Headgasket Solution?(NEW!!)

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Threads
12
Messages
363
Location
Redding,Ca
Hey everyone. I've been working with a guy @ Cometic about all our HG problems. It seems that someone else here had some time ago as well. They have given me a new spark. Here is the skinny.

Cometic has the factory HG for reference & already has a pattern.

Cometic does not have the sealing area of the gasket done. The raised area of the gasket.

Cometic is willing to put out the effort & time to engineer a new "superior" product.

We will have to COMMIT with hard $$$ cash. Someone will need to pool together the money. Someone reliable. Or we can just get a firm $ from Cometic after the form is submitted & pay them directly. They want a order of 50 to 100 gaskets. I just don't have the budget to fund this. I will pay $150 to $250 for one. I will even pay without product. Maybe a cruiser guy or retailer wants to take on a new venture?? I dunno...

Cometic has E-mailed me a "Gasket Request Form". The form is PDF so I can E-mail it to anyone that would like to make the extra effort. I have alot on my plate right now, so I'll do the best I can to help, but I need some GURUS. Lets give this a good shot. There are questions on the form about layers etc. that I need some ideas for. Even though I am boosted, I think we should concentrate on a gasket that will be good for N/A stock first. I have had great success with MLS and really believe it will be a good solution. I will try to post the request form or fax it to who ever wants to take control of this project. I need someone that has more experience than myself with the specs & may also have some engines apart for reference.

Ideas??? Hope I'm going the right direction with this -Andy
 
Has anyone had a 'new' style HG fail yet?????
 
I don't think so. The new gasket has been redesigned several times to eliminate any flaws. Paying someone to do that again seems odd. I have never heard of these folks, but I am sure they put out a good product. That being said, I highly doubt that it would be superior to the Current toyota gasket, and it will be even less likely to sell at that price.

.02

Dan
 
Supposedly the original HG had a problem, which has been resolved on any replacement gasket sold now.

Would they be making a complete kit. or just the HG?

What would make their product 'superior'? Who gets to be the guinea pig?

-Spike
 
I'm pretty sure after talking to Robbie and Ben and Christo and the collective fine folks here that no one has had a new style headgasket fail. Now, some have had to replace the new style headgasket but that was due to cracks in the head or the block, incorrect installation, etc. I've heard that the cometic is an amazing product however in this application I'm not so sure it is relevant. Can you get them to make a "decompression gasket" so I can go to twenty psi?
:D :D :D
 
LOL. Maybe there will not be a need for the general 80 crowd. I do believe in the new design. I just put one in my truck. However, it is not ideal to have any composite gasket between a Iron/aluminum combo. This is why there is no modern performance vehicles (that I'm aware of) running anything like our "revised " HG. I have seen a trend over the past 7 or so years of Mitsubishi, Honda, others... Even Felpro changing over to MLS. Just did a 06 EVO today. OE is a 5 layer MLS. Miata last week for a blown HG. Upgrade is MLS. I realize Toyota has great engineers, but it is without a doubt less expensive to produce a composite HG. I personally think that the new OE HG will still fail in due time. It would just be nice to have the option. My shop used a Cometic HG for a Acura recently. Once the first production run has been done for the engine, you can use the form to build custom high or low compression gaskets. I just specified the required compression ratio & my machinist was able to order it. This could be great for all motor or low comp. boost applications. This may however be like the turbo kits. Not for everyone.

Again. I am just sharing my humble opinion with you guys & would like to say Thanks to all, for the acurate info & time you guys spend on MUD! FWIW I'm ANTI forums... Anti EBAY... but you guys have me hooked. Can't say enough about how well MUD is moderated. -Andy
 
OK, apparently this isn't an apples-to-apples comparison. I'm not familiar with MLS, I think I know what 'composite' means, but could you give me the run down for HG dummies? :D Or a link, I'll try Google in the meantime.

-Spike
 
Turbocruiser- YES! It is just a matter of another layer. WALA! lower compression. I know this sounds scary but, I had a tech remove the valves on a mitsu head. The customer had the head surfaced soooooo many times the machinist needed them out as to not cut the valves while surfacing:eek: He then ordered 2 MLS gaskets, drilled the rivets and installed new rivets into BOTH HGs.:doh: The car has been living at 22psi for several years.
 
