"Horrible Purchase"

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m curious... what do your parents drive?

A few thoughts since most of us are looking for a way to pass the time these days.

My first truck was a 94 Land Rover Discovery in 2003. Man I loved that truck but it was a money pit and PITA—-and it had the 3.9L Rover V8 which was considered to be one of the most reliable variants 😂. I did what I could myself and was mechanically inclined but had no experience working on cars and knew no one that did. It actually never left me stranded once but was a constant battle and was definitely a bit unsafe at at times. This was all on my parent’s dime (except the mods) and I still feel guilty about it. Hindsight is 20/20 and I underestimated their reputation for unreliability. A $5k rover was far more than $5k. I should have just gotten a Civic or Carolla.

In 2007 or so, my parents made me
swap it for a 2005 v6 Grand Cherokee. I hated the idea of it but knew they were right. It’s still in the family to this day and never had issues...I’m still surprised by that.

That experience is why I’m a a diehard Land Cruiser guy now haha.

The moral of the story is I get what your parents *think* they are protecting you from. You paying an arm and a leg to maintain it as a recent grad because it’s ‘old’.

Granted they’re wrong and would probably outlast/be around longer than whatever they’re driving now. Plus they’re being overly authoritarian and jerks about it considering you’re footing the bill and 21.

There is a catch though. Yes, Cruisers have a reputation for being indestructible and extremely reliable but people often conflate that with not having to maintain it.

Cruisers need maintenance and things do need to be replaced to go their next 250k miles. At that mileage things bushings, ball joints, steering rack bushings and the rack itself, and half shafts are at the end of their lives or start going. Buying a 20-ish year old or older Cruiser is only economical if you do a good chunk of the work yourself.

If you can’t and are short on cash you skip maintenance and repairs that are needed but may not seem necessary. Since they’re tanks they’ll go down the road with a ton of things wrong or out of spec. Continue doing that and they won’t be reliable. And IMHO, if you take them to average mechanics and/or are using cheap parts and they’ll continue to deteriorate.

Drive a cheap beater for a few years then get the cruiser of your dreams and prove them wrong. You’ll also get a much better truck buying one here and/or flying and driving a truck from a southern state with no salt. Then fluid film or krown will be your best friend of you have to drive it in salt...but you should keep the beater for that.

This rant may or may not be helpful but what I’m trying to say is going into a potential recession they could be doing you a huge favor despite them being dbags about it.
I wanted a discovery for my first car In high school. I had no clue at the time what they were all about. But seeing the cult following they have today i recognize people love them like they do landcruisers
 
I follow Dave Ramsey’s principles and only buy things with cash. I have a 0 credit score and am currently renting and saving for a house.
I’m 27 and remember what it was like just a couple years ago at 22.
Don’t fall into the trap of credit scores and debt.
Look at all the people struggling in our country right now because they’ve borrowed their way thru life or forgot all about what happened in 2008.
Cash is king. Buy it and be done with it.
Just because your parents are older than you, it doesn’t mean that they are smarter.
What this guy says x 1000. I’m 45 and have owe nothing but my mortgage. I follow Dave Ramsey’s plan as well. My daughter is 23. She just bought her first car on her own yesterday, a 2007 Sequoia with 135k for 7 grand in cash. She’s been saving since she graduated. A lender or co-signer owns you until you pay it back. Work, save, and don’t believe the bull**** that credit cards are necessary and everyone has car payments. You just dodged a bullet.
 
I’m curious... what do your parents drive?

A few thoughts since most of us are looking for a way to pass the time these days.

My first truck was a 94 Land Rover Discovery in 2003. Man I loved that truck but it was a money pit and PITA—-and it had the 3.9L Rover V8 which was considered to be one of the most reliable variants 😂. I did what I could myself and was mechanically inclined but had no experience working on cars and knew no one that did. It actually never left me stranded once but was a constant battle and was definitely a bit unsafe at at times. This was all on my parent’s dime (except the mods) and I still feel guilty about it. Hindsight is 20/20 and I underestimated their reputation for unreliability. A $5k rover was far more than $5k. I should have just gotten a Civic or Carolla.

