I'd like to thank both of you for your opinions and the information you've generously shared. They've given me much to think on. I'd also like to apologise to Mark Davis for hijacking his thread and shall try to be better behaved in the future.
Kalawang
I see that you are trying to back out of this discussion gracefully, without getting angry at me or anyone else. I appreciate that. I'm sorry that I can't seem to do the same and keep trying to force you to see things my way. It's a fault I have, and I apologize for it. I have to try again before you go out and spend a bunch of money.
I've given you all the information I have on the CDL. I can't get you to understand the function of the light, and that the fact is that your CDL is locked no matter what you feel. Let's try with the axle lockers.
The factory e-locker works virtually the same way the ARB does. It is fully selectable- open or locked, no in between. When it engages, it locks the two axle shafts together as one. There is no slippage possible. The only way one wheel is going to slip is if you break an axle shaft or something equally devastating. The only differences are that the e-locker uses an electric motor to move the locking fork, while the ARB uses air pressure to move the same fork. The ARB has a higher spline count on the locking mechanism, allowing it to engage with less difference in wheel speed. Make no mistake, that doesn't mean the e-locker 'slips', it will lock the instant one wheel moves less than 1/5th of one revolution more than the other wheel. On the rear axle the ARB also locks the two axles together in a different place on the carrier than the e-locker does, but the net effect is exactly the same.
The ARB has advantages and disadvantages compared to factory e-lockers but selectability, pinion count and full lockability are not among them.
I would highly suggest you do some research with an open mind. I don't know if the FSM has diagrams of the inner workings of the locker mechanisms, that might be a good place to start if it does. Seeing the inside of the mechanism and axle would be ideal. Maybe someone local to you is planning some teardown. Or, perhaps someone who's knowledge you trust can explain better than I. All I can say is I've seen the inside of these things with my own eyes, taken them apart and put them back together.
I will agree not to hassle you if you promise not to say anything alluding to the CDL not being locked when the light comes on, or suggesting that the lockers are not fully selectable. You are welcome to believe whatever you want, but with all due respect, you're wrong.

As far as hijacking the thread, I believe we're still discussing the CDL and associated systems, and so far it's a civil discussion.
-Spike