Catch can?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

White Sheep

Darren
SILVER Star
Joined
Dec 3, 2019
Threads
94
Messages
2,431
Location
Okinawa, Japan
Question for the community??

I recently bought two PCV hoses because I wanted to give a catch can a try. One hose for if I like it, and the other if I want/need to go back to OEM. My super charged Scat Pack Shaker Challenger (name drop :flipoff2:) has a catch can installed, and seen them on a few LC applications.

There is the JEGS 52205 that most LC's have for about $60, or you can go to Home Depot and get a Husky brand for $25. I took the $25 approach to see if I like it or not.

Installed about a week ago and looking at it today. . .it caught oil. But the question is, is the juice worth the squeeze? Am I actually getting good results or would have most of that oil went back into the PCV valve anyway? What are your all thoughts?
 
Question for the community??

I recently bought two PCV hoses because I wanted to give a catch can a try. One hose for if I like it, and the other if I want/need to go back to OEM. My super charged Scat Pack Shaker Challenger (name drop :flipoff2:) has a catch can installed, and seen them on a few LC applications.

There is the JEGS 52205 that most LC's have for about $60, or you can go to Home Depot and get a Husky brand for $25. I took the $25 approach to see if I like it or not.

Installed about a week ago and looking at it today. . .it caught oil. But the question is, is the juice worth the squeeze? Am I actually getting good results or would have most of that oil went back into the PCV valve anyway? What are your all thoughts?

The oil would not have gone "back into the PCV valve", it is headed for the throttle body. The idea is to keep the oil out of the throtle body to keep it "clean".

However, there are a few folks that are still in need of better valve cover seals, spark plug tube seal, and an oil cap seal and it allows the free air to pick up additional oil and deposit into the catch can.

It can indicate some health of the engine, but it can also be a PITA as it gets full or it causing a restriction in the line and reducing the vacuum on the engine.

Personally, I think it's a novelty item to get sales and no one really knows if it helps or not. But, if it makes you feel better that it's there, then, enjoy it and enjoy dumping it regularly.
 
Catch cans are for forced induction only
 
Catch cans are used on many NA high perf. cars...... althought Forced Ind. are more typical. I have one on my C63 track car...... likely will do a modified version for the LC when we do the HG next month...
 
Question for the community??

I recently bought two PCV hoses because I wanted to give a catch can a try. One hose for if I like it, and the other if I want/need to go back to OEM. My super charged Scat Pack Shaker Challenger (name drop :flipoff2:) has a catch can installed, and seen them on a few LC applications.

There is the JEGS 52205 that most LC's have for about $60, or you can go to Home Depot and get a Husky brand for $25. I took the $25 approach to see if I like it or not.

Installed about a week ago and looking at it today. . .it caught oil. But the question is, is the juice worth the squeeze? Am I actually getting good results or would have most of that oil went back into the PCV valve anyway? What are your all thoughts?

I have a similar catch can from Jegs that I just put on 2 weeks ago, 5226 all aluminium. I stayed away from the plastic because of the heat. My motor is newly rebuilt at 5K miles. There is a small amount of oil in that catch can, and my motor is working about as good as you can get. That is oil that didn't make it into the intake to get gunked up.
 
Last edited:
I have the cheap version, probably more like $10. It grabs oil, probably an ounce every thousand miles ish. I am happy that it isn’t going into my throttle body.
For what it is worth, nobody at Home Depot encouraged me to install this on my 80, novelty myth to make money is busted:rolleyes::flipoff2:
 
Last edited:
I can see running one if you force the manifold, or to see the overall health of a new motor or ‘new to you’ motor - but letting a little oil in otherwise is negligible if you just pop the throttlebody off for a cleaning about every 2nd POTUS election.

But if you want to get down to the last inch of what all is going in in your motor, it’s your choice.
 
Catch cans are for forced induction only

Absolutely not.

Many a N/A diesel benefits from one. I installed one last year on a 1PZ, engine absolutely loved it.

Cheers
 
I have a similar catch can from Jegs that I just put on 2 weeks ago, 5226 all aluminium. I stayed away from the plastic because of the heat. My motor is newly rebuilt at 5K miles. There is a small amount of oil in that catch can, and my motor is working about as good as you can get. That is oil that didn't make it into the throttle body to get gunked up.

Hey Gil do you have a picture of your setup?
 
Hey Gil do you have a picture of your setup?
Here you go

20191222_165742.webp


pic.webp
 
The Jegs one is junk. I had it mounted and the bottom where the drain fitting cracked. I didn’t over tighten it either since it has a O-ring. It did work good for a year or too. I Recommend taking it off to drain it. Don’t use the drain fitting.
 
The Jegs one is junk. I had it mounted and the bottom where the drain fitting cracked. I didn’t over tighten it either since it has a O-ring. It did work good for a year or too. I Recommend taking it off to drain it. Don’t use the drain fitting.

That is exactly the reason why I was told not to get the plastic catch can
 
Hey Gil do you have a picture of your setup?

Do not attach the filter that screws under the lid. Let the air free flow. I filled the catch can with steel wool. Probably should use copper brillo pad like LC Phil.
C04A7B68-D259-4AB3-8444-19589C27BFC2.jpeg
 
Last edited:
What’s the Jegs part number? I looked up the 5226 and came up with a painless wire harness .
Here is the official website.


 
Do not attach the filter that screws under the lid. Let the air free flow. I filled the catch can with steel wool. Probably should use copper brillo pad like LC Phil.

2x on removing the filter. I didn't and after some years it became clogged; you'd never know unless you tried to blow through it.

I run the cheap plastic one too. Closed the bottom drain with solder; good for more than 10 years.
 
Lowes, HD; HF are other options.
 
Do not attach the filter that screws under the lid. Let the air free flow. I filled the catch can with steel wool. Probably should use copper brillo pad like LC Phil.
View attachment 2167773

Yes the filters most are using are for air and the filter are too fine and let too much oil by. This is why I remove the fine filter and use copper brillo and fill the filter.
I get 10 cc of oil every 1000 miles on a strong running motor.

1577642328152.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom