Different year engine swap

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Threads
69
Messages
498
Location
Tustin, CA
Hi all,

long story short, I sold my cruiser 3 years ago and I've regretted it ever since. Sold it to a kid that lived on my parents street and he might be selling it back to me because it's having some engine issues. Don't know what they are, as I'm waiting for his dad to give me a call and discuss.

it's a 93. Found a great deal on a low mileage 95 that recently had the head gasket done. Wondering if I could drop the 95 engine in to the 93. I know there are some slight differences (obd1 vs obd2) and wondering if this would be a compatible swap?

Thanks and I can't tell you all how excited I am to be back (hopefully!). Assuming the price is right I will definitely be buying it and replacing the engine. Current engine has about 240kplus and I know they've already replaced the radiator and done some other work. New engine has 180k and had the head gasket done at 140.
 
also threads are better with pics so here you go

20140523_182501.webp


20140523_182524.webp
 
It's just the engine out the 95. Previous owner did a v8 swap and now has the engine lying around.

This truck is the first vehicle I ever purchased with my own money that I actually enjoyed. Lots of hand me downs and old beater sedans in high school and college. I learned to turn a wrench on it, learned how to weld to build the sliders, did my first carpentry project when I built the drawers, learned 12v electrical when doing the dual battery and lighting setup.

I've been saving up for and looking for a van with a 4x4 conversion, but the thought of having my actual 80 back is just too good to pass up. Too many good memories.
 
Both engines 1FZFE? Strip the 95 engine down to just and engine, swap all of the emissions stuff from the 93 over to it. All the way to just a bare long block from valve cover to oil pan. The differences of components between OBD-1 and OBD-2 are just the stuff that bolts to the engine as far as I know. Should be pretty easy, and gives you a great chance to clean up the peripherals like EGR, Fuel Filter, any and all associated solenoids and VSV's. Change the valve cover and plug tube seals, clean the intake manifold and throttle body.... you know, all the fun stuff that sucks when you cant get to it when its under the hood!!

Sounds like fun!!
 
Both engines 1FZFE? Strip the 95 engine down to just and engine, swap all of the emissions stuff from the 93 over to it. All the way to just a bare long block from valve cover to oil pan. The differences of components between OBD-1 and OBD-2 are just the stuff that bolts to the engine as far as I know. Should be pretty easy, and gives you a great chance to clean up the peripherals like EGR, Fuel Filter, any and all associated solenoids and VSV's. Change the valve cover and plug tube seals, clean the intake manifold and throttle body.... you know, all the fun stuff that sucks when you cant get to it when its under the hood!!

Sounds like fun!!

exactly the answer I was looking for. Thanks! I'll keep everyone posted.
 
I wouldn't assume it needs a new engine. These engines are extremely sturdy, my '93 has 300k+ on it and is going very strong. If you can get your hands on the cruiser cheap, snatch it up and then jump into the diagnostics. I've picked up vehicles very, very cheap because they 'didn't run' only to find that there was a dead battery or shot fuel pump.

I don't think the '95 will plug 'n play with the '93. As you pointed out OBDI vs OBDII, and I believe the ECU is different across those years. For sure you have different intake and different emissions.

If you're bent on an engine swap you'll probably need to strip it down as AlaskanLX450 states above. Once you get it down to the block its likely interchangeable.
 
the obd 2 engine has a crank sensor. i think you can use it in your obd 1 truck but you cant use the obd1 engine in the newer trucks. i think i am correct on this but not 100% sure. its an expensive lesson to learn. i would hunt down a 93-94 engine personally.
 
I wouldn't assume it needs a new engine. These engines are extremely sturdy, my '93 has 300k+ on it and is going very strong. If you can get your hands on the cruiser cheap, snatch it up and then jump into the diagnostics. I've picked up vehicles very, very cheap because they 'didn't run' only to find that there was a dead battery or shot fuel pump.

I don't think the '95 will plug 'n play with the '93. As you pointed out OBDI vs OBDII, and I believe the ECU is different across those years. For sure you have different intake and different emissions.

If you're bent on an engine swap you'll probably need to strip it down as AlaskanLX450 states above. Once you get it down to the block its likely interchangeable.

Right. Like I said, I still haven't even heard what they think is wrong with it. The kid doesn't really know and I haven't talked to his father yet. I do know that it's been giving them some issue for a while. The kid is a college student so when I see it parked in the driveway of his parents' house I know it's having issues because he doesn't live there right now. Whenever I see it, after wiping the tears out of my eyes, I usually text him and see "how it's running". Again, he usually doesn't know exactly what happened or what was fixed, but I've pasted together a history more or less of: It overheated, we fixed some things, ran great for a bit, overheats again, new radiator, "some valves and things" as he put it, which I assume means a top end rebuild?, but apparently it's still giving them some issues.

Last time I texted him and reminded him that he wasn't ever allowed to sell it without letting me know first, and that's when he said he and his parents have been throwing around the idea of maybe selling it and getting something else. He told me his father would call me "when things slowed down with work".

