Collectors Insurance

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 11, 2006
Threads
37
Messages
907
Location
Atlanta
Researching "Agreed value" insurance after it came up in a recent post and my search brought me to a thread in the lone star chapter. I had no idea there was such a thing. It seems that most of them are like American Collectors want vehicles 25 years or older, or that have a special niche. They have limited miles allowances of 2500, 5000 or 7500 miles per year with a garage stored vehicle.

I was curious if there is anyone with an FZJ80 1996 or 97 who has some kind of "Agreed" insurance and who you went through. These vehicles aren't 25 years old *YET* and I get anxious driving it because of all the distracted drivers. Mine is primarily a stock cruiser but I have a lot of money in maintenance and *restoration* that I would hate to see ignored by my current insurance. *God forbid anything happens, knock on wood and all that*
 
Last edited:
Interested as well given the total loss value of my 80 is probably 1/4 of what I've spent on maintenance and upgrades.

I've looked into finding someone other than USAA, but found pretty much the same restrictions as you. Regardless, the whole game is rigged. I pay just as much for my 80 as I do on my wife's Yukon XL that has wholesale value 6x that of my rig! How do you start an insurance company?
 
I don't have collectors insurance on my '96, but I do have agreed value through Nationwide. It added ~$100 per year or so to the std. quote
 
I wouldn't want limits on miles and garage parking is impossible. So I'm thinking the least amount of insurance on my vehicle as possible (still need adequate coverage for the other vehicle/people), high deductible and a disciplined monthly contribution to my own "rainy day" fund. At least that way I'd have the money in my control rather than the insurance company.
 
I wouldn't want limits on miles and garage parking is impossible. So I'm thinking the least amount of insurance on my vehicle as possible (still need adequate coverage for the other vehicle/people), high deductible and a disciplined monthly contribution to my own "rainy day" fund. At least that way I'd have the money in my control rather than the insurance company.

I get that. For me I drive this as a weekend vehicle or it fills in if another car is down. So it is garaged and my daily driver is out in the rain (sorry camry). So if the price wasn't crazy and all that it might fit my lifestyle.
 
Here in oz a vehicle 30 yrs or older can be considered for special insurance and registration due to it's age. Is it really worth it for 4wd's that are by design intended for rough use?

Oldest 80's are 1990 vintage so still at least 2 more years to wait before they start to qualify.

Even now most insurance companies ask you how far you intend to drive in a policy year and adjust premiums based on that (and other questions about usage).
 
I'vr got mine on limited use with Shannons and get a discount even though its on full reg. I have my daily drive insured with them as well.

Here in oz a vehicle 30 yrs or older can be considered for special insurance and registration due to it's age. Is it really worth it for 4wd's that are by design intended for rough use?

Oldest 80's are 1990 vintage so still at least 2 more years to wait before they start to qualify.

Even now most insurance companies ask you how far you intend to drive in a policy year and adjust premiums based on that (and other questions about usage).
 
Here's another insurance company you should contact, they do alot of stated value policy's on collector cars. But i can tell you that they will place yearly mileage limits on your use, and they too will want you to keep your truck inside when not being driven.
Hagerty Classic Car Insurance | For People Who Love Cars
 
I have american collectors on my 97 with $21k value
i pay $450 year

I wish I could score this deal.

When I filled out the brief version of the application it was $326 a year. When I was done filing out the long form it jumped to $790.

I pay $400 a year with progressive. I guess I'll fight with them if I wreck it.
 
Insurance coverage options vary by state, by company, and by agent. I have stated/agreed up on value thru Farmers here in AZ.

I have heard that Haggertys wants you to park inside and NOT wheel offroad.
 
I have heard that Haggertys wants you to park inside and NOT wheel offroad.[/QUOTE]

Actually according to my agent that is true with most policies. But since I do most of my off-roading on designated Forest Roads I am covered. In the event I roll it on an unmarked road, I would ask Inkpot to drag me over to a marked road where I could claim the loss:smokin:
 
I use Safeco for my house and my cars. I have a $20K agreed value policy on the LC. I also have basic insurance on my Tacoma but they are a combined $120 per month.

No limits on miles but I do store the truck in a garage and I don't wheel it hard. My more likely issue would be an animal strike or a lost handle in a snow storm.
 
