Max speed for locking the Center Diff?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Okay, I have to admit that my initial response rapidly rejected the theory of permanently activating the CDL but when I thought about that response I realized it was greatly generated by the fact that convention commonly dictates the center "locker" stays "unlocked". Since some are wonderful at challenging any convention, I thought "what the hell, I'll lock er up and let er rip".

I chose a slightly slippery situation to start with when we recently had some steady rain for a few days (slight safety measure just in case convention IS correct!) and tried several things in progression ... first just "locking" at a stop sign and rolling around slowly on pavement which I had never done before without ice or snow above that pavement, then locking while rolling slowly, then more rapidly up to around approx sixty, all of this more or less on straight sections of pavement. Then tried the same things while turning on pavement.

My honest assessment in an 80 is that there is no problem locking up the diff while driving straight, or more or less straight, on pavement. Acceleration, at least up to that sixty, while traveling straight seems similar. Braking seems better but NOT because of any anti-dive property associated with the CDL but ONLY because the threshold of braking is higher with all four tires screaming but not skidding at me to stop than it is with the ABS constantly barely chirping and trying to stop.

Start turning however and things change it seems in proportion to the turn tightness. Folks, there is now no doubt in my mind that activating the CDL in an 80 and above pavement IS A BAD THING TO DO; I could clearly feel the bind in those tight turns - a smooth sweeping turn at twenty feels no different but start slowly navigating parking places in and out and you can clearly feel the bind in turns. This is at idle essentially loping from place to place and then tight turns to the 180, four point turns, etc etc etc. Put a slight amount of gas and the bind gets greater in a strange way I cannot completely explain yet, like the rig is tense, erect and edgy. Further, if you begin a bind and really give it gas you really feel the rig rocketing on a very unfamiliar vector than it would when you spin the tires while taking a turn "open".

I tried to think this through and argue that the effect wasn't even there but folks it is there. I have to conclude that bind equals extra force, which equals extra friction, which equals extra wear, etc etc etc. I read all the arguments and allotta them are thought provoking but I'm sorry to say that a 5500 pound rig with 33" tires behaves a bit differently then a quattro! Since the fake checkmate move around here is "BTDT", I'll say BTDT to this test and move on. Anyone who wants to, can continue to turn blue in the face! :cheers:
 
Last edited:
...
My honest assessment in an 80 is that there is no problem locking up the diff while driving straight, or more or less straight, on pavement. Acceleration, at least up to that sixty, while traveling straight seems similar. Braking seems better but NOT because of any anti-dive property associated with the CDL but ONLY because the threshold of braking is higher with all four tires screaming but not skidding at me to stop than it is with the ABS constantly barely chirping and trying to stop.

Start turning however and things change it seems in proportion to the turn tightness. Folks, there is now no doubt in my mind that activating the CDL in an 80 and above pavement IS A BAD THING TO DO; I could clearly feel the bind in those tight turns - a smooth sweeping turn at twenty feels no different but start slowly navigating parking places in and out and you can clearly feel the bind in turns. This is at idle essentially loping from place to place and then tight turns to the 180, four point turns, etc etc etc. Put a slight amount of gas and the bind gets greater in a strange way I cannot completely explain yet, like the rig is tense, erect and edgy. Further, if you begin a bind and really give it gas you really feel the rig rocketing on a very unfamiliar vector than it would when you spin the tires while taking a turn "open".

I tried to think this through and argue that the effect wasn't even there but folks it is there. I have to conclude that bind equals extra force, which equals extra friction, which equals extra wear, etc etc etc. I read all the arguments and allotta them are thought provoking but I'm sorry to say that a 5500 pound rig with 33" tires behaves a bit differently then a quattro! Since the fake checkmate move around here is "BTDT", I'll say BTDT to this test and move on. Anyone who wants to, can continue to turn blue in the face! :cheers:

I applaud you for taking it to the streets. I don't think what you describe is any different from any other locked center vehicle, nor from my descriptions posted. Look, tight turns causes bind. That means that for most open road driving this isnt' a problem, you even state that. And threshold braking is better, something I also noticed.

Tight turns shouldn't prevent you from locking the diffs, only make you aware that you have the ability to unlock it when the time comes. I'm not at all advocating locking the center diff and leaving it locked all the time. I say for the majority of your driving, it's fine, and binding is a non issue. Tight turns? Absolutely, if you know you have some coming up, or you are parking, turn off the center diff lock! BTDT

A much bigger jump is to summary claim it's just not good to do because it binds in tight turns. Don't use it in tight turns. Then, you have added a dimension to driving education and control and awareness that the center diff lock has benefits in everyday driving, pavement or otherwise.

