Spring Over Vs. Spring Under

SPRING OVER VS. SPRING UNDER


  • Total voters
    157

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

72cruiser said:
even with old stock springs?

is that just b/c you've been reworking them and they haven't 'settled' yet even though they're not new....?


malphrus

Yep, Old stock springs. They droped an inch on the first run.In the year i've been running it since it has settled another 1/2", and then stopped.
Don't get me wrong, I love my setup.but when I did my cut and turn I pointed the pinion at the t/c and since It settled the pinion points a little high now.Next time I do a cut and turn I will just plan on a little sag.
aw
 
that's cool, i'm still headin that direction (soa) so i'm just tryin to figure out all the stuff...
and i really appreciate all the info that gets discussed here

so when i set it up should i try to account for that droop?


malphrus
 
i don't think it matters if you are a little high on the front pinion angle . doesn't the axle torque down under load . in four wheel drive ?.if it did this would still make diff point straight at the transfer . i could be wrong . i no the rear diff torques up under load a few degrees .
 
72cruiser said:
that's cool, i'm still headin that direction (soa) so i'm just tryin to figure out all the stuff...
and i really appreciate all the info that gets discussed here

so when i set it up should i try to account for that droop?


malphrus


I would if I was doing the cut and turn. Something else to think about would be shock mounts/shock length. If you are cutting things close and allowing for 60% pluss for shock droop and minimal up travel and then you droop untill you only have half of your up travel left.
 
GreenWeeny78 said:
Men-That-Like-It-Up-The-Ass sell lift kits, of course they don't want you going SOA that takes away profits :flipoff2:

Sway bars are for pussies :flipoff2:

We dont tell people dont do spring overs... We say do it right!! We would make more money doing a spring over in the shop anyways. We have done a few in the shop last year. Most people who come in would rather be sprung under. So......... :flipoff2: :flipoff2: :flipoff2:
 
spring - over one of the reasons for the height drop may be (if you did a shackl,e reversal ) may also be from the way the springs compress you will notice before the shackle reversal
the cruiser did not dive forward . when you braked , but after shackle reversal and spring-over
the nosediving during braking is more noticeable . in turn fatigueing the springs slightly . i did notice mine droped about 1 inch in the front after a spring -over and shackle reversal
 
I have done two spring overs and while they have huge advantages and sort of look cool I guess, my only point is that they are BIG. Pretty much the smallest size that works is a 35 and a 35 in my opinion is also a big tire. So, if you want a big ass truck and some big tires then a SOA is for you. And you can make a SOA work on the road but it takes some work to get it completely right. Anyway, 90% of the stuff I feel like you can get up and over with 33's and a 4" lift. But 35's do make a big difference off road. Anyway, I am thinking the next wagon I build will probably be 33's and 4" lift. But I guess I wouldn't know that unless I was SOA. But it does look cool of course... :)
 
I voted SOA.

2.5” SUA is a great set up if you just need the few inches for the use of your rig.
4.0” SUA is a great set up if it fits the budget or you want to keep the truck as original as you can. What I mean by that is not cutting the rear wheel wells on a nice truck. A 4” lift allows you to run the bigger tire yet you can reverse the whole thing if you wish.

Now why SOA?!

First off this is a SOA done right: OE springs, Cut-n-turn front axle, track bar in the rear, and high steer steering set up.

The basic SOA set up right performs better on the street IMO since the OE spring packs give the truck the original ride. I have driven a number of trucks with “soft lifts” and none of them seamed all that soft to me. A custom spring arced to generate lift is just going to be stiffer. Get back into a truck with OE springs and it just goes down the road straight and handles better. (OE springs w/ healthy bushings!) Yes you do get more sway in a SOA truck, sway bars would help. There is another trick to help dampen sway. A few of the Cascade Cruisers have put in the remote adjustable shocks (RS9000) and just stiffen up all the shocks on the street, then open them up on the trail. Works perfect for them.

Going SOA does not mean you have to be way up in the air. Case in point, LT here on the board as (GreenWinnie78) had a 4” lift on his truck prior to SOA. Side by side his hood line was 3-4” higher than my SOA 79’. (Both trucks on 35’s) He did at the time have a true 2” body lift on, but that still sat his SUA higher than my SOA by at least one inch. I run modified leaf packs making the truck sit lower. The modified packs (-1 leaf and one mid leaf is from a 55) also perform and flex more off road. The draw back on the street is they allow axel wrap, so track bars are a must. The benefit on the road the truck handles ruts extremely well since the suspension just sucks them up. I am a firm believer in keeping the truck as low as you can.

