So I had yet again another issue on my truck with the knuckle studs loosening, falling out and shearing on the passenger side of my axle. After reading what others were doing and trying some of those ideas I decided to take a closer look at what was going on.
First lets talk about the dimensions of the stock stud and in this case I'm referencing a new stud with a torx head on it and other relative parts.
The stud has:
a 12 x 1.5 threaded section that treads into the knuckle housing itself
a 12 x 1.25 threaded section that a cone washer, flat washer and nut are placed on to clamp the assembly together. The OD of this threaded section is 11.84mm
A shoulder section measuring 11.96mm OD and 11mm in length
The cone washer has a total height of 8 mm
With the cone washer in place in the arm the total height from the base of the arm to the top of the cone washer is 17.5mm. This means that the bottom of the cone washer is 9.5mm up from the base of the arm or the top of the knuckle.
In this first picture you can see that with the stock stud in place there is 11mm of shoulder exposed.
Given that the bottom of the cone washer is 9.5mm up from the base of the arm this equates to only 1.5mm of engagement between the cone washer, arm and stud. This is due to the fact that the shoulder diameter is slightly smaller than the hole in the arm and the threaded section of the exposed section is slightly smaller than the shoulder.
This can be seen when inspecting the tapered holes in the arm.
Notice the clean ring area where there is continuous contact between the arm, washer and stud and the larger area where no continuous contact is.
Further signs of this can be seen on a cone washer itself. The next three pictures are of the same washer just rotated to show all sides.
You can see irregular markings which I believe are from the washer being distorted some during install and use.
First lets talk about the dimensions of the stock stud and in this case I'm referencing a new stud with a torx head on it and other relative parts.
The stud has:
a 12 x 1.5 threaded section that treads into the knuckle housing itself
a 12 x 1.25 threaded section that a cone washer, flat washer and nut are placed on to clamp the assembly together. The OD of this threaded section is 11.84mm
A shoulder section measuring 11.96mm OD and 11mm in length
The cone washer has a total height of 8 mm
With the cone washer in place in the arm the total height from the base of the arm to the top of the cone washer is 17.5mm. This means that the bottom of the cone washer is 9.5mm up from the base of the arm or the top of the knuckle.
In this first picture you can see that with the stock stud in place there is 11mm of shoulder exposed.
Given that the bottom of the cone washer is 9.5mm up from the base of the arm this equates to only 1.5mm of engagement between the cone washer, arm and stud. This is due to the fact that the shoulder diameter is slightly smaller than the hole in the arm and the threaded section of the exposed section is slightly smaller than the shoulder.
This can be seen when inspecting the tapered holes in the arm.
Notice the clean ring area where there is continuous contact between the arm, washer and stud and the larger area where no continuous contact is.
Further signs of this can be seen on a cone washer itself. The next three pictures are of the same washer just rotated to show all sides.
You can see irregular markings which I believe are from the washer being distorted some during install and use.