re: stay with skinny tire....
Yes. The 12.50's are too wide, in my opinion. They give good float on sand, but that's all they're good for. I'd rather have a little higher weight per square inch of contact area for mud and snow.
On one very slick dirt road the tires floated very nicely on the muddy surface, only going down about an inch. But I could not get a good bite with them, and steering was becoming useless.
For snow and ice, the tires also float a bit too much, and the floatation works against them in trying to bite their way out of icy ruts. I have heavy chains that solved that problem, but this only makes the issue of the rear wheel well clearance worse. There is some chain contact when bumps are hit, and they will be, as that's the nature of ice rutted roads.
The point here is that 10.50 or even 9.50 tires would be superior for most uses, and I wish the PO has gone to 10.50s. The tires have minimal wear on them, and I don't relish the costly prospect of replacing them.