Never mind, I'm ejumicating myself at http://www.cometic.com/faq.aspx

One thing that bothers me is this quote from their front page- "In only 17 years Cometic Gasket, Inc. has grown into a leading worldwide supplier of custom and short-run gaskets for the motorsports industry."

It doesn't mention expected longetivity anywhere that I found. I figure they might make different gaskets for say, dragsters that will run once and be torn down. I assume the MLS isn't one of those?

-Spike
 
I'd also like to add. HG Technology has advanced quite a bit in the last 10 years. We will probably make huge advancements with the forced induction LCs in the next year or two. Lots of interest here with everyone like Dusty, Msgrunt, Slee, etc... Wideband technology. Someone will push the envelope & go bigger. Someone will break something. But mostly, our favorite vehicle will be better on & off road. Damn. I want a HG. I'm gonna make one with foil & old gum wrappers:bounce::bounce2:
 
This sounds very good. Robbie posted a few years ago saying the MLS gaskets would be his first choice but couldn't get it done.

Realistically you'll need to get some hard numbers to move forward. The exact amount of orders and at what cost. Once you have that start a poll thread so people can select to be "in" and it will keep a running tally for you.

I don't know how the layer thing works out but I'd imaging the number of layers that equals the thickness of the current head gasket
 
Quit spending my money damnit! I am planning on PMing my HG this winter...if we can get it done by then I am in...depending on the cost.
 
I have a nice seat on the fence as I ponder a PM driven replacement for my '94 with ~170K miles....Alert to Dan - I firmly request that voodoo and knitting needles be held dormant to ward off rash of HG failures in anticipation of potential alternative solution....:D I would love to do my HG as a PM as opposed to having a three ring circus of stranding, towing, etc......
 
Never mind, I'm ejumicating myself at http://www.cometic.com/faq.aspx

One thing that bothers me is this quote from their front page- "In only 17 years Cometic Gasket, Inc. has grown into a leading worldwide supplier of custom and short-run gaskets for the motorsports industry."

It doesn't mention expected longetivity anywhere that I found. I figure they might make different gaskets for say, dragsters that will run once and be torn down. I assume the MLS isn't one of those?

-Spike

Perhaps "short-run" means short production run, not short longevity?
 
Its been a some years since I was closely involved with head gaskets but the multi layered steel (MLS) design was the sweet setup even back in the late 80's. The problem was the cost. The elastomer coated steel was expensive and the tooling required to make the gaskets was way more expensive than the conventional composite designs. The real strength of the MLS design was the lack of creep. The gasket acted like a true spring. You could crush it and it would spring back with nearly the same sealing stress it started with. With a conventional gasket, if you can retain 75% of the initial stress, your lucky. MLS was the only solution for some engines, particularly engines that were short on adequate head bolt stress. (I6 engines tend to have plenty of bolt stress.) Early multivalve engines sometimes had little weeny head bolts.

While it is possible for a small custom shop to produce a decent aftermarket HG, I would lean toward the Toyota solution unless I had a highly modified, heavily boosted motor due to the extensive field testing and history of the mass produced HG.
 
Turbocruiser- YES! It is just a matter of another layer. WALA! lower compression. I know this sounds scary but, I had a tech remove the valves on a mitsu head. The customer had the head surfaced soooooo many times the machinist needed them out as to not cut the valves while surfacing:eek: He then ordered 2 MLS gaskets, drilled the rivets and installed new rivets into BOTH HGs.:doh: The car has been living at 22psi for several years.

Agree, this is pretty common to do with the Audi MLS gaskets as well. Buy two, make a 'Audisport version' using a rivet gun. Compression goes from 9:3 to 8.6.

Fiber headgaskets are still used, but a lot of manufacturers went to MLS for all the identified reasons. The first of which is that mixing antifreeze flavors doesn't not degrade the gasket!

Audi made the swap to MLS gaskets in 1991. And a known upgrade is to replace fiber with MLS on earlier cars.

Scott J
 
FWIW, the 2JZ-GTE in the Supra comes from the factory with a Toyota MLS HG. This is after major HG problems with the 7M-GTE from the earlier Supra. Even Toyota recognizes the benefits.

Almost no one upgrades the HG in the 2JZ-GTE. The stocker is good for well over 1000HP; 3x factory output.

(I know. Supra, Supra, Supra. :shotts:)
 
Back
Top Bottom