In 2007 or so, my parents made me
swap it for a 2005 v6 Grand Cherokee. I hated the idea of it but knew they were right. It’s still in the family to this day and never had issues...I’m still surprised by that.

That experience is why I’m a a diehard Land Cruiser guy now haha.

The moral of the story is I get what your parents *think* they are protecting you from. You paying an arm and a leg to maintain it as a recent grad because it’s ‘old’.

Granted they’re wrong and would probably outlast/be around longer than whatever they’re driving now. Plus they’re being overly authoritarian and jerks about it considering you’re footing the bill and 21.

There is a catch though. Yes, Cruisers have a reputation for being indestructible and extremely reliable but people often conflate that with not having to maintain it.

Cruisers need maintenance and things do need to be replaced to go their next 250k miles. At that mileage things bushings, ball joints, steering rack bushings and the rack itself, and half shafts are at the end of their lives or start going. Buying a 20-ish year old or older Cruiser is only economical if you do a good chunk of the work yourself.

If you can’t and are short on cash you skip maintenance and repairs that are needed but may not seem necessary. Since they’re tanks they’ll go down the road with a ton of things wrong or out of spec. Continue doing that and they won’t be reliable. And IMHO, if you take them to average mechanics and/or are using cheap parts and they’ll continue to deteriorate.

Drive a cheap beater for a few years then get the cruiser of your dreams and prove them wrong. You’ll also get a much better truck buying one here and/or flying and driving a truck from a southern state with no salt. Then fluid film or krown will be your best friend of you have to drive it in salt...but you should keep the beater for that.

This rant may or may not be helpful but what I’m trying to say is going into a potential recession they could be doing you a huge favor despite them being dbags about it.
Absolutely agree with this. From a teenager standpoint, with the LX being my first vehicle, these trucks last a long time, but proper maintenance will still need to be conducted. My truck has 292K on it, and I'm just getting to basic maintenance, like fluids, timing belt, etc. and installing accessories myself. If your passionate enough, and are willing to do maintenance, by all means get it.
 
You bought a house with no credit history?
I had no existing loans/lines of credit of any kind when I bought the house other than a mortgage on the one we sold. I had a 25% down payment on the home in cash. We have 3 paid for cars. I haven’t had a credit card in 17 years.
 
I had no existing loans/lines of credit of any kind when I bought the house other than a mortgage on the one we sold. I had a 25% down payment on the home in cash. We have 3 paid for cars. I haven’t had a credit card in 17 years.
You had an existing mortgage....so of course you had a credit score. You're in a different boat than the kid you're giving out advice to.
 
You had an existing mortgage....so of course you had a credit score. You're in a different boat than the kid you're giving out advice to.
Guy had a house but saying he had no credit....hmmm

@Kabanstva , Careful the ramseyites will come after you. Interesting that every person who reads a Dave Ramsey books suddenly becomes a financial guru and is more than willing to spit some sort of comparison to their own scenario regardless of how different it is.

Btw, A 3% car loan on a 9k vehicle is like 700$ over the life of the loan. that’s it.
 
Dave Ramsey is great if you can't handle the temptation of credit cards. Otherwise, it's more of a guide than a rule. The bonus points you can earn using credit cards is excellent. You just have to make sure they are paid off every month. I use my card whenever I can, unless it's cheaper to pay with cash.

When the wife and I bought her 2017 GX a few months ago, we put as much on the card as the dealer would let us. The rest we wrote a check for. Waited two weeks, paid the card off, and received a couple hundred dollars in points. On the other side of this, we had a Subaru that we financed for 4 years and put zero money down. The reason is that we got 0.9% financing and our savings account collects between 1.6 and 2.0%. By doing it this way, we make more in interest than we would save by paying cash.

Yes, this isn't 100 series tech, but for @Bizzaror and any other younger folk, there's still some great info in here about the buying process. Also, keep in mind that it's a lot easier to be critical of other peoples spending when you're over 40 and financial stable. Moral of the story, keep at least 3 months of net income in your savings and never carry a balance on a credit card. Those two things alone will keep you on the positive side of your finances.
 
