controls or infinite-turn dials so the system always stays in sync.
Still working through what makes the most sense here.
The difference with this system is that it’s electronic and state-based. The HVAC ECU is constantly making decisions on its own (especially in Auto mode), and things like fan speed and airflow can change in the background.
That creates an interesting problem:
If you use a traditional knob with fixed positions, it can end up showing something different than what the system is actually doing.
Example:
- You set the fan to 2
- Turn on Auto
- System ramps fan up to 5 on its own
Same idea applies on startup. The system may already have a stored temperature or mode, but the knobs don’t know where to “start” from.
So the question becomes more about:
Do the controls represent a fixed position?
Or do they simply tell the system to go up/down/change state?
Modern vehicles have mostly moved away from fixed-position knobs for this exact reason, they use things like up/down controls or infinite-turn dials so the system always stays in sync.
Still working through what makes the most sense here.