I wouldn't jump right to the new engine, but I just wanted to see if this was an option if it came down to it since swapping would be cheaper than a complete rebuild if those were my two options. The engine is pretty much already a totally stripped long block. See pics.

engine1.webp


engine2.webp
 
the obd 2 engine has a crank sensor. i think you can use it in your obd 1 truck but you cant use the obd1 engine in the newer trucks. i think i am correct on this but not 100% sure. its an expensive lesson to learn. i would hunt down a 93-94 engine personally.

Good to know. I will confirm before I purchase the engine. Thanks.
 
Actually looks like some 95's were OBD1? I'll have to talk to the seller more about this.
 
It will work but you will need to do a couple of things

1- strip it down to the basics as stated. you MUST use the MAF/VAF from the 93-94
2- swap out the upper oil pan, there is an oil sensor in the 95+ pan, it's 89491-60010
3- either delete or reinstall the pair valve

Thats all I can think of now, may be 1-2 more items but they are small. Should be plug n play after that. And don't forget to do the PHH!
 
Two of the most common problems with the 1FZ-FE are head gaskets failing and problems with the wiring harness where it passes next to the EGR. It would be cheaper to fix those problems with the existing engine than doing the transplant. When you do the transplant you would have to address the same wiring harness issue and run the risk of damaging other parts of the harness and broken connectors. A new wiring harness is no longer available from the dealer so factor that in. Unless the new engine already has a new head gasket it would only make sense to replace it while the engine is out as PM. Then there all the other repairs and while you're in there items.​
 
Actually looks like some 95's were OBD1? I'll have to talk to the seller more about this.

Most 95s are OBD II, but it was not federally required until 96. So in most smog states it is tested as an OBD I, which is a more invasive test.
 
2- swap out the upper oil pan, there is an oil sensor in the 95+ pan, it's 89491-60010

Would it hurt to just leave the later upper pan and sensor in place even if it's not used?
 
Would it hurt to just leave the later upper pan and sensor in place even if it's not used?

Good question. I've never done it so I cannot speak for experience. I do know that people normally swap out the pans though. My concern would be that you might get a CEL that cannot be clear because of it
 
The 95 can go into the 93. You run your intakes and manifolds from 93. No need to swap pan just plug the hole with the sensor. You could run the 95 manifolds but you would have to delete the pair system. I would delete it either way. You'll need your vaf and air cleaner. Your 93 may or may not have the egr temp sensor , if I were you and you don't have emissions delete the pair system and egr pull the pipe from the head and block it off. But like said above stop down to bare motor run your accessories and intakes and air box
 
Good question. I've never done it so I cannot speak for experience. I do know that people normally swap out the pans though. My concern would be that you might get a CEL that cannot be clear because of it

I don't think there would be a code because the 93 ECM wouldn't be missing any sensors.
 
Wanted to give everyone an update on this. Guy said he'd sell me back the cruiser for 4 grand. Which I think is a great deal. Interior is just how I left it (excellent). Exterior the hood and roof are pretty much shot. Would definitely need to plasti dip or monstaline or paint those. He also got in a fender bender and the bottom front driver side of the arb is dented and bent. It also smashed in to the fender a bit and the turn signal is broken. Not a huge deal and probably not something I would worry about fixing immediately, but would in the future.

Now, on to the engine updates:
He has put almost 8 grand in to the rig since he bought it three years ago. 1200 of that was in new 315 bfg's he just put on. Various repairs like new cat converters and other emissions components, plugs cap and distributor, those kinds of things.

The bulk of the money, however, has come from overheating issues. The cruiser started overheating so he put in a new radiator and new hoses and clamps etc. (though I don't think that includes the pesky heater hose).

Later he was told the head gasket needed to be replaced but the mechanic told him to just use some blue devil first and see if that fixed it, which it did for a year or two.

Later there was a leak in the oil cooler plate. He got that fixed and on the way home his new radiator blew at a seam on the top.

He took it back, replaced it with a better radiator, and the mechanic told him there was too much pressure in the cooling system because he thinks the head gasket is now toast.

Does that sound like an appropriate diagnosis to you folks who are much smarter about this than I am?

I figures if we replace the head gasket we should probably rebuild the top end while we're at it. The cruiser has 246k miles on it, so I figure it's due.

The way I see it there's a best case scenario, a worst case scenario, and a lot of in between.

Best case: Head comes off, everything looks squeaky clean and we throw a new gasket on there and the cruiser is AOK for a buzillion miles after that.
Worst case: I take it in to get the head gasket done and while they're in there they see that the engine is totally shot, needs a bottom end rebuild as well as as the top end. In that scenario, I think I'd buy this 95' engine that has been discussed and drop that in instead of a rebuild.

This is where I need your help! First and foremost, does anyone know of any good cruiser mechanics in southern california? I'm in Orange County.

Secondly, what do you guys recommend I do? What is the most cost effective and practical solution? If I can talk the guy with the engine down to like 6 or 7 hundred bucks would it be cheaper to do that and have it installed than it would be to do the head gasket? Then I would have a low mileage engine with a new head gasket.

What's the going rate for a new headgasket+labor these days? What about a top end rebuild assuming I'm not doing any work myself?

OK I know that's a lot of questions but any advice you guys can give would be really appreciated!
 
Back
Top Bottom