t-case noise: 3spd v 4spd

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Threads
164
Messages
1,924
Location
land of enchantment, at least for now
Is there a definite difference in t-case noise between the two (split cases not included)? I had a 3spd case behind a 350/4500 and it was really noisy, but it had untold mileage on it, so I didn't know whether to attribute it to being a 3spd case or being old. The 4 spd and case in my 40 is much quieter but it only has 47k on it.

I'm debating swapping a 3spd case into my 55 while swapping F for 2F. It's a 1/74 so it's a 4 spd and I already would have the transition gear. It'll be the family fourwheeler, on either 33s or 35s, not a daily driver, but it would get driven to trails, not towed. So is it worth noise for the gearing? I may someday go to an H41 as well. I don't want to give up my PTO winch, at least not yet, so I've already discounted gm tranny swaps, etc.
 
I used some adhesive thermal barrier from Summit on the tranny tunnel and it quieted the noises quite a bit, and my feet don't get cooked anymore.

The gears may be lower with the 3 spd case but the case is suppose to be more brittle. The 4 spd case is suppose to be more durable, but the gears aren't quite as low. I think a few folks have even put the 3 spd gears in the 4 spd case.

So you can use the one you want.

Bret
 
Is a gear swap worth it?

The 3 speed transfer case has a low ratio of 2.31.

The 4 speed transfer case has a low ratio of 1.992.

Personally, if the gears will swap, I wouldn't do it unless I had to pull the units out for some other reason. Like having to do a clutch. As for the 3 speed unit, I'm concerned that it is "more brittle" than the 4 speed case. In my case, I'm running a V-8. I doubt I'd be as concerned with a stock motor.
 
I don't think that there is a big difference in the noise level of the 3sp and 4sp cases as long as they are both in good shape.

I wouldn't bother swapping out a good 4sp case just to get a 15% gear reduction.


Early (up to 69) 3sp cases may be brittle, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they are especially weak. They tend to crack when later cases just stretch. I have seen them hold up to abuse.
 
I have all the drivetrain out, I have the transition gear, and I just found a 3 spd case for free. So I won't be in it much more than a rebuild kit. Maybe when I get it done I can side by side compare the difference with a 4 speed case in my fj-40.
I ran a 3 speed case behind a tbi 350, NV4500 with Dana 60s, 4.88s, Detroits, 36's under a 5600 pound FJ60 for a couple years. Drove it cross country twice, 4+s in Moab several times, jumped it, gave it Hell, and never had any trouble with the case. The gears/bearings finally gave out towing 6000 pounds up a mountain headed back cross-country. Luckily there was another 3speed case in the vehicle being towed. :) Oh yeah, the case I started with came out of a '73 that had been sitting for years and I didn't rebuild it. Can't complain...
 
noise from the transfer case, what are you worried about :confused: Before that, I'd get all kinds of noises or rattles from anywhere else :rolleyes: :D
 
My 3spd trans

howled in all directions, so I went to the 4spd, with new bearings, which is somewhat quieter - it don't whine so much in 4th is bascially it. If you want quiet running, better go hydromatic. I like it noisy because the old lady can't run her yap continously on the cell phone - like she does everywhere else. The later 4spd transfers have helical-cut gears which are supposed to be quieter than the straight-cut gears in the 3spd transfers & early 4spd transfers. The 4spd transfer gears definitely will not fit the 3spd cases - I tried. I did not try the other way around because I didn't have the 16 spline straight-cut input gear. Doing that might mean shimming the cluster since I think the 4spd case is just a bit wider there. The helical gears are much more robust than the 3spd gears, so I question the assertion of some that the 3spd gears are stronger.
 
My now rebuilt 3 speed case, is quieter than my old 4 speed case. My rebuilt split case, is quieter than my rebuilt 3speed case. The noise from my sm420 overwhelms all! It's noisy, but not unhealthy.
 
Corrected

You're right Pin, I don't know how I was left with that recollection. But, hey, that s***'s been happening to me a lot lately.:whoops:
 
IF you want quiet, get a split case.
If you want to wheel it, you're better off getting an H41 or an SM420/465, and run that.
 
Back
Top Bottom