There is more than a carb and dissy, it is a whole vulnerable system which includes the computer, vacuum switching valve, speed sensor, water temperature sensor, and EGR to be at precise stock spec. And, then you might want to get an answer about how the two distributors centrifugal advance compare to make a truly informed decision. A stock vacuum retard system would be great if you make it work in only those conditions when you were closer to the conditions causing engine knock, like running low octane gas on a hot motor.
I imagine that there is a difference between the action of different ported vacuum sources, including non-Cruiser carbs, like when and how much do they pull.
Look in the bore of the later carb from bottom, and work the throttle plate, it will give you a sense of when each port barb gets vacuum based on the position of the throttle plate, and how much, it probably would need to be measured.
Basically, the consensus is to run just centrifugal advance and keep it simple, unless you have a vacuum advance distributor.