Shot of my 79’ SOA 1st in Black Hills, on the Buzz Worms trial, 2nd Bend OR Staging .
More photos: http://www.metaltechcage.com/bhcc_july03/index.htm

Mark


image_34_jpg.jpg

image_14_jpg.jpg
 
Last edited:
I ve had 4" SUA Pro comp springs, liked but not loved. I do love the SOA, you do notice the difference on the trail. I've had some pucker factors, but all in all it works well. I say SOA!
 
Two 1970 FJ40’s stopped by my shop today. Both on 35’s one SUA w/ 4” springs one SOA with stock springs. Good examples and comparisons for the ride height on the trucks so I shot a few photos for you.

Blue one is Chris’s and sports a 4” SUA lift
Yellow one is Supper Dave’s and sports a well done SOA


Mark
SOA SUA POR.webp
 
Ok yes the blue 40 does have a non stock shackle on the rear. So I measured the hood lines between the two at the cowling. Taking in to the differences of the two different manufacturers 35” tires size, the SOA was only 1 5/8” taller.

SD is running Revolver shackles up front; this is what they do at full droop!


Mark
SD Forked POR.webp
 
Hi All:

"Nuclear Lemon" (Hi Ige!) hit the issue on the head - it really depends upon what you intend the rig for.

I have been running the full Old Man Emu (OME) suspension uder my FJ40 since 1998. It rides fine and flexs good on the trail, but I'm limited to radial 33X12.5 tires (which rub when the tires fully stuff into the fenders.)

A couple of my friends have gone SOA on their FJ40s in the last 2-3 years, and I have to say that a properly done SOA creates an impressive machine!

These SOA rigs are much more capable than my SUA rig on a tougher trail. I am seriously considering the same conversion for my truck in the next year or two.

But, if you just intend the truck as a fishing/hunting rig, or for more mild off-road exploring the the SOA swap is complete overkill.

If you have a stocker FJ40/45/55/60, and don't intend it for hard-core off-raod trails, then get the basic stuff fixed - carb, steering, front axle re-build, and so on. Don't throw money away on "dress-up" stuff until you get the basics covered.

My $00.02

Regards,

Alan
Seattle
 
What kind of money are shops charging foe the 40 sprung over option?

I was quoted $2500 in No Ca.

JB
 
I drove my 40 with stock SUA suspension and put it on its side the first time I went wheeling. I then learned how to drive and stepped up to a 4in. Skyjacker lift and have wheeled that for three years. I am now in the middle of doing my SOA because I need more flex and want to run bigger tires. I am ready to tackle harder trails. After running the SOA for a few years I will probably link it once my fab skills and driving skills improve even more. I see it as an evolution of my truck and fab skills growing together.

My biggest complaint about a 4in. SUA lift is the ride sucked unless I was carrying lots of weight in the truck. The skyjackers took forever to break in and unless I was running the hardtop or lots of weight in the rear the ride was harsh. SOA trucks I have ridden in are caddy plush.
 
Last edited:
I like the stability. ;)
m56ja.jpg


I voted SUA. Not that I am against SOA swaps, but personally, I don't like the roll center of the SOA since it is high, and to me it makes the vehicle feel a little unstable in the off camber stuff. I also spend a LOT of time on the road with my cruiser, and after having a wheel come off at 60mph, I wonder how a SOA truck would handle in an emergency. The nicest riding Cruiser was The Dude's SOA HJ61, but it is relatively low (for a truck that rides on 38s) and wide. I think before I go SOA, I'd go coils sprung like a 80 series.
 
I go SOA. and i drive my rig everyday to work. If it don right it it improves the road handling.
I hav Nissan Patrol front leaf back on my 40. the patrol leaf is parabolic and have the centerbolt 2 inch further back so the wheelbase is 2 inches longer. I'm also increase the caster from 1 to 6 degrees. Now my rig goes smother on the road and it goes stright forvard, no wandering.
 
Why not coils or coilovers? But, if I HAD to pick from your 2 simple suspension designs, I'd pick SOA. After having an LC with a stock SUA, I'd say the Toyota engineers did a poor job in offering the most inefficent & lackluster type of design available. Heck, look at the early Broncos & Ford trucks, they had coils!!
 
Back
Top Bottom