Another S/C question!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Ken,
Well, I agree and disagree with you at the same time. I read that thread awhile ago and understand what you are saying. I know that a snorkel helps keep the heat down, working somewhat as a cold air intake, as you are pulling ambient air from the outside (rather than from the hot engine compartment area). However, when you feel your intake on a hot day, it's hot (no empirical evidence/numbers to back this up), and therefore, it has to affect performance. If this weren't true, intercoolers wouldn't exist.

Now I know you tow your Jayco popup with S/C. Have you towed that on a hot day over Eisenhower/Vail? If so, how was your performance (speed, temp, etc. I think I remember you saying that you had to turn off the A/C?)

Bottom line, I want an intercooler. They're, well, cool... especially on a motor that runs really hot.

P.S. (Minor thread hijack) Have you seen these hitches:
Lock N' Roll Trailer Hitches
Definitely going to go this route when I buy an off road pop-up (leaning towards the Starcraft 10RT) this spring.


Never said an intercooler wouldn't be better, just disagree that the SC loses most of its effective advantage on a hot day. I have a SC and I know that to be a false statement.

It will make the cooling system run hoter due to more stuff in the way for airflow. The temp increase in my cooling system is unrelated to SC performance and the air fuel mixture process. Two seperate systems.

I have an aux fan now and don't need to sut off the AC going up the mtn passes on a hot day any more.
 
Never said an intercooler wouldn't be better, just disagree that the SC loses most of its effective advantage on a hot day. I have a SC and I know that to be a false statement.

It will make the cooling system run hoter due to more stuff in the way for airflow. The temp increase in my cooling system is unrelated to SC performance and the air fuel mixture process. Two seperate systems.

I have an aux fan now and don't need to sut off the AC going up the mtn passes on a hot day any more.

OK, I'm not trying to argue, but I am curious what the difference would be. I guess unless we were to dyno test a S/C'd 80 with both hot air and cold air going into the intake to see the difference in performance, we can't know what the actual output is. Last time I looked in my garage there wasn't a dyno machine laying around.;)

Having read Blarsen's thread about intercoolers, and his performance gains, it's hard to imagine that we aren't losing significant performace due to temperature. Have you done anything further with your hood scoop project?

Regardless, I think I will be in touch with Cdan shortly (or whenever we have less than 5 feet of snow on the ground) regarding the JDM fan. Thanks for the info!:cheers:
 
It will make the cooling system run hoter due to more stuff in the way for airflow. The temp increase in my cooling system is unrelated to SC performance and the air fuel mixture process. Two seperate systems.

Ken, not sure that is totally true. Just the nature of compressing air with a screw type compressor will also heat up the air. You can feel the outlet on our compressor at work. It is also a screw type compressor just like the Eaton unit and it heats up the air for sure.

Warmer air into the motor also makes it run hotter. Yes, you have increased the capacity of the cooling system to remove more heat by adding the fan, but they are not unrelated.

It is not just the airflow that is an issue.
 
Ken, not sure that is totally true. Just the nature of compressing air with a screw type compressor will also heat up the air. You can feel the outlet on our compressor at work. It is also a screw type compressor just like the Eaton unit and it heats up the air for sure.

Warmer air into the motor also makes it run hotter. Yes, you have increased the capacity of the cooling system to remove more heat by adding the fan, but they are not unrelated.

It is not just the airflow that is an issue.


I wasn't meaning to say something different. He said my diminished SC performance was shown by my