head gasket replacement - advice needed

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I would go with number one and be happy. If you had done the job yourself you would never have known about it. It sounds like he is doing everything by the book and I assume you are using factory parts so I wouldn't think the warranty is necessary. If you decide to go with number five let me know, I'll trade you a nice running 3fe powered 92 with an intact head gasket.

I thought you were done with the "fancy" 1fzfe's? Anyway, you've got a nice truck, so it's tempting as it is.

I think I'm going with option number 1 unless someone has a compelling reason otherwise.
 
Chances are others have had the exact same issue, only your mechanic found it on yours, their's did not.

I would say go with Option #1.

I hate it when stuff like this comes up. You have done everything you can do to plan and repair, and then bam. something else screws up the plans. Good Luck
 
skip decking the block and just have the engine put back together. I can understand the guy not warranting a failure at that point but to not warranty anything seems a little excessive.

We've got it worked out. He's going to warranty everything but the gasket itself. I think that he should warranty against a failure at some other point, too, but I don't think he's comfortable doing that. I will ask him again tomorrow, though.
 
dont sweat it!! i have done a few of the 1fz head gaskets and never had the block decked. always have the head pressure tested and checked for flatness(at a machine shop).

odd that the head was straight and the block was off.....

X2 on making sure the checking tool is actually straight(not likely)

oWG2Q
 
Last edited:
I haven't actually messed with the head on the 1FZ, but I have had experience with similar toyota engines, the 2jz and 7m (I was a supra guy). I've had some that were questionable in flatness and I never redecked them. I had a few heads shaved, but never the block. I suggest using ARP head studs and spraying the gasket with copper spray. They sell copper spray at most auto parts stores. I have done this on a 400hp+ 2jz with an out of tolerance deck and it held for the 70k miles I owned the car and was still holding fine when I sold it. The same on a 7m. Copper spray fills in a lot of imperfections and ARP studs will allow you to torque them properly. Also, not sure is this applies to the 1FZ, but the very common HG failure on the 7m was due to the torque specs on the head bolts being wrong during production, maybe some others can chime in on that topic.
 
I'm with Jig - there are a number of products that will help with irregularities on a block mating surface. What you have is not warpage but from the deteriorating old gasket vibrating against the block, or combustion gasses similarly removing a bit of material. Lots of stuff for that, and also the gasket itself will account for a bit. It's important to know that this is neither a high compression engine, nor a high output engine. It's a slow RPM industrial engine. My block had some slight variations in areas the old gasket was failing that did not concern me. Since installing my HG, I've had the truck at wide open throttle for over 4 minutes pulling a 6000lb trailer up a grade. As the former Worldwide Powertrain Planner for GM (tooting my horn here), that's out and out torture. No problem.

I'd bolt it up and you'll find it will not be a problem.

DougM
 
Get your rich doctor wife to spot ya! :flipoff2:

Oh, and what the others said. Make sure the head gets checked.

I'll be calling CDan for HG pm soon.
 
Ok...I'm not a hack...I've rebuilt and still do rebuild plenty of motors...personally, unless I'm given reason to question the straightness of a block or head, I usually don't even check them.

I guess if my motor just FOR SURE smoked a head gasket I'd check the head, but a cast-iron block? Most assuredly no is the answer on whether I'd check it. Fug, it's cast-iron.

Mechanics, when they are charging you and warrantying the job, like to CYA as much as possible. So I can understand his trepidation about giving you a 2y/24k warranty on the headgasket given what he has "found."

But I'd bet my left n*t that this engine will have no issue provided that everything else is done right. So yes....go with option #1 in your list. And keep us posted, a la "stump the chumps" from Car Talk as to your success, or lack of.
 
Ok...I'm not a hack...I've rebuilt and still do rebuild plenty of motors...personally, unless I'm given reason to question the straightness of a block or head, I usually don't even check them.

I guess if my motor just FOR SURE smoked a head gasket I'd check the head, but a cast-iron block? Most assuredly no is the answer on whether I'd check it. Fug, it's cast-iron.

Mechanics, when they are charging you and warrantying the job, like to CYA as much as possible. So I can understand his trepidation about giving you a 2y/24k warranty on the headgasket given what he has "found."

But I'd bet my left n*t that this engine will have no issue provided that everything else is done right. So yes....go with option #1 in your list. And keep us posted, a la "stump the chumps" from Car Talk as to your success, or lack of.

Good points.

Now get that SC installed.

:flipoff2:

-o-
 
It's important to know that this is neither a high compression engine, nor a high output engine. It's a slow RPM industrial engine. My block had some slight variations in areas the old gasket was failing that did not concern me.

Or, as the saying goes, it's a tractor engine with emissions BS and A/C.

:grinpimp:
 
Jay, I just read through this thread and can certainly empathize. Sometimes less knowledge is more if you know what I mean. I have nothing to base my opinion on other than gut feel but if it were me I would put it back together and forget about it.

I hope I never have to PM you for the mechanic's contact details. :D
 
somebody beat me to it, but I was going (and am here) to say that when you're talking about 1/2 thou you better make sure your tools are up to par. It's not obvious at all having a long piece of steel floating around the shop that is straight within a thou I would think. Obviously one can do things like flip it over etc but that still would not show all imperfections. FWIW I did play once with some calipers using standard blocks and I saw some that were well over 1 thou off.
 
Good points.

Now get that SC installed.

:flipoff2:

-o-

Working on it...or not...soon...for this summer maybe??? After a birf job PM head gasket, (whoa, did I just say that?) fix the parking brake, good wash and wax, and finish the brake job on my buddy's Chevy dually, and change the GF's oil, get the boat ready for the fishing trip, blah, blah, blah--But you are right...it needs to be installed!
 
somebody beat me to it, but I was going (and am here) to say that when you're talking about 1/2 thou you better make sure your tools are up to par. It's not obvious at all having a long piece of steel floating around the shop that is straight within a thou I would think. Obviously one can do things like flip it over etc but that still would not show all imperfections.

The guy had a bar that looks just like the one in the FSM, and it was in a cardboard box, and it had a plastic sleeve protecting its edge, but still, who knows.
 
Back
Top Bottom