FJ80 compared to cherokee?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 13, 2009
Threads
2
Messages
4
how do you guys compare cherokees to the landcruisers? i think they also come with 4.0 motors solid axle front and rear, a bit lighter, i think they do better on gas as well due to weight, i havent been in one, and i have a 95 fj80, i love it, but around town wouldnt mind getting a cherokee or for short trips.

are there certain years to look for, or they all pretty much the same 4.0 4x4?
 
Like comparing apples and oranges. Both get you there, one has a true frame while the other is unit body, one will last almost forever while the other has auto transmission issues, lighter axles and rides far worse. I know, I've owned 2 of them. I like the Cherokees but they're no LC although their 4.0-4.2 liter engine is pretty good and last almost forever.
 
how do you guys compare cherokees to the landcruisers? i think they also come with 4.0 motors solid axle front and rear, a bit lighter, i think they do better on gas as well due to weight, i havent been in one, and i have a 95 fj80, i love it, but around town wouldnt mind getting a cherokee or for short trips.

are there certain years to look for, or they all pretty much the same 4.0 4x4?

So, you are considering spending several thousand dollars on another vehicle to save money on gas? Between the initial price, the maintenance and the gas you are still using - it would most likely be a long road to paying off for you.
 
I have to STRONGLY agree with SeanAndHis80,

Not even worth the consideration or comparison.
 
With Cherokees it is best to get a red one. Red jeeps are the best ever. The only thing better is a white Land Cruiser. The other colors of Land Cruisers are just ok, but everyone agrees the white Cruisers outperform all others, even the 40th anniversary with its two-tone leather seats. I have a green Land Cruiser, and it can never keep up with a white one, but usually it can keep up with a Jeep, so long as isn't a red one. Once I was leading a Jeep up a hill climb, but I couldn't make it, and the Jeep could, because it had heated seats. And it was red.
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Sorry, I just can't take anymore 'what rig is better' questions....
 
I have to agree that this rig comparison is getting pretty old.

As a matter of fact....shouldn't any of this type of banter belong in the Chat section of Mud?

Just my thoughts..maybe on of the moderators will step in and put a stop to it all.
 
This really isn't a "which is better" question.

A Cherokee is a good 1,500 lbs lighter than an 80, and a heck of a lot smaller. The 4.0L engine has reliability reputation of 200K-300K easy, and at least in '97+ years they used a Toyota auto transmission.

All of the transfer cases are weak and have a slip yoke in the case. Fine for road use, but that's it (there is a fix). The rear axle is weak in either form (find one with the Chrysler 8.25 over the Dana 35) - the Dana 30 front on later models is about as suitable to the lighter Cherokee as the 80 series front is to the heavy 80 (you could reasonably run 35" tires on it).

The Cherokee in stock form will feel like a sports car compared to an 80 in terms of power to weight ratio, they really are fun little trucks. It will also feel like a tin can to a large degree compared to your 80 for the same reason.

I had one for 8 years before I outgrew it and bought my 80, and over 105K miles it only had one failure: a window motor. And I wheeled it hard through about 80K of those miles, spending 20K along the way to upgrade axles, etc.

My 80 is what I had always hoped I could build a Cherokee into being right out of the box. They really are not comparable vehicles, and you will not save material gas money by buying one. It's a big inefficient inline six - I think best I ever did was around 16 mpg stock. :meh:
 
I didn't mean to give the Rookie a hard time...

I don't see why you would want a Cherokee as an alternative vehicle to the 80 you already own to run around town in. The mileage is about the same, yes the 4.0 is a lively motor but it isn't a sports car. Whatever money the Cherokee costs to own and maintain is better spent on your 80. JMO, but similar second vehicles in the name of saving money don't usually make financial sense.
 
Not another heep question! Look what has happened to our car and truck industries - that should put your inquiry to rest! The rest of the World, if they have a choice and are not forced to buy jeeps, buy Toyotas!:cheers:
 
Are you somewhere that you need a 4x4 to run around town??
Get an old corolla or something.
 
Doesn't it also have a unibody construction vs. a fully boxed frame. My buddies spend more time welding and repairing the Jeep's than driving. I am still a rookie...
 
Since this is tech, technically I would never buy a Cherokee. I agree with Mike red ones have less problems and are more capable. :flipoff2:
 
Have you ever sat in the back seat of one? Cramped and you feel like you are falling through the seat bottom, and I'm way south of 6', and ~150lbs.
 
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha
 
I'd imagine just the extra insurance cost will more than make up for any savings from better gas mileage. Heck, the added basic maintenance would as well...

The FJ80 drives much nicer than a Cherokee.
 
If you're looking for a daily driver, look for something economical:hhmm:. Its also nice to have something considerably different, like a sedan or sports car. The change up is good for the soul.:steer::bounce::bounce2:
 
Some of you noobs need to lighten up! I am sure every one of your posts has been chock full of invaluable technicle data!:meh: If you don't like the subject don't read the post!

OP, I have a 93 XJ and a 95 80. They are two very different trucks. For running around town the XJ is just fine. If you take care of regular maint. it will last a long time. Mine has 226,000 miles and the engine has a long way to go. The rest of the truck is falling apart around the OME suspension and motor. Yet it just keeps going. I would avoid an auto and get the 5 speed. With the OME suspension it is a good light/medium duty trail rig. The turning radius is awsome for tight situations. Mine has seen a ton of rough fire roads while hunting and fishing. I have never wheeled this truck so can't talk about that.

The LC is so much more capable than the XJ. With the factory lockers it is a true rock crawling rig. It's weight is a bonus in most traction situations but not all. You can run larger tires without worrying about snapping axles or regearing. It is far more comfortable. It will out perform the xj in almost all areas except acceleration and turning radius.

Look at how much you will spend on the XJ to "save money." Figure out how much gass that extra 5 mpg will buy and make your decision.

:cheers:
 
a car is definitely the best around town vehicle if the cost of running the 80 around town is killing you.

I think the Jeep would turn into a money pit and the front seats are just plain not nearly as comfy.

In terms of durability, there are some Cherokees out there still and it is still one of the best looking, most utilitarian 4x4s ever made, it embodies what this category of vehicle is so well. I don't think adding another older model 4x4 to the stable will really create a lot of value-focused benefit to your stable.
 
Buddy has a 91 cherokee, his wife bought it new before they were married. he inherited it as it got older, she got a '03 liberty which has done well for them so far, (they drive American only)

The Cherokee's AW4 transmission is closely related to our A343 that part has been reliable for him except for the solinoids, same problems we have and an easy fix.

It has well over 200K, about the same as my LX, my FJ62 has right 200K or so, both the cruisers are holding up much better than Cherokee, the cherokee is at the end of its life, he has pretty much parked it as it is stating to need as many hours working on it as driving it.

but a Cherokee should be cheaper to purchase, if you get one in goods shape for little coin it could be a fun beat 'em up truck, it has a certain disposable nature a cruiser does not,

YouTube - Destroying Cherokee

If you get one stay away from the V6. the I-6 4.0 is the way to go. not sure what year but the later years got a better intake also.
 
Back
Top Bottom