I'm a huge fan of education in driving. I find the reluctance to lock center diffs on dry pavement to be bordering on the obsurd. Hardly blue in the face, only dispelling myths. The biggest 'myth' is that locking the center diff on dry pavement is 'bad'. That's BS, period. In a tight turning maneuvers it can add bind? Absolutely. A push of the button and that problem goes away. I only argue that tight bind scenario shouldn't prevent you from using the center locker button on a regular basis. It's lockable at any road speed, the key is straight wheels (= driveshaft rotation), not vehicle speed.

BTDT

Scott Justusson
 
Last edited:
I fully understand all of that , in fact work on the s*** all the time.....my point is, what situation would arise where you would suddenly need the center diff lock say at 60 mph?

While I'm not going to jump in to the rest of this discussion I will comment that I do lock the center diff on the fly at times. I drive my truck for work and find myself in situations during the cold weather where wind driven snow can leave slippery patchy areas on the road. This is especially true in the miountain areas on long inclines.

When I come upon one I usually let of the gas and lock the center diff. I personally feel the truck is more predictable in that situation locked. The rest of the time it's open.
 
I applaud you for taking it to the streets. I don't think what you describe is any different from any other locked center vehicle, nor from my descriptions posted. Look, tight turns causes bind. That means that for most open road driving this isnt' a problem, you even state that. And threshold braking is better, something I also noticed.

Tight turns shouldn't prevent you from locking the diffs, only make you aware that you have the ability to unlock it when the time comes. I'm not at all advocating locking the center diff and leaving it locked all the time. I say for the majority of your driving, it's fine, and binding is a non issue. Tight turns? Absolutely, if you know you have some coming up, or you are parking, turn off the center diff lock! BTDT

A much bigger jump is to summary claim it's just not good to do because it binds in tight turns. Don't use it in tight turns. Then, you have added a dimension to driving education and control and awareness that the center diff lock has benefits in everyday driving, pavement or otherwise.

I'm a huge fan of education in driving. I find the reluctance to lock center diffs on dry pavement to be bordering on the obsurd. Hardly blue in the face, only dispelling myths. The biggest 'myth' is that locking the center diff on dry pavement is 'bad'. That's BS, period. In a tight turning maneuvers it can add bind? Absolutely. A push of the button and that problem goes away. I only argue that tight bind scenario shouldn't prevent you from using the center locker button on a regular basis. It's lockable at any road speed, the key is straight wheels (= driveshaft rotation), not vehicle speed.

BTDT

Scott Justusson


Yer just turnin blue-er, and contradicting yourself left right and center (pun intended). Go on, go on, see if you can get to red!
 
Let's compare some quotes...I think it is easier to let you argue against yourself, kinda like losing the eye blink contest with one's self in the mirror!

I've already driven my SC 80 a couple thousand miles with the center diff locked, on road or off road. Hours at a time, there is no reason not to.

Ideal brake force distribution (albiet no abs), better handling, more predictable handling, and better acceleration would be the benefits of locking the center. I can't see any reason not to, I've never thougt twice about doing it, even my track prepped quattros all run center diff locked.

HTH

Scott Justusson




Then this...

Wear *can* be accelerated, it's not a fact Spike.

I don't break axles, neither does the quattro rally car I service, it also eats tires. They aren't fighting each other, they are just forced to turn at the same speed.

It's not inherently dangerous, it's a tractoin tool that has many advantages in everyday driving.

SJ




Then this...

I think this is BS through and through. Push the button anytime you want. Even your warning to not do that on dry pavement isn't right.

SJ



Then this...

Spike, you miss the point completely. I've been locking centers on pavement for 16 years man. Not drifting, driving the frickin car. "Bind" only happens in a really tight turn. With the wheelbase on the 80 you can drive in the city and never 'bind' the axles, I do it all the time.

I have more than 4000 miles logged with my center diff fully locked, dry pavement the majority.

It's not abuse, it's just understanding how vehicle dynamics work. I find any blanket statements about wear or handling in locked center diff awd to be unsupported opinions. I work on locked center cars as my living, cars built and designed with center lockers for ROAD use. I don't see the 80 any differently, only that it's built like a sherman tank in comparison.

