Bad spindles?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 5, 2016
Threads
55
Messages
482
Location
Bay Area, CA
Hey all,

In the process of regearing and my spindles have some wear marks on them.

This is strange because I just put them in brand new when I redid axles less than 1,000 street and freeway miles only.

Separately from that, there is some rust on the edges and some splatter on the face. I foolishly drove through the edge of the water in Pismo, so lesson learned there.

Three questions:

1 why are there wear marks on the spindles so soon after they have been installed with brand new bearings, new grease, etc?

2 are they salvageable/usable? I am doing another axle job so now would be the time to replace them

3 if usable, what is the best way to remove rust from edges and face?

975DC051-469B-4160-A863-8FA702090785.webp
F01A4C92-0BE7-4CF0-ABA2-BB0AA669B8F3.webp
AEE85BED-696D-4DBC-B4A3-18C2B6C6F581.webp
D3AA554C-9D03-4DA7-9AE9-D9EE4D30453F.webp




Thanks in advance.
 
Last edited:
It’s not dirt, actual wear marks. Looked a lot like the ones that were on the spindles I replaced, but are smaller.

The bearing should have been fine during this time - we installed everything new, and followed the book on preload setting. The nuts were on there at the expected tightness when I removed them. So a bit stumped as to why this could have happened.
 
It’s not dirt, actual wear marks. Looked a lot like the ones that were on the spindles I replaced, but are smaller.

The bearing should have been fine during this time - we installed everything new, and followed the book on preload setting. The nuts were on there at the expected tightness when I removed them. So a bit stumped as to why this could have happened.
Because if you follow the FSM for the bearing settings in the USA, they are too low.

Should be 30 LB-FT and the lock nut at 45 LB-FT. The manual states 35 LB-IN and they will work loose in under 1000 miles.

To me, those look like corrosion marks from moisture inside the bearing area, with the inner race starting to corrode to the spindle. That is not "wear" like the inner race is spinning.

When the bearings are packed, did you also pack the cavity BETWEEN the bearings in the hub to at least 1/2 full? Needs to have that or the grease will migrate from the bearing to the open area during extended operation to to the drop point temp of the lubricant.

The rust on the flange faces is gonna happen. You can coat them with a VERY light coat of grease if you choose to on installation. It won't really hurt anything as long as it's NOT between the bolted surfaces.
 
Because if you follow the FSM for the bearing settings in the USA, they are too low.

Should be 30 LB-FT and the lock nut at 45 LB-FT. The manual states 35 LB-IN and they will work loose in under 1000 miles. To me, those look like corrosion marks from moisture inside the bearing area, with the inner race starting to corrode to the spindle. That is not "wear" like the inner race is spinning.

Thanks I will tighten it to this spec next time. So you think these are still usable?


When the bearings are packed, did you also pack the cavity BETWEEN the bearings in the hub to at least 1/2 full? Needs to have that or the grease will migrate from the bearing to the open area during extended operation to to the drop point temp of the lubricant.

Don't remember to be honest, but when I took everything apart there was plenty of grease on all the surfaces... bearings etc were still fully packed with grease - still fresh and red from the recent reinstall. But will make sure I fill this area when I reinstall. thanks for the tip.

The rust on the flange faces is gonna happen. You can coat them with a VERY light coat of grease if you choose to on installation. It won't really hurt anything as long as it's NOT between the bolted surfaces.

Should I try to sand it off? What about the outside facing edges of the base of the spindle, the one that mates to the outside shell of the knuckle? Should I sand and paint it?
 
Like Bilt4ME said, you cannot follow the FSM for preload and torque. That’s one thing I don’t follow in the FSM. I think ToolRUs has a good write up,

Just reinstall everything and preload it correctly. Doesn’t look bad enough the the bearing will fit loose and spin.
 
Thanks I will tighten it to this spec next time. So you think these are still usable?




Don't remember to be honest, but when I took everything apart there was plenty of grease on all the surfaces... bearings etc were still fully packed with grease - still fresh and red from the recent reinstall. But will make sure I fill this area when I reinstall. thanks for the tip.



Should I try to sand it off? What about the outside facing edges of the base of the spindle, the one that mates to the outside shell of the knuckle? Should I sand and paint it?
The spindles are absolutely usable. There are no ridges or any cuts there that I can see.

You could use a Scotch-Brite pad to clean off any rust or discolored area, then clean it up again and re-lube the areas. Scotch-Brite won't remove metal like emery cloth or sanding/grinding will.

If there are no ridges you can hang a fingernail on, then you're in good shape. I don;t see any grooving on the seal surface areas either, and there shouldn't be on a new spindle in 1000 miles.

Do a search for @Tools R Us thread on his specific bearing tightening. You may find one about he and I discussing the differences. His method is tried and true.

I switched over to the Trail Gear nuts that are thicker, but only a single nut. They have their own challenges, but I torque them to 35 LB-FT before locking them in. Set the torque while rotating the hub, with all the freshly packed wheel bearings and hub 1/2 full of grease. Don't forget to grease the surface of the seals and where the seals slide so they don't drag and cut when you slide the hub on..

My truck is a DD of about 20K/yr so mine works well for that, 33" tires, minimal off-road. If you have large tires and beat it hard, it may require a little more. Kevin talked about as much as 45 LB-Ft on the bearings for those applications.
 
Right on, thanks.

Do you think it's ok to sand the rust off the faces of the spindles? Or is there a less abrasive way to get it off?
 
Also, is there a way or a need to grease the bearing inside the spindle?
Use the Scotch-Brite pads to remove the rust bloom. Shouldn't be a big deal. They don't remove metal. Then wipe with light oil or grease.

Is there an actual BEARING inside of that spindle? If so, then, yes.

I am assuming you have washed it, based on how clean all of that is. If that's the case, you need to squish grease into that bearing. I would use the two-finger method. Scoop out a gob on two fingers, insert into the hole, the smash it into the rollers, and do this over and over all the way around it. After you have done it once around, try to roller the rollers with your fingers to work the grease in a little more, then do it all again. It's kinda messy, but it will insure you don't end up with dry spindle bushing squeals. Having too much in there is better than not enough. I would use the same Moly fortified grease used in the birfields. (I use Valvoline Palladium) I also use Lucas Red-N-Tacky 2 for the wheel bearings for what that's worth. Both greases are compatible with each other in case they mix, and they will over time through the spindle housing.

Even if it's just the bronze bushing, you definitely need to grease it well, but it won't take as much because there is not the volume for it to go into (not that it's a huge difference)

Make sure to grease the shaft of the birfield where that bearing will ride as well.
 
When you get it all back together keep a eye on it. The easiest way to do that is grab the wheel at 12 o clock with both hands and pull towards you if you can fill movement the wheel bearing are to lose. ;)
 
on the outside edge, use a grinder with a flap wheel to make it clean. I use a brush and some 2 part epoxy paint to give them a couple coats of paint. dont worry about being messy. After it is dry, use a scotch brite pad on a die grinder to clean off the face - red is fine and that will also kick off the paint you got on the face. When you assemble it, put a light layer of some of the knuckle heavy grease over the area and it will keep it rust free.
 
Bringing this thread back with another n00b question.

I am further along tearing apart the hubs to replace the wheel studs/flange studs, and am finding more rust on the hubs and the knuckles. Likely the result of my frolicking on the beach earlier.

My goal is to remove as much of this surface rust as possible, and stay the hell away from salt water from here on. The truck is garaged the rest of the time.

I have been reading a lot of threads on here, and have two options:

1) use a rust removal product like like EVAPO-RUST from harbor freight, or something similar, that strips the rust off metal and gets it back to bare metal.

2) use a wire wheel/brush to scrape off the rust

3) get the parts sandblasted at my local shop to get it back to bare metal.

The question is this - once the metal on the hub and the edges of knuckles etc are stripped down back to bare metal, does it have to be covered/reconditioned with something to make sure it doesn't rust again? Or do I just leave it as bare metal (and avoid salt water) in the future? Or is the expectation that these parts will rust again no matter what?

Here is a picture of the rust spots on the hub and the back of the knuckle that I am trying to get rid of. Cleaned off a piece of the edge on the knuckle for a side-by-side before and after rust reference.

IMG_0408.webp


IMG_9391.webp


IMG_0145.webp
 
Why don’t you just get it all sand blasted, tape off and paint?

Cheers

Planning to get the hubs sandblasted. I already repainted the outside of the knuckles and those seem to be in good shape.

The question I have is for surfaces like the inside edge of the knuckle, that aren't supposed to be painted/coated with anything. Supposed to be bare metal. Same goes for other mated surfaces on the hub, like where the bolts that attach the rotor sit. Can't imagine it's a good idea to have paint in there.

Is there some other kind of a treatment for these exposed metal surfaces to prevent them from rusting? Or is that just expected over time?
 
Somewhat off topic question.

What is all that red bearing grease doing inside the knuckle?

My kunckles had some rust buildup similar to that when I did my axle job. Got it all off with a scotchbrite pad. It definitely took some time.....
 
Personally I wouldn't sandblast them, most of that is surface rust, you could apply a rust converter and put it all back together. Having said that, 10 years ago I bead blasted my knuckles and then had them powdercoated, along with the drive flanges. Problem with powdercoat is everytime you work on those parts you risk dinging them and the rust then gets underneath the powdercoat, so I won't do that again.

However if you do get the hubs blasted (better not to use aggressive
media), follow that with a rust converter which will get into the small pits, then if you want to get fancy, use an epoxy paint (catalyzed if you can find it (Eastwoods) not rattle can). Just block/tape off critical mating surfaces/holes.

 
Back
Top Bottom