I dance with the devil and have a JKU and an LX.
I have owned several wranglers and although I LOVE my LX, for a first “grown up” car, a JK is a better choice. This is due to not having as many expensive things like AHC, Brake booster, timing belt etc. to worry about. If you were getting an LX that had a detailed history report where you had proof that those things had been recently done, that’s one thing. But... otherwise stick to the Fiat.

For your price range you can find a nice JK with well under 100k. Try to find a plain non lifted sport model that is as stock as possible. Also.. skip the Sahara, Rubicon, Willy’s editions, they aren’t worth the $ thanks to a HUGE aftermarket where you can build what you want later on for a fraction of the cost. If you can find one with factory steel wheels and tires, it’s far less likely to have been abused. 2007-2010 is gen 1 jk with the lesser quality engine that gave these things such a bad rep, and an older interior to boot. 2011-2018 is the gen 2 which is worth the $ to skip over the plagued 3.8 v6.

2011+ JKs are pretty reliable sans the 2014 year that had casting sand issues. I’ve put a collective 120k miles across 3 wranglers and had 3 issues total. My 2011 had no issues at all, my 2014 had the casting sand issue that caused me a summer of hell and warranty claims, and my 2017 had a brake booster leak after a lift, 35’s and gearing. It was $200 to replace instead of $1500 that it woulda been on the LX.

Good luck man!
 
What this guy says x 1000. I’m 45 and have owe nothing but my mortgage. I follow Dave Ramsey’s plan as well. My daughter is 23. She just bought her first car on her own yesterday, a 2007 Sequoia with 135k for 7 grand in cash. She’s been saving since she graduated. A lender or co-signer owns you until you pay it back. Work, save, and don’t believe the bulls*** that credit cards are necessary and everyone has car payments. You just dodged a bullet.

Agreed. You don’t have to take out loans to earn credit. We do use a credit card but we are responsible spenders, manage our money and pay it off every month. 12-18 months of that will give you a good credit score. The airline miles are a really nice perk. The only loan we have is our mortgage, I’ll be damned if I ever take out another loan. Save up, pay cash.
 
I really appreciate everyone's insight and opinions. I'll be sure to pay for my SUV in cash, then earn whatever I can back on my credit card. Also with all the advice I'll probably just look for a Toyota. I love the Lexus, but you guys are right with the repairs. Worst case scenario I can't wrench something, I'm gonna fork a lot of money to Toyota or Lexus. The search continues, and if anyone had websites or recommendations for buying in the South, I would like that. Till then, I'll slave away in retail! Hopefully I'll be back soon! Thank you all!
 
How much cash do you have? And how mechanically inclined are you?
See if there’s someone in the local cruiser club that may have a truck in your price point.

If your parents are adamant on a Jeep tell them OK, they can pay for it and you can pick it. Then go find the most expensive one on the lot.

I was 100% reliant on my parents when I was in college at 21 and it sucks so I totally feel you.

Maybe try and see if they’d go for a 4runner, and if they try and quote your uncle tell them he’s an old hack that doesn’t understand the market. Also ask them how many Lexus products he works on on a weekly basis, and if he says none really then question his ability to give advice about cars he doesn’t work on.
Then double down and start testing his knowledge about all kinds of cars. If he’s just so well versed.

What cars do your parents drive?
 
Maybe your parents saved you from a lemon. Theres lemon Land Cruisers out there where you could've spent an additional what you paid for it to get it all up to date. Timing belt + new steering rack + new OEM CVs + brake booster + new starter + fixing faulty VGRS would've set you back probably another cool $9k. All possible things that could've happened.

NJ Law requires any dealer to report the vehicle as a lemon, and if it's not reported they owe you for all repairs. If I had the CarFax I would show you how well this thing was taken care of, followed maintanence schedule to a T.

You can also pull records from the Toyota/Lexus website using the VIN. Only covers dealer services but it’s free to do and is a great tool when looking at buying LCs/LXs. You don’t have to actually own it to run it through the website.

