Keep it or sell it?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 27, 2014
Threads
13
Messages
115
Location
Beaufort,SC
Hello All,

Should I sell my 96 with 212k? I seem to be putting $2k a year in it to maintain just because I am not a mechanic and use it as my DD. This would be a 4th Gen 4runner payment with half the miles. It's never left me stranded once in 13 years and have always kept up with its needs. About to go in for a tune up and new front bearings ($750!). I feel at some point it will present me with a problem that I can not afford on my teacher salary.

Keep:
-I love it. My daughter loves it.
-It's more reliable than me at this point.
-I would miss this forum (wish I could contribute but you all know how to put gas in and check tire pressure).
-Trade in at dealer is $1500, although I'm sure a private sale would yield higher amounts.

Sell:
-The amount of miles scare me, never owned a vehicle with so many.
-I'm a 1 banana mechanic...maybe, and the local shops leave me broke at times.
-Although I aspire to camp more, I'm not a rock crawling nomad and someone else may use it to its full potential.

Any thoughts would be welcome. Thank you.

20151231_121239.webp
 
A tune up and front bearings is a one banana job to me, which I believe a Land Cruiser owner should be doing or learning to do themselves. $750 is highway robbery. If you think about it, $2K per year on maintenance isn't too bad compared to payments on a new car. Hopefully the LC is paid off. I would personally recommend somebody that cannot do a tune up on one of these, to sell it and get a vehicle that costs less for somebody else to do the maintenance and gets better gas mileage. Unfortunately, this out weighs the fun factor.
 
I'm a one banana. This forum adds 1 banana. FSM adds another. Anyone can do it!

I could do your wheel bearings in a couple hrs now. But when I rebuilt my front axle, it took me 30 hrs to do the job.

Even if you choose not to do your own work, for cost purposes, use partsouq.com and amayama.com. they have OEM part at sometimes half dealer prices (yes, half). Poke around this forum or toyodiy for part numbers and you're good to go.:steer::steer::steer::steer:
 
I'd say keep it. Take some of the money for the mechanics next bill and buy some tools, download the fsm from here and start learning. This way as you learn how to work on your truck the fear of the higher mileage will start to disappear. There's no better feeling then knowing how to fix any problem that may pop up at home or out while exploring in your truck.
 
As AMX390 said, ownership includes rolling your sleeves up and learning what makes this rig tick. Talk to other Cruiser owners, club members in your area and jump in. Your daughter would love it. once you do something simple like a tune up and have success you'll be less scared of owning an operating a high mileage rig. Just Do It!

Use the barter system, you'd be amazed at what some beer and bar-b-q, or you providing your talents to someone will get you. Just like this forum. Love Beaufort, SC. I have an aunt that grew up there and lives a little closer to Hilton Head now. Good luck.

P.S. Also when working on the rig, especially with upgrades, do one thing at a time so you can feel the benefits and you'll know what to undo in the event you need to.
 
Keep it, you will kick yourself in the ass if you let it go... I prefer my 80 to my wife's hundred but that's me... I went from a second gen 4runner to my 80 and couldn't be happier... Just did my knuckle job and had about 12 hours total in it... But I was dealing with a broken stud and lots of nasty parts... Best of luck with your decision...
 
I just bough 95 with 229 on the clock!! I also own a 03 Volvo XC90 that I have been trying to kill for a year and a half, it has 210 on it. I am probably a two banana guy, but given this forum and a service manual I could probably get after most repairs. I prefer older vehicles for the reason that if they are still working that many years later they are worth keeping and repairing. My wife has a new Subaru Forrester! I hate that thing, it has no "feel" to it. Also as gnarlytoes said; I will give you 1600! It would be nice have a parts rig. Just for s***s and giggles, is it locked?
 
A tune up and front bearings is a one banana job to me, which I believe a Land Cruiser owner should be doing or learning to do themselves. $750 is highway robbery. If you think about it, $2K per year on maintenance isn't too bad compared to payments on a new car. Hopefully the LC is paid off. I would personally recommend somebody that cannot do a tune up on one of these, to sell it and get a vehicle that costs less for somebody else to do the maintenance and gets better gas mileage. Unfortunately, this out weighs the fun factor.
750 is about right. Cap rotor wires plugs and pack wheel bearings-thats actually a good deal.
 
Thanks Guys,

I suppose it is inevitable at some point my mechanic skills will need to be improved. I've done my brake booster and some electrical but that's about it. A tune-up is well within my ability but the bearings seem like a big job. I work 65-70hr a week at school, year round (IT, Facilities and teach) with little time to tinker and no time for a 3 ton paperweight. I really do fear regretting a newer truck. It's been so good to me and have never even truly used the factory lockers in 13 years (I engage them every so often to ensure they work.) The mileage is almost pure highway. Florida owned for the first 60k(PO) and SC for the rest It's not a parts rig and I'm aware of its value. I laughed at the dealer when he said 1500. The tires were almost that much.

I already had the bearings repacked and the steering is still loose. The new shop said they were worn (still showing play) and should have been replaced and the Dragon link (but I didn't feel any movement in the drag link except rotational.)

Yes, dallen341, the 4th Gen probably would need some work at some point and that is a concern. A car payment and repairs is BS. I've owned this for over a decade with just PM work. I'm only assuming a 4runner would have the same reliability. Maybe I have just been spoiled on this one. I know we had a $2k brake job done on our Prius we have within the first year. Not cool.

I appreciate the advice guys. It does help.
 
Here is what I see: Sounds like you have too much vehicle for your needs. Your struggling to keep it on the road. Keep in mind you have a vehicle that was top of the line in its day. And parts and repairs of it will always remain top of the line prices regardless of it losing resale value every year. However the craftsmanship put into a 80 series is some of the best out there and u just won't find it in any newer Toyota. As they get newer u get more plastic, but also more airbags, crumple zones, and refined abs. A newer 4runner 4TH gen will cost 12-20k. They also have issues like the tcase leaking at the actuator a 3k dollar repair to install updated seals. The CV boots Crack 600.00 repair. Alternators can be a issue, don't install aftermarket, 1200 dollar repair.
Point is, all used suv vehicles need maintenance. Some will be less expensive to repair. Will a 4TH gen be less expensive maintenance probably. And will give better mileage. So if u sold your cruiser for 6500, bought a 4TH gen for 15k, add taxes and registration your gonna owe 9k. 9K is a lot of extra money! I would sell the 80, get a 3Rd Gen 4runner with like 150k miles on it. You would pay likely 9k to buy it. So selling the 80 it would be like 3k u owe-not bad. You would probably need 1500 a year for maintenance, and get 16-20mpg. But u would have less safety features of the 4TH gen so that may or may not be important to u.
 
think about the $2k/year in maintenance as a monthly payment... ~$170/month doesn't buy you much these days.
If you get another used vehicle, consider that even if it is a Toyota, you will still have to put money into repairs/maintenance, but maybe not right away. You are, however, buying a vehicle with issues that you don't know about, so it could be right away that you have to fix things.
Also, consider finding a new mechanic. bearings don't wear like that(if they do, you have much bigger issues), but most likely whoever repacked the bearings didn't adjust the preload properly. The loose steering is adjustable by a small screw in the steering box itself. and if you have the original ball-joints, yeah, sure, maybe it is time to replace them, but not the whole link(unless the rod is bent).
 
Thanks Guys,

I know we had a $2k brake job done on our Prius we have within the first year. Not cool.

Just spent 2K on a tiny little radiator for the charging system on my wife's Prius...ridiculous, but there was no way I was gonna touch that! My wife drove the 80 for the first time around town while her car was getting fixed...she thinks she's a bad ass driving it, all smiles and "wow I love your truck". A 100 or 200 is in our future for her. Keep the 80 and attempt to do some of the maintenance yourself.
 
I had a 4th gen 4runner and disliked it immensely, compared to an 80 its going to feel like a real grocery getter IMO. Also cost me about 1k the first month I had it. They aren't necessarily cheap to maintain either. 2k a year on maintenance isn't too bad IMO if you are paying others for the work. If it were me I wouldn't get out of it for a payment and potential maintenance on a 4runner.

I wouldn't be scared of the miles alone as long as you can afford to keep up the maintenance. Worst case scenario if it S***s the bed big time and you don't want to pay for the big repair, its still probably worth as much as the dealer is offering you for trade in.

You don't need to be a rock crawling nomad to enjoy the thing, they are great vehicles whatever you use them for. Who knows maybe your daughter will become a rock crawling nomad in the future and you will be glad you have the 80 to pass to her?
 
Good thoughts White Stripes. I wonder what 9k in repairs and upgrades to the 80 would look like! I HATE plastic and it doesn't belong on a truck. I do have too much truck for my needs and the lockers have inspired a few offers in the parking lots around town.

Goglo13, that has always been my moto, expenses / year is less than car payment. But at some point the ratio will be outweighed. Also, I did switch shops after a few other small events. They gave me back a crooked steering wheel after an alignment and said it was fine, just old sloppy steering. I will dig the forums to see how to check for proper preloading of the bearings.

Ewillis, the prius is a spaceship that no shop but the dealer will touch. That is a no brainer to trade in and I can't wait to get rid of.

You guys a really great as always. Keeping it real.
 
I can see both sides of the coin and a 4th gen runner is a nice truck for a "light offroad" family and probably a lot cheaper to get worked on by your average mechanic. I owned 2 3rd gens and maintaining both for three years cost less than baselining my LX for 6 months.

I think any 80 owner at this point should be prepared to learn to do his own maintenance (or at least most of it). I would encourage you to learn, its not that hard and there are detailed instructions for everything you might want to fix in the FSM. If you're absolutely sure that's not your cup of tea, then I would strongly consider the 4runner. I understand how it is when you just have too much real work to find time to work on the truck.

If you do end up selling your 80, please, for the love of God, don't trade it in at a dealership. You'll probably get 3x what they offered by selling it in the classified's section here on mud, and then the next owner gets the benefit of meeting you, asking questions and whatever maintenance records you've kept.

FWIW, 212k miles is just broken in, in my humble opinion.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom