Electrical dilemma

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 22, 2007
Threads
62
Messages
471
Location
Fort Collins, CO
Summary of problem: 1996 80 series. LC intermittently has trouble starting up.

Replacement of parts:
Starter: last year,OEM
Alternator: 3x in last 10 months, OEM
Battery: last week, Interstate Megatron
New Ignition switch and tumbler

Repairs:
Additional hot and ground cables to alternator
Electrical short in Driver side door switch

This morning, truck did not turn over at all. Battery showed 12.3v
Came back later in the afternoon and jumped with Microstart. Did not turn over at all.
Jumped from vehicle battery to LC and started right up.

Even the Forum famous NLXTACY traced down a parasitic drain that no one else found and we're still having troubles here.

All ideas welcome.
 
Last edited:
Background on the alt, OE failed then two bad rebuilds including an OEM that didn't put out more than 11.7v

Likely has a dome circuit short somewhere. But this is still odd.

Problems started when starter was replaced last year.
 
Basic rule of electrical troubleshooting is start at the problem and isolate circuits. Pull fuses and test for battery drain on each circuit. Get a good multimeter and write down everything you do. If you have extra electronics disconnect them. Set aside a weekend and try not to get frustrated...
 
Basic rule of electrical troubleshooting is start at the problem and isolate circuits. Pull fuses and test for battery drain on each circuit. Get a good multimeter and write down everything you do. If you have extra electronics disconnect them. Set aside a weekend and try not to get frustrated...

Hehe, been there done that. Isolated to dome circuit.
 
The dome circuit runs a ton of miscellaneous stuff and it can be hard to isolate it all. Check out this matrix from the power source section of the EWD. There's stuff listed for the dome circuit on all 8 pages:
 

Attachments

Summary of problem: 1996 80 series. LC intermittently has trouble starting up.

Replacement of parts:
Starter: last year,OEM
Alternator: 3x in last 10 months, OEM
Battery: last week, Interstate Megatron

Repairs:
Additional hot and ground cables to alternator
Electrical short in Driver side door switch

This morning, truck did not turn over at all. Battery showed 12.3v
Came back later in the afternoon and jumped with Microstart. Did not turn over at all.
Jumped from vehicle battery to LC and started right up.

Even the Forum famous NLXTACY traced down a parasitic drain that no one else found and we're still having troubles here.

All ideas welcome.

When you say "did not turn over at all" do you mean the starter does not spin or do you mean the engine won't fire up?

There's no reason a good battery charged to 12.3v can't spin the starter except if there's a problem in the starter circuit. It would be instructive to measure the voltage at the battery when you turn the ignition key to start. If it stays at 12.3 and the starter motor doesn't run, then you've got a problem in the starter circuit.
 
When you say "did not turn over at all" do you mean the starter does not spin or do you mean the engine won't fire up?
The starter did not spin at all


There's no reason a good battery charged to 12.3v can't spin the starter except if there's a problem in the starter circuit. It would be instructive to measure the voltage at the battery when you turn the ignition key to start. If it stays at 12.3 and the starter motor doesn't run, then you've got a problem in the starter circuit.[/QUOTE]
I got it started earlier during the day and left it running for 30 minutes to charge the battery. Came back to it 5 hours later. Battery reading was 12.4v. I turned the ignition key and voltage dropped to 10.4v for a brief moment then went up to 14.4v and it was started.
 
It sounds like you may have a failing cell. The cells are 2V each in a wet cell battery.

12.6V is usually considered a fully charged battery if measured after sitting a few hours.

You say it went to 14.4, was that after it was running? If so, that tells me your alternator is fine.

A lot can be learned by cranking with the headlights on. Headlights will only draw a fraction of what a starter does, and you can judge your battery state by how dim the headlights get while you're cranking.
 
It sounds like you may have a failing cell. The cells are 2V each in a wet cell battery.

12.6V is usually considered a fully charged battery if measured after sitting a few hours.

You say it went to 14.4, was that after it was running? If so, that tells me your alternator is fine.

A lot can be learned by cranking with the headlights on. Headlights will only draw a fraction of what a starter does, and you can judge your battery state by how dim the headlights get while you're cranking.


It could be a failing battery cell. Not likely as the battery is only a week old. I know it can happen, but not likely.

I just did your suggested test with the headlights. They do dim a little. I don't know how I would quantify that to you other than yes, they did dim a little while cranking.
 
Last edited:
Step 1. Get a good charger onto the battery and give it a full 24 hour charge cycle. Alternator is not the solution to charging a fairly discharged battery. 30 minutes is not long enough to charge.

Step 2. Put a meter RIGHT on the battery contacts - a decent meter, not some junk $5 (or free) meter. Then measure voltage as you crank. A DC clamp meter is something anyone that 'plays' with vehicles should own, it can then tell you actual current flow without having to interrupt wiring etc.

Parasitic draw is ONE issue, not starting/cranking at all is another issue. So, first step would be to charge the battery properly (see step 1 above) then verify if the engine will reliably crank and start. Get that resolved first. Monitor the battery voltage and current draw as the vehicle sits with everything off and engine off. Again, DC clamp meter is a good tool to own (also, not some junk unit either).

Then worry above identifying the parasitic draw. Quantify the current too - is it 200mA, 2A, 20A ????

cheers,
george.
 
Bad battery cables. These are a real pain to test. I have a carbon type tester that has found bad cables that look perfectly fine.
 
The next time it WON'T start, use the headlights to check it. If the lights go out, you have a bad connection or a bad battery. If the lights stay on bright, the starter circuit is likely at fault.

Again, when did you measure the 14.4V?

14.4 v was just after truck started. I measure 12.3v before start, dropping to 10.4v momentarily upon starting, and 14.4v after truck started and running.
 
Bad battery cables. These are a real pain to test. I have a carbon type tester that has found bad cables that look perfectly fine.

That is certainly a possibility. I'm following George's recommendations first. I'm charging with a good charger for 24 hours tomorrow.
I'll measure battery voltage before starting and during cranking. I'll report back on Saturday.
 
Do you know how to do a voltage drop test? That can tell you a lot about the cables and electrical system. It can be a long process to test all of the cables and switches and relays but it works. If need be I can explain it you
 
What size AWG wiring are you using for the alternator to battery, alternator to ground, battery to ground, and battery to starter? Did you change any of the wiring? What condition is the wiring. How are the connections? 12.3v is too low - could it be the battery is getting insufficient power from the alternator? How is the alternator grounded?

You were able to start right up there at the end. Was that from the vehicle main battery or from another vehicle?
 
What size AWG wiring are you using for the alternator to battery, alternator to ground, battery to ground, and battery to starter? Did you change any of the wiring? What condition is the wiring. How are the connections? 12.3v is too low - could it be the battery is getting insufficient power from the alternator? How is the alternator grounded?

You were able to start right up there at the end. Was that from the vehicle main battery or from another vehicle?

Alternater to battery is new 4g, Alternator to ground is new 4g. Battery to ground and battery to starter is stock cable and has not been changed. Could be a problem. All connections are solid. Alternater grounded to block and body.

Vehicle to vehicle finally got it started.
 
What size AWG wiring are you using for the alternator to battery, alternator to ground, battery to ground, and battery to starter? Did you change any of the wiring? What condition is the wiring. How are the connections? 12.3v is too low - could it be the battery is getting insufficient power from the alternator? How is the alternator grounded?

You were able to start right up there at the end. Was that from the vehicle main battery or from another vehicle?

All stock wiring to the starter/alt/ground except that there was an extra run on each added.

I'm already planning on changing the cables for Gil to the 1/0 I have here.
 
I saw a thread recently where a guy bought a reman starter and it failed quickly because the contacts weren't replaced flush. Perhaps your starter is bad already?
 
Back
Top Bottom