Easy to shift the logic over to it.

SJ



Then finally this...look if you keep backpedalling that hard yer knees are gonna give out...

Look, tight turns causes bind.

I'm not at all advocating locking the center diff and leaving it locked all the time. I say for the majority of your driving, it's fine, and binding is a non issue. Tight turns? Absolutely, if you know you have some coming up, or you are parking, turn off the center diff lock! BTDT

A much bigger jump is to summary claim it's just not good to do because it binds in tight turns. Don't use it in tight turns. Then, you have added a dimension to driving education and control and awareness that the center diff lock has benefits in everyday driving, pavement or otherwise.

In a tight turning maneuvers it can add bind? Absolutely. A push of the button and that problem goes away.

BTDT

Scott Justusson


Then this ... well never mind more contradictions to come, fire away ST!!!
 
Thank God not everyone blindly follows someone just because they sound like they know what they're talking about.

-Spike
 
Let's compare some quotes...I think it is easier to let you argue against yourself, kinda like losing the eye blink contest with one's self in the mirror!

Sorry, don't see any contradiction. Look, lock the diffs anytime you want. You want to park *easier*, unlock the diffs. You don't want to feel bind, unlock the diffs in tight spaces. A big jump to say it's bad, it's gonna break something, or you shouldn't do it.

Again, I'll laugh with anyone on this thread. The center diff can be locked at any speed, that's the question in the thread. The diffs can be locked on ANY surface, that's in the design of center locking diffs. Locking the center diff should not be attempted during a turn.

I'd love to see more than opinion that a locked center diff will break something on an 80. That should have already happened. I've read lots of threads on locking center diffs in sand. If something is going to break in a locked diff, sand should do it. Bogging tires with no way for lateral slip.

Pavement is a whimpy test in comparison. The tires will be forced into lateral slip in any bind scenario, the gear is too strong for the tire.

The opinion really revolves around the argument that turning radius induced bind = break. I think that's complete BS, your attempts at pointing out some sort of contradiction aside. I appreciate the fact you at least tried it. Here's hoping more do. It's part of becoming a better awd driver IME/O.

It's ok to lock the diff, and unlock some of the myths. Better car control, better traction, better braking, and more predictable handling. Oh yea, and in really tight turns the axles will bind. So noted.

ST
 
It's ok to lock the diff, and unlock some of the myths. Better car control, better traction, better braking, and more predictable handling. Oh yea, and in really tight turns the axles will bind. So noted.

ST

You actually believe this on dry pavement? Ice?
 
Sorry, don't see any contradiction. Look, lock the diffs anytime you want. You want to park *easier*, unlock the diffs. You don't want to feel bind, unlock the diffs in tight spaces. A big jump to say it's bad, it's gonna break something, or you shouldn't do it.

Again, I'll laugh with anyone on this thread. The center diff can be locked at any speed, that's the question in the thread. The diffs can be locked on ANY surface, that's in the design of center locking diffs. Locking the center diff should not be attempted during a turn.

I'd love to see more than opinion that a locked center diff will break something on an 80. That should have already happened. I've read lots of threads on locking center diffs in sand. If something is going to break in a locked diff, sand should do it. Bogging tires with no way for lateral slip.

Pavement is a whimpy test in comparison. The tires will be forced into lateral slip in any bind scenario, the gear is too strong for the tire.

The opinion really revolves around the argument that turning radius induced bind = break. I think that's complete BS, your attempts at pointing out some sort of contradiction aside. I appreciate the fact you at least tried it. Here's hoping more do. It's part of becoming a better awd driver IME/O.

It's ok to lock the diff, and unlock some of the myths. Better car control, better traction, better braking, and more predictable handling. Oh yea, and in really tight turns the axles will bind. So noted.

ST


Keep belching out bad advice to these good people and to their good rigs...


No one's listening any more, topic after topic you are just flat wrong.
 
Thank God not everyone blindly follows someone just because they sound like they know what they're talking about.

-Spike

Kettle theory... Spike, the main reason I stayed in this thread was exactly the myths you put forth in terms of the vehicle dynamics of locked center awd. I've taught awd driving on tarmac and at Steamboat for 15 years. My learning, codriving, race car building and 2 toyota awd trucks contradicts your opinion on center diff locking. It's ok that you don't. It's different to put forth myths about doing so.