I’m not that much older (33) but would caution you from assuming that because there is a law that says if it’s a lemon the dealer is going to be 100% honest and do the right thing. Most states have a similar law.

The language of lemon laws (and most pro-consumer laws) have been massaged based on input from pro-dealer lobbying groups. It’s completely counter to a dealership’s best interests to just lay down and shell out $$$$ without a fight. Not to mention proving it’s a lemon and getting it deemed as one is a huge gray area as you likely wouldn’t be able to prove anything beyond speculation. Not to mention the cost to lawyer up to fight is generally not worth it.

Not trying to lecture more because it sounds like your parents are plenty good at that but wanted to share my real world experience...in addition to the one I already shared 😂.

My wife and I bought a used non-turbo Outback that was definitely a lemon. It was pristine on paper— looked great inside and out and underneath. We even got to look at it and drive it before the dealer did anything to it (it was a fresh trade-in). It had all the maintenance records and had low miles but not so low it was questionable (38k) for a 5 year old car. People love their Subarus and we thought we would too. Never again will I own one.

We did a pre-purchase inspection by an independent shop and it needed a new battery, transmission fluid change, and control arm bushings right off the bat. We really had to twist the arm of the dealership to get that taken care of even when our salesman was awesome. The ‘new’ battery they gave us was dead within two years.

By 80k it had gotten a new steering rack, new front driveshaft, new valve cover gasket (a known issue at least), 6 wheel bearings, $3k worth of front end work, and the rear half of the exhaust literally turned to dust. There was no rust anywhere else, was rarely driven in heavy salt/snow/slush and always got an undercarriage wash after heavy salt exposure. It also had to have the tranny flushed again due to burnt fluid— luckily it still drove fine.

It was never abused by us... DC potholes didn’t help though. All work was done by reputable Japanese car specialists— I didn’t love it enough to learn to do the big stuff myself. My wife and I commute by public transit so it was a weekend/road trip car. I drove it mostly and am mechanically sympathetic/attune to identifying potential problems early on.

All of these issues (except the valve gaskets) were way outside the norm for that car with that mileage...let alone to have them all happen.

The lemon law couldn’t help us. In an ideal world it should have but the real world is far from ideal.

Unlike what most sellers would do we sold it to the next owner fully disclosing everything and I explained that level of work is atypical.

TL: DR: a car can check all the boxes for a good buy and not be—even a mainstream/basic Japanese car. Just because a law exists doesn’t mean it eliminates the issue.
 
Last edited:
You can also pull records from the Toyota website using the VIN. Only covers dealer services but it’s free to do and is a great tool when looking at buying LCs. You don’t have to actually own it to run it through the website.

I’m not that much older (33) but would caution you from assuming because there is a law that says if it’s a lemon the dealer is going to be 100% honest and do the right thing. Most states have a similar law.

Not trying to lecture more because it sounds like your parents are plenty good at that but share my real world experience...in addition to the one I already shared 😂.

The language of lemon laws (and most pro-consumer laws) have been massaged based on input from pro-dealer lobbying groups. It’s completely counter to a dealership’s best interests to just lay down and shell out $$$$ without a fight. Not to mention proving it’s a lemon and getting it deemed as one is a huge gray area as you likely wouldn’t be able to prove anything beyond speculation. Not to mention the cost to lawyer up to fight is generally not worth it.

My wife and I bought a used non-turbo Outback that was definitely a lemon. It was pristine on paper— looked great inside and out and underneath. We even got to look at it and drive it before the dealer did anything to it (it was a fresh trade-in). It had all the maintenance records and had low miles but not so low it was questionable (38k) for a 5 year old card People love their Subarus and we thought we would too. Never again will I own one.

We did pre-purchase inspection by an independent shop it needed a new battery, transmission fluid change, and control arm bushings right off the bat. We really had to twist the arm of the dealership to get that taken care of even when our salesman was awesome.

