I voted SOA.
2.5” SUA is a great set up if you just need the few inches for the use of your rig.
4.0” SUA is a great set up if it fits the budget or you want to keep the truck as original as you can. What I mean by that is not cutting the rear wheel wells on a nice truck. A 4” lift allows you to run the bigger tire yet you can reverse the whole thing if you wish.
Now why SOA?!
First off this is a SOA done right: OE springs, Cut-n-turn front axle, track bar in the rear, and high steer steering set up.
The basic SOA set up right performs better on the street IMO since the OE spring packs give the truck the original ride. I have driven a number of trucks with “soft lifts” and none of them seamed all that soft to me. A custom spring arced to generate lift is just going to be stiffer. Get back into a truck with OE springs and it just goes down the road straight and handles better. (OE springs w/ healthy bushings!) Yes you do get more sway in a SOA truck, sway bars would help. There is another trick to help dampen sway. A few of the Cascade Cruisers have put in the remote adjustable shocks (RS9000) and just stiffen up all the shocks on the street, then open them up on the trail. Works perfect for them.
Going SOA does not mean you have to be way up in the air. Case in point, LT here on the board as (GreenWinnie78) had a 4” lift on his truck prior to SOA. Side by side his hood line was 3-4” higher than my SOA 79’. (Both trucks on 35’s) He did at the time have a true 2” body lift on, but that still sat his SUA higher than my SOA by at least one inch. I run modified leaf packs making the truck sit lower. The modified packs (-1 leaf and one mid leaf is from a 55) also perform and flex more off road. The draw back on the street is they allow axel wrap, so track bars are a must. The benefit on the road the truck handles ruts extremely well since the suspension just sucks them up. I am a firm believer in keeping the truck as low as you can.
Shot of my 79’ SOA 1st in Black Hills, on the Buzz Worms trial, 2nd Bend OR Staging .
More photos:
http://www.metaltechcage.com/bhcc_july03/index.htm
Mark