Don't 'blindly" let me lead you anywhere. Come to any tarmac venue or my Steamboat Event, I'll work hard to help you understand the vehicle dynamics of awd, and the importance of center diff locking to increase performance, control and education.

If you want to focus on turning induced axle binding = break, please feel free to do so, I still think it's BS. If you want to focus on awd dynamics of awd, I'm happy to help educate, without blindly making a single statement.
:cheers:

ST
 
You actually believe this on dry pavement? Ice?

Absolutely! I'll be at Gingermann with a locked center and rear race quattro in two weeks, and I'll be at Steamboat Ice Track with a locked center 80 and a locked center and locked rear quattro.

I think a locked center diff is much more predictable in terms of handling than any other form of center diff (LSD, torsen, VC and/or open).

You wouldn't make it around the track at Steamboat with the center diff open, Blizzacks or no.

ST
 
Kettle theory... Spike, the main reason I stayed in this thread was exactly the myths you put forth in terms of the vehicle dynamics of locked center awd. I've taught awd driving on tarmac and at Steamboat for 15 years. My learning, codriving, race car building and 2 toyota awd trucks contradicts your opinion on center diff locking. It's ok that you don't. It's different to put forth myths about doing so.

Don't 'blindly" let me lead you anywhere. Come to any tarmac venue or my Steamboat Event, I'll work hard to help you understand the vehicle dynamics of awd, and the importance of center diff locking to increase performance, control and education.

If you want to focus on turning induced axle binding = break, please feel free to do so, I still think it's BS. If you want to focus on awd dynamics of awd, I'm happy to help educate, without blindly making a single statement.
:cheers:

ST

Ahhh....the Cruiser isn't an AWD vehicle. It doesn't have an automatic locking CDL.

The Cruiser is a Permanent 4WD vehicle with a locking CDL. If you lock the CDL it's locked into 4WD and tha'ts not AWD. An all wheel drive vehicle locks and unlocks automatically as needed. It will remain UNLOCKED almost ALWAYS for better handling, safety and the like. ONLY will it lock TEMPORARILTY when it sees traction being lost. As soon as traction is regained it will unlock...as I said...for safety.

Making a habit of driving with a locked CD pavement or icy conditions is insane and dangerous.
 
.

Ok, lets talk about dynamics. Most would agree that running 33-37" tires also increases the binding forces imposed in a turn. Especially compared to some 22"tall tires on an Audi. Not the same thing as an 80.

This is like saying that locking the diffs doesn't add stress to the birfs and r&p. It does add stress, from the t-case to the diffs. That is why in my truck it says:

Lock CDL- when losing traction at one or more wheels.

Not a chance of losing traction. Why use it?

I agree higher speeds at not a issue.
Dan, can you PM Sumo the price for a t-case rebuild kit?:grinpimp:
 
Keep belching out bad advice to these good people and to their good rigs... topic after topic you are just flat wrong.

I look at it differently, topic after topic, I see a lot of myths. In awd locking center, it's just not myth, I feel I have enough experience in theory, application, competition and teaching to say "BS".

I'm happy to have someone demonstrate "flat wrong" at any venue I'm at in the next year. Steamboat is second week of February. I'll have the race quattro (locked center) for testing in a couple weeks in MI, and more in the spring.

Bad advice? That to me is blindly saying it's bad to lock the center diff because it 'feels' bindy, when the benefits to awd vehicle dynamics are so well documented. And the breakage and accelerated wear from it lacks documentation.

Turbocruiser, I have no ill will toward you, only a challenge to come to Steamboat and play. I've seen more revelations by folks with mindsets than I care to count. Makes all the rest of the BS worth it.

ST
 
Making a habit of driving with a locked CD pavement or icy conditions is insane and dangerous.

I like having mine locked on icy roads....as long as the turns arent tooooo tight. It keeps me from locking up the front axle. Seems like the weight distribution is better.
 
To state that bind does not equate to wear is not just a blind statement, it's absurd. Binding the drivetrain accelerates wear on all of it's components, from the tire all the way to the center differential. If you can't see that, and it's pretty obvious by now that you can't, you're not capable of using the brain that God (or the provider of your choice) gave you. Any statements I have made previously about handling are my opinions and assumptions, granted. I have my own experiences with cars and trucks, mostly open diff, and all cars 2wd, so I have avoided that particular arguement with you. I will stand by my assertion that locking the center diff induces extra wear on the drivetrain components, and there's nothing that you can say that will convince me that I'm wrong. You can get off the broken parts soapbox as well. Just because you haven't broken anything doesn't mean you haven't worn anything. Stop making it sound as if no broken parts equates to no wear.