I just joined this forum, initially specifically because I am looking for some advice in this thread. I have a '78 FJ40 that is all original, and in almost immaculate condition. I've owned it for over 30 years. I knew the value of these FJs have gone up, and started thinking my standard coverage was probably inadequate. So, at the suggestion of my underwriter, I got an official appraisal. It is crazy high!! I had no idea the value was anywhere near the appraisal I was given. So, I started looking into collectible insurance to better cover my FJ, and as many have posted here already... there are severe limitations. Every single policy I've checked into so far (and that includes Heacock, Hagerty's, Grundy's and a couple of others) ALL will deny coverage for any driving that is not strictly pleasure like getting an ice cream or going to a car show (NO errands of any kind, no driving to work etc) and NO dirt roads. Needless to say, off-roading of any kind is not covered. Has anyone found a reputable policy which might have some mileage limitation (I don't drive this more than 1500 miles a year or so) but does not discriminate against running the occasional errand or driving on a dirt road? It's ridiculous how many restrictions are placed on collectible coverage. But I'm afraid of what a standard policy might cost with this kind of stated value. Suggestions?
 
I use State Farm and have agreed upon value on a Studebaker and on a 70 GMC K2500. There are NO restrictions. However, I must stay on top of values as they change in the marketplace.

If I wreck the truck, I will only get up to the maximum value of my agreed upon price. If it's much lower than my cost to repair or replace it, then it's my problem, not theirs. I pay in accordance to the value of the policy.

My 96 LC is currently insured normally and I had him advise current value as a "stock" truck and it landed about $12,500 for my area. I asked about add-ons for winch, sliders, bumpers, etc. and he advised that as long as I have receipts, then those get added on.

I also learned something else recently: A friend had his 1986 Chevy C10 stolen and the removed the engine and trans and tore up the interior. They totaled the truck. He bought it back. Even though HE owned it, it is required in the state of Kansas, that the title MUST be changed to a SALVAGE title even if the official ownership never transferred to the insurance company. They submitted it to the State, and he got a letter from the state that forced him to surrender his current title to the state and then reapply for a salvage title.

This really pisses me off, but once the insurance company releases it, it's a salvage truck in the state of KS. Check your own state's laws.
 
Interesting... I'm on the phone now (on hold of course) with Safeco, who seems to offer a similar policy. We'll see what the rate comes in at comparatively. But they seem to have no restrictions, other than the mileage limit which you can set at whatever you want. I'm also checking with my daily driver underwriter to see if they have a stated amount policy. It does seem like this is the only way to have some freedom from the ridiculous limitations that collector policies have on them.
 
So very surprisingly, Safeco came in with a very attractive rate compared to Hagerty, Grundy, and Heacock with NO restrictions on driving other than an established maximum miles per year (which was fine) AND no restrictions on designated forest service roads. They did not cover off-roading, but I didn't expect they would. I'm still waiting on a couple more quotes, but so far this seems like a very attractive option! Anyone else used Safeco before?
 
If you are using your LC as a primary vehicle (i.e. two drivers in the household and two vehicles are owned) and you are not parking it in a garage, you are probably better off with a traditional policy. I'd still work with the agent to account for add on parts and attempt to get the value up to real market if you feel yours should be substantially above book.

I have a 1965 Mustang with agreed upon value coverage through Haggerty. It is not a primary driver, but I am covered for occasionally driving it to work or on errands in addition to pleasure drives and to shows, etc.). I recommend calling them and being very honest with how you will use the vehicle and I would bet most agents will be able to come up with a reasonable quote. The Mustang insurance is dirt cheap, since they know I will only drive it about 2000 miles per year. They did want a picture of the vehicle, but were very nice to work with and didn't have any problem when I told them I'd need to park it out doors for a summer.
 
So very surprisingly, Safeco came in with a very attractive rate compared to Hagerty, Grundy, and Heacock with NO restrictions on driving other than an established maximum miles per year (which was fine) AND no restrictions on designated forest service roads. They did not cover off-roading, but I didn't expect they would. I'm still waiting on a couple more quotes, but so far this seems like a very attractive option! Anyone else used Safeco before?
That is who I use. No complaints thus far.
 
Those of you with agreed value policies, do you have full coverage or just liability/comprehensive/uninsured motorist?

I'm personally not too worried about wrecking my 80 myself but more by someone else hitting me. Specifically an uninsured or under insured and have to deal with a wholesale payout.

Once I finish my engine rebuild and turbo I'll be shopping for more than my current standard coverage policy. I can accept responsibility if I roll it on the trail. But for an accident on pavement I'd want full coverage for its replacement cost or agreed number.
 
Back
Top Bottom