OK, I'm gonna have to go on record as being in complete disagreement with Sumo on that.
First, drivetrain wear. With the CDL locked, both axles are forced to turn at the same overall speed. That's going to cause binding when turning- even if you can't feel it. The full drivelines will be fighting each other, from the u-joints through the diffs and on to the axles, birfs and drive flanges. Wear will be accelerated, that's a fact. 'Wear' in it's worst manifestation is 'breakage', but there are degrees in between.
Wear *can* be accelerated, it's not a fact Spike. My race prepped quattros don't have the option to unlock the center. What wears? Tires, that's it. Full race rubber with maximum traction driven 10/10ths. I don't break axles, neither does the quattro rally car I service, it also eats tires. They aren't fighting each other, they are just forced to turn at the same speed.
You have shock to the drivetrain, because you have awd. Locking axles only doesn't allow one axle to rotate faster than the other. I can think of better ways to parallel park, but the question was locker speed. If you lock it at all, your argument applies. Locking it at 100 won't change that, even if I was to agree with it.
Second, handling. On straight roads, there should be no ill effects. Take it into a turn, however, and disaster awaits. Normally the axles turn somewhat independantly, again allowing them to turn at their own speeds. Turning, the rear axle is going to want to turn slower, as it has less distance to travel. If the two axles are forced to turn at the same speed, something has to give. That something, if not catastrophic breakage of the drivetrain, will be the tires' traction with the road.
BS Spike. Here's what happens. In a straight line with the center diff locked, f/R torque distribution follows weight distribution exactly, always. In a turn F/R torque distribution will favor the rear (based on turning radius and wheelbase) until it breaks loose, then it favors the front (from a turning radius forced torque argument to a traction argumet), which then results in understeer since a turning front wheel can't support 100% of engine torque under normal conditions. The speeds at which all this happens is based on wheelbase, cf, cog, tire load, slip angle, steering input and engine torque. Tires in awd inherently have more traction, even in turns, locked or not. I personally lock center diffs all the time because the understeer is predictable in a locked diff, spinup in an open diff isn't, especially in low cf conditions.
That means that at the time you need traction- side-loading the suspension- one of your tires is already out of the equasion. If you should have to turn a bit tighter, perhaps tighter than you would normally at a certain speed- say you're avoiding a collision- you are already relying on only 3 tires to hold you to your turn. Hit the brakes or a piece of ice, and your downfall is imminent.
Unless a tire is lifted, it's not out of the equation. You can turn a bit tighter, nothing stops you from doing that. The understeer maybe greater, it depends on how much weight is at the rear wheel , that's not correct to make the jump to loss of control. Hit the brakes, you only have no abs, you haven't automatically lost control, that would depend on how much tire slip is present front and rear. Loss of control is a big jump. Spike, Audi raced with locked center diffs in awd for 20 years, in fact in many of the race cars they took at the center diff alltogether, cuz if you don't use it you lose the weight.
The arguement that 'nothing bad has happened yet' doesn't hold water for me. The forces involved must follow simple physics principles. You are adding stress and reducing traction with that practice. When you need the control the most is when it's going to fail you- in a turn, at speed, during a maneuver. Frankly, you seem like a smart person, I'm suprised you haven't seen this for yourself.
-Spike
Spike, come to Steamboat, or any quattro track event, I teach and practice and build car control with center diffs locked all the time. In fact, I lock my 80 center diff in Chicago traffic quite often. This is a long wheelbase vehicle compared to what I normally drive locked (99in quattro). My passion is teaching, advocating and understanding of awd performance. A big part of that is center diff locking and it's effects on chassis dynamics and car control. Locking center isn't just an offroad tool, it's a great way to educate yourself on the differences between awd open and locked center diffs. It's not inherently dangerous, it's a tractoin tool that has many advantages in everyday driving.
I can also show you Audi quattro owners manuals from lockers that specifically speak to the conditions under which locking diff has the advantage.
I have two passions Spike, turbos and awd. In awd, my passion is vehicle dynamics of it. You present arguments I hear all the time. I know that you will chew up a tire before you break a darn thing on a quattro, and the LC has drivegear massive in comparison, it's not a fact you will break a darn thing, that's an opinion without support. IMO/E.
A bit of audi trivia to leave you with. The first audi quattro released to the motoring press in 1982 was delivered with no center diff. They asked for feedback, and eventually added the dog clutch center diff. Parking the only complaint.
SJ