By 80k it had gotten a new steering rack, new front driveshaft, new valve cover gasket (a known issue at least), 6 wheel bearings, $3k worth of front end work, and the rear half of the exhaust literally turned to dust. There was no rust anywhere else, was rarely driven in heavy salt/snow/slush and always got an under carriage wash after heavy salt exposure. It also had to have the tranny flushed again due to burnt fluid— luckily it still drove fine.

It was never abused by us... DC potholes didn’t help though. All work was done by reputable Japanese car specialists— I didn’t love it enough to want to do the work myself. My wife and I commute by public transit so it was a weekend/road trip car. I drove it mostly and am mechanically sympathetic/attune to identifying potential problems early on.

All of these issues (except the valve gaskets) were way outside the norm for that car with that mileage...let alone to have them all happen.

The lemon law couldn’t help us. In an ideal world it should have but the real world is far from ideal.

Unlike what most sellers would do we sold it to the next owner fully disclosing everything and I explained that level of work is atypical.

TL:DR a car can check all the boxes for a good buy and not be—even a mainstream/basic Japanese car. Just because a law exists doesn’t mean it eliminates the issue.

X2 what is said here. Cruisers are expensive vehicles and they aren't cheap to run despite what every one is saying how reliable they are. Reliability doesn't mean its cheap. They are dependable and rugged but that comes at cost far higher than a 10 year old Tahoe. 150-200k is when most 100 series get traded in because of all the work that needs to be done and coming up. I think it was a really good decision by your parents as it would've saved you from a bunch of garage bills if you weren't doing the work yourself. There far more dependable choices for a car at 22 than a 100 series. For example at 190k miles, can bet the starter is on its way out (would cost around $1k at a shop to get it done), and the m/c is on its last bit of life before it goes ($2400 parts alone).

I can guarantee that any 100 series no matter how old, even the 07s, that at 190k miles will need at least $1-2k of work right off the bat no matter how religiously it was taken to the dealer for oil changes and maintenance. All the ones that have been gone through completely to the T won't have been traded in or sold. They're sold here on Mud for a premium. I can bet that within the next year or two (25k miles), you're going to run into most, if not all the issues that basically all 100 series need at 200k. If you aren't able to do your own work, it racks up quick.
 
If you were wanting to work on it yourself don’t forget to factor in your time and the money to acquire tools.

Yes, you can do a lot with a 10/12/14/17/19/23/24mm sockets, wrenches, some other basic tools, and a copy of Techstream but to make it reasonably efficient, enjoyable and sustainable you’ll need to invest in a bit more. Local clubs are indispensable if you have an active one nearby (check out the clubhouse forums here).

Also, sometimes it makes sense to do other work when you have things apart which is more $$$ but less headache down the road and definitely less $$$ if paying someone to do it.

For example, the 90k timing belt interval should also include the water pump, heater Ts, idler pulleys, front crank seal, and cam shaft seals because of the duplicative labor involved.

Also....if you’re a wrenching nood sometimes you accidentally break other stuff when attempting to fix something. Ask how I know.

Apologies for the continued brain dump but definitely know where you’re coming from so it struck a chord. It sounds like we’re both car/Land Cruiser enthusiasts coming from a non-gear head family/existence... minus your uncle of course but he has questionable opinions on LXs 😂. Plus I’m from Jersey originally.

Here’s what I’d do if I were you. Buy a beater and save for LC, keep the beater when you get the LC as I mentioned in my previous post. In the meantime, convince your uncle to teach you a bit about wrenching and show him you’re not part of the know-it-all generation (#okboomer). Continue your research here, dive into the factory service manuals, watch YouTube videos (@otramm’s channel is a great resource) so you know if/when he’s giving bad advice and respectfully/kindly educate him on these trucks.

End goal is to have a shop that you can use on the weekends if he’s local and maybe you’ll convert another non-believer. Worst case you’ll be more prepared for when you do land your LC.
 
Last edited:
If you were wanting to work on it yourself don’t forget to factor in your time and the money to acquire tools.