-Spike
 
Ahhh....the Cruiser isn't an AWD vehicle. It doesn't have an automatic locking CDL.

More myths. The cruiser is an awd vehicle. It has a normally open differential where 50% of the torque always goes to the front and rear axles. It doesn't have an automatic locking CDL, never said it did. It has a VC Limited Slip for the center diff which allows lockup based on driveshaft speed differential.

The Cruiser is a Permanent 4WD vehicle with a locking CDL.

No, the cruiser is a AWD vehicle with a Viscous Coupling Center differential lock with over-ride hard lock capability.


If you lock the CDL it's locked into 4WD and tha'ts not AWD. An all wheel drive vehicle locks and unlocks automatically as needed. It will remain UNLOCKED almost ALWAYS for better handling, safety and the like. ONLY will it lock TEMPORARILTY when it sees traction being lost. As soon as traction is regained it will unlock...as I said...for safety.

No again. If you lock the CDL it's still awd, 4WD technically is 4 drive wheels, that requires CDL and front and rear locked. AWD vehicles don't automatically lock anything if it's an open diff vehicle. The 80 with the HF2AV in open diff form (unlocked CDL) with driveshaft speed differential, will couple the front and rear driveshafts up to full lock. I disagree that it will remain unlocked for better handling. The HF2AV was designed to unlock for ABS activation. It only locks temporarily because that's the design of the VC.

You are incorrect that it's a traction argument that unlocks it. You can have all wheels spinning on ice and have the VC uncouple. That's because the VC isn't smart, it's only looking for equal F/R driveshaft speed rotation.

Making a habit of driving with a locked CD pavement or icy conditions is insane and dangerous.

I think a lot of education is needed, and you have a basic misunderstanding of awd systems. I make a habit of driving a locked center diff on dry pavement because I find the vehicle dynamics more predictable. Understeer is not dangerous, understeer is a dynamic that has fantastic predictability. Regarding ice, I say driving with an open diff is more dangerous in terms of control. I'm happy to educate you on why if you come to Steamboat's Ice Track. The most dangerous thing you can do there is forget to lock the center diff when you thought it was (btdt).

Shotts, I'm happy to be futher enlightened on awd systems. You have some fundamental misunderstandings of how awd works. I'm not big on discussions of systems, because that education can be had on line. My passion and my interest is awd systems and vehicle dynamics of it. I'm 15 years into theory, research, and practical application, on tarmac and off.

Happy to get the understanding of the awd system in the 80 out of the way first, then move on to the dynamics of it. I have the slight advantage of a week on 8inches of ice this past February with my supercharged 80.

ST
 
To state that bind does not equate to wear is not just a blind statement, it's absurd. Binding the drivetrain accelerates wear on all of it's components, from the tire all the way to the center differential. If you can't see that, and it's pretty obvious by now that you can't, you're not capable of using the brain that God (or the provider of your choice) gave you. Any statements I have made previously about handling are my opinions and assumptions, granted. I have my own experiences with cars and trucks, mostly open diff, and all cars 2wd, so I have avoided that particular arguement with you. I will stand by my assertion that locking the center diff induces extra wear on the drivetrain components, and there's nothing that you can say that will convince me that I'm wrong. You can get off the broken parts soapbox as well. Just because you haven't broken anything doesn't mean you haven't worn anything. Stop making it sound as if no broken parts equates to no wear.

-Spike

I stand by my assertion that there will be plenty of 'other' ways to break a center diff, turn induced binding isn't one of them. I see a high speed turn bog in sand as one of them. I see stamping on the gas pedal with the wheel locked (NOT the center diff locked). I see a full throttle acceleration mixed mu causing breakage.

Wear? Spike, show me a worn out transfer case or differential on an 80. I say you can turn induce bind the crap out of that thing for years beyond the life of the motor, and never have to replace a 'worn' component.

Your opinion on the thread is clear. I guess I need to see more evidence of breakage or worn out center diffs to understand your point. Right now, I don't see any evidence of it, and I don't at all agree with your vehicle dynamics scenarios.

I'm sure it's the loose nut behind the wheel of my 80 tho

:cheers:


Scott Justusson
 
Back
Top Bottom