Warn M12000 overheating? Needs Maintenance?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 12, 2006
Threads
124
Messages
1,109
Location
St. Louis, MO
Warn M12000 overheating?
I posted this in the recovery forum Friday but no luck with help, so I thought I'd try here as I know this is a popular winch for the 80.

======
REPOST
======

So I purchased my Warn M12000 in 2000 and have never used it for self-extraction (not that I'm complaining). I have used it to pull out a small tree and a few shrubs in tight spots, but generally avoid this as I find the 80 can yank these things out just fine if there is room. I've used the winch a time or two to extract others, but again, avoid this. So in all, I may have used the winch 5-6 occassions and only short pulls and not for long. It is mounted in an ARB winch bar and is unprotected from the elements. There is slight surface rust on the drum, but that seems to be it.

Now, today I was out in the 'country' clearing trees from some new property in preparation for a bridge pour. In short, I can only access the property across a small creek and to get the trees out for the bridge I had to fall them and then drag them up the creek bed for cutting. I opted to use the winch as the creek bed is pretty steep. The largest tree was about 10-12 inch diamteter and most were no more than 8, but a few were pretty tall. I can't imagine any of these things weighed more than 1,000 lbs. I had to drag most of them about 100 ft each (so I was using most of the winch line for each tree). After dropping them, I threw a chain around each and hooked up the winch and pulled them up - without ever a problem.

However, after dragging out 4 of them, the winch just stopped working. I checked for a loose connection at the remote but it looked fine. Also, the winch would still spool out, just not in. I waited a few minutes and everything worked fine. Would this normally overheat given the light use? Or maybe spooling out 100 ft and then back in with a load isn't light use - especially if done 5-10 times in a row with just 10 minutes or so between trees (to cut up the one I pulled out). Should I be looking at maintenance in the near future? What is the maintenance (I will pull the manual out this weekend, I'm just curious if anyone has a quick answer)?

I did notice that even when working the winch would stall for a second and click loudly at each rotation. I can't say if this is normal b/c I've rarely ever used the thing. I've never done any maintenance b/c . . . well . . . I've hardly ever used the thing. But now I'm wondering if maintenance SHOULD have been done simply b/c it is exposed to the weather. I noticed the area under/around the control box was a bit warm, but not really THAT hot.

Any thoughts? I'm leaving next week for a 2-month trek up through northern minnesota and canada in and around the boundry waters area, so I'd really like to know everything is working before I go. Also, I noticed that if I moved the clutch to 'free spool' to pull out the cable, it was REALLY hard to pull out. Even with my 250 lbs I had such a tough time that I ended up using the remote to spool out (maybe this added to the heat issue).

Thanks!
 
even with light loads the run time is important to keep down...because of the bushings...bearings in the motor would increase run time.

when pulling trees...how long do you run the winch...per pull?

you may even have some gunk in the winch...which is making it work harder than it should...it sound like
 
Three thoughts come to mind.

Were you powering out the line? Powering out causes overheating.

If that's not it, the next thought is that non-overloaded motors can overheat because of low voltage. Are you pretty sure the winch has fat enough wires that it's getting its full 12-13v?

Lastly, you were using the winch for something it wasn't designed for. Pulling 400 feet (4 trees, 100 feet each), even moderately loaded, may not be withing the design limits of the winch.

My 2 cents...

T.
 
when pulling trees...how long do you run the winch...per pull?

The basic scenario was that we would pull the winch cable across the creek to the downed tree (shortest pull was about 70 ft but most were in the same area at about 100 ft), wrap a chain around the trunk at the cut, then winch it back across the creek and up the side to the service road for cutting. I don't know the spool-in speed for the M12000, but I'm guessing it was able to do this every time in under 5 minutes (seemed like about 3-4 minutes). It never seemed to bog down except once when one of the trees got caught on the embankment - I stopped the winch and just put the cruiser in reverse and it pulled the tree out with little more than the engine idle (otherwise, I've been told not to pull in reverse for gearing reasons). However, if you count the 3 minutes it took to power out the line across the creek, a 30 second break to wrap the chain, then 3 minutes back with the tree under load, and it could conceivably be as much as 10 minutes of power out followed by a nearly immediate power-in under load.

Were you powering out the line? Powering out causes overheating.

If that's not it, the next thought is that non-overloaded motors can overheat because of low voltage. Are you pretty sure the winch has fat enough wires that it's getting its full 12-13v?

Lastly, you were using the winch for something it wasn't designed for. Pulling 400 feet (4 trees, 100 feet each), even moderately loaded, may not be withing the design limits of the winch.
T.

You may be correct regarding your first and third thoughts (they were my concerns as well).

First, I was powering out the line (it was really hard to pull it out in the free-spool mode). I wonder even more if it needs service b/c I thought it should be relatively easy to pull out by hand with the clutch in free-spool. I think powering out ~100ft and then winching a load back may have lead to overheating. I just don't know if this means I need to service the winch or just don't do this in the future.

Second, I don't think it was short any voltage. I followed the specs of many here on mud including Christo and George (I think they were all on 80scool at that time?) when I set it up. I used 2/0 welding cable and supplies and I used two optima blue tops that are recently replaced with two more optima blue tops, and I made certain both batteries were supplying the winch before the first pull (via a marine switch).

Third, I still think you may be right on this one too. I'm thinking the 125 ft of cable is there for a reason, but not this one. In theory, the long cable is there to reach an anchor point and then the winch will pull the cruiser free which should only be the lenth of the cruiser (even a long mud bog should not require 100ft of line winching under load). I was just thinking that the trees were so light (relative to the winch capacity) that it wouldn't be a problem. I think if I continue this in the future (and I was hoping to do so) that I need to pull out the line by hand in the free-spool mode, and then winch back with longer breaks between trees for cool-down.

Thanks to you both for the quick help. I think it is safe to leave next week without major service to the winch.
 
If you were powering out, that was probably the cause of the overheating. With the orbital winches, the owners manuals should tell you that powering out over any distance will cause you to overheat.

If you can't manually spool out easily, you probably need some maintenance to fix that problem.
 
If you were powering out, that was probably the cause of the overheating. With the orbital winches, the owners manuals should tell you that powering out over any distance will cause you to overheat.

Just as an aside, why would powering out a winch cause overheating? I rebuilt my M12K some years ago and it's gears and a motor. In reverse you're just reversing polarity on the motor. Please elaborate.
 
I have a new M12.
I can easily pull out the cable by hand. I'd guess the effort required is less than it takes to drag a heavy suitcase on the floor at the airport. (sorry, couldn't come up with any better on short notice... :))
 
Just as an aside, why would powering out a winch cause overheating? I rebuilt my M12K some years ago and it's gears and a motor. In reverse you're just reversing polarity on the motor. Please elaborate.

Based on what I've read in my owners manual and on web sites, here's the problem:

The orbital winches have brakes to make sure they don't allow free spool if power is lost. This way you don't send yourself careening back into a ditch if you lose voltage or have some other problem.

When you power spool out, the winch is essentially overpowering the brake to spook out the line. It's like driving with your ebrake on.

My 9.5 XP specifically described this in the owners manual, and said that powering out the line was to release tension, and would cause overheating if used more than briefly.

Based on what I've read, this limitation is common to all orbital winches. I did quite a bit of reading on this when I was trying to figure out if it was OK to mount my 9.5XP upside down on my old Slee bumper. I decided it was NOT OK, and I switched to the new slee bumper so I could mount it properly. If I'd mounted upside down, I'd be pulling against the brake when spooling in, and I'd have no brake to keep me from free spooling out.

I'm 95% sure that what's above is accurate.

T.
 
Last edited:
This is what I read for Warn VR12 winch.
D5F38959-3239-41BF-AF17-B5BECCB6ABC7.webp
 
The exact technical term is planetary winch. The motor is tightly packed in one end, the gears (and brake too, IIRC) in the other. You'll note virtually no ventilation. Then think of how hot something with enough amperage to lug 12,000 pounds will get with that flowing through it.

The e-brake thing is a new one on me, but planetary winches in general have to deal with this tendency to overheat. Limiting pull time is rather important, as that's what causes the heat buildup and the lack of ventilation means that radiation (of heat, not anything nuclear) is the main source of cooling. Get one of those infrared-non contact thermometers and track the heat next time you get the winch out -- it's easier than risking blisters on your fingertips.

Free-spooling out removes the power from this part of the use cycle, regardless of whether an e-brake is involved, leaving the winch cooler for when it starts the real pull

Sound like the auto-protect feature of the winch at work and not a electrical failure with the shutdown, but some of the other behavior suggest maybe a solenoid or whatever it uses for contacts/control (the newer ones are electronic and not so prone to failure) may have some issues. Solenoids in particular don't like sitting for long periods as the contacts have tendency to stick or have corrosion issues that may need attention, especially if the winch sits out in the weather.
 
ALL electric winches (including Warn) have a 'duty cycle'. Spooling out under power and then spooling in (without ever stopping) will quickly exceed the duty cycle of most winches.

Don't winch for over 1 minute (regardless the load) without letting the winch motor cool 15-20 minutes and you will be fine.
 
ALL electric winches (including Warn) have a 'duty cycle'. Spooling out under power and then spooling in (without ever stopping) will quickly exceed the duty cycle of most winches.

Don't winch for over 1 minute (regardless the load) without letting the winch motor cool 15-20 minutes and you will be fine.

I'd say the notable exception to this is the old (but still available new) Warn 8274. In fact, it's the go to winch for power out, which you do need in some applications.

Some folks would say you're being conservative with those numbers, but I bet your winch is still a happy camper. Staying cool s what makes winches last.
 
I'd say the notable exception to this is the old (but still available new) Warn 8274. In fact, it's the go to winch for power out, which you do need in some applications.

Some folks would say you're being conservative with those numbers, but I bet your winch is still a happy camper. Staying cool s what makes winches last.

^^^^^^ Yes, I am inclined to agree. Mainly because of the 'speed' of the 8274. It simply doesn't need to run as long as the others. I've put mine (bought new in 1983) through some pretty tough use over the last 35 years.

Even so....you are correct "staying cool' is the name of game for Winches and Automatic Transmissions.
 
Back
Top Bottom