Yes, you can do a lot with a 10/12/14/17/19/23/24mm sockets, wrenches, some other basic tools, and a copy of Techstream but to make it reasonably efficient, enjoyable and sustainable you’ll need to invest in a bit more. Local clubs are indispensable if you have an active one nearby (check out the clubhouse forums here).

Also, sometimes it makes sense to do other work when you have things apart which is more $$$ but less headache down the road and definitely less $$$ if paying someone to do it.

For example, the 90k timing belt interval should also include the water pump, heater Ts, idler pulleys, front crank seal, and cam shaft seals because of the duplicative labor involved.

Also....if you’re a wrenching mood sometimes you accidentally break other stuff when attempting to fix something. Ask how I know.

Apologies for the continued brain dump but definitely know where you’re coming from so it struck a chord. It sounds like we’re both car/Land Cruiser enthusiasts coming from a non-gear head family/existence... minus your uncle of course but he has questionable opinions on LXs 😂. Plus I’m from Jersey originally.

Here’s what I’d do if I were you. Buy a beater and save for LC, keep the beater when you get the LC as I mentioned in my previous post. In the meantime, convince your uncle to teach you a bit about wrenching and show him you’re not part of the know-it-all generation (#okboomer). Continue your research here, dive into the factory service manuals, watch YouTube videos (@otramm’s channel is a great resource) so you know if/when he’s giving bad advice and respectfully/kindly educate him on these trucks.

End goal is to have a shop that you can use on the weekends if he’s local and maybe you’ll convert another non-believer. Worst case you’ll be more prepared for when you do land your LC.
You gave me some great ideas. After all, he didn't want to sell me a J120 at his dealership because I pointed out it needed work before I bought it. Maybe I should visit that again and tell him to give me the shop so I can fix it lol
 
Hey neighbor. So you still have the LX? I got confused reading all the comments about credit score. If you need a hand with maint. I wrench on my LC and was a mechanic for 10 years so I could help you. Have had my LC and other than preventative maint. no issues yet.
 
You framed your posts in a way that made it seem like you were buying it on your own, and your parents didn't want you to. As it turns out, you were getting a loan and needed them to co-sign (Edit: This also makes no sense if you have an almost 800 credit score). The interest rate was probably at least 5% on such an old vehicle. Then I think I also saw that you're fresh out of school and working in retail. And you wanted to treat yourself?

You've come off as very immature in multiple ways: the way you've talked about your family, celebrating the purchase you've made but as it turns out you hadn't, mocking wranglers and your uncle's opinion, claiming an almost 800 credit score but wanting the car on a loan to build credit (what??????) etc.. You may have some people here on your side from a reliability standpoint, but this would have been a terrible financial decision and your parents have done you a solid.
 
Your parents definitely saved you from a mistake, but IMO it's a blessing. 20% unemployment right now my dude. Cherish your job focus on that so you don't lose it. Check Craigslist, it is probably flooded with good cheap cars from people trying to make cash to pay rent. Wait a month or two and maybe you can get that same LX for $7000. I got my first car loan at 22 and never had any history of credit through my bank and nobody co-signed for me, I still own the car.
 
You framed your posts in a way that made it seem like you were buying it on your own, and your parents didn't want you to. As it turns out, you were getting a loan and needed them to co-sign (Edit: This also makes no sense if you have an almost 800 credit score). The interest rate was probably at least 5% on such an old vehicle. Then I think I also saw that you're fresh out of school and working in retail. And you wanted to treat yourself?

You've come off as very immature in multiple ways: the way you've talked about your family, celebrating the purchase you've made but as it turns out you hadn't, mocking wranglers and your uncle's opinion, claiming an almost 800 credit score but wanting the car on a loan to build credit (what??????) etc.. You may have some people here on your side from a reliability standpoint, but this would have been a terrible financial decision and your parents have done you a solid.
Yes I have a near 800, all the banks and CUs near me told me I needed a cosigner. I'm going to assume b/c of my age I'm a huge liability to them. Also I make more than enough from retail to pay for all my expenses and a car payment right now while saving more than 50% of my checks. Also I do valuable my parents opinions, but when they're saying to get a base Wrangler over a LC I'm not listening to them on that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom