Interesting winch article

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Interestin read, should be more fair dinkum tests done like this on winches and other gear. Pull them straight out of the box and hook them up and go, and see how they perform.
 
Great find. Very enlightening.

Thanks for posting!
 
I had always wondereed about the Harbor Freight winches. I'm always in there looking for tools to fix my 40, and have been under the impression that I may only use it once, and don't want to spend a lot of money. They also will send out coupons for 15% off any item, making it even cheaper...
 
Nice post Cap. :D

-Spike
 
One thing that is not addressed in that test is what happens when a part fails five or ten years from now? Will there be parts available to repair it? Or will you be forced to replace it, whether it's under warranty or not?
 
I would also like to see the DNF's run again. Because of one failure out of the box (which would be covered as a return or warrantee I'd wager) we can't see them compete. It would be nice to know how they would do in the 'real world'.

-Spike
 
If they are still 525 at 4WP and if the sale the 14th knocks them down more, I might be doing so on an M8000.

Food for thought: two reasons I decided on an M12000

1. Most popular winch on this site

2. My buddy started out with an M9000 on his 80 in AK. He burned it up the first season. He replaced it with the M12000 and has done nothing but praise the 12K. He definately uses it in the "real world".

Im not trying to say that everyone needs a 12K winch just throwing in my .02
 
I would also like to see the DNF's run again.

Agreed. And I don't see how the line crimp failing on synthetic line on the T-Max (they say it was spec'd new with it?) is a fault of the winch.
 
I would also like to see the DNF's run again. Because of one failure out of the box (which would be covered as a return or warrantee I'd wager) we can't see them compete. It would be nice to know how they would do in the 'real world'.

-Spike

well, that's an interesting point. Of course if you bought the winch, you are out there, and it fails because of a stupid freakish occurrence that would be covered by the warranty, well, you are still stuck out there. Maybe that *is* the real world? :)
 
The Harbor Freight stuff is a total crapshoot. They sell cheap stuff that has little or no quality control. One unit may perform like a champ, but the one next to is may be DOA, and the one next to it may work the first couple times you use it. I have seen some discussions about the Harbor Freight winches on MUD, and I have the impression that they are a waste of money. I am dissapointed that they scrapped the T-Max just because of the line crimp. This article basically tells you to get a WARN if you have the cash, which everyone already knows. If a WARN is outside of your budget, I would trust you fellow MUDDer's advice a little more than this article.
 
-Spike- said:
It would be nice to know how they would do in the 'real world'.
Unfortunately, it was real world. They took them out of the box, installed them, used them, and had failure. Just like anyone of us would've encountered if we'd installed one of those winches on our rigs.

It's kind of a bummer they didn't fix/replace them, then test. I'm left wanting to know how the DNF's would've done overall. I think a point reduction would've been better rather than a DNF.
 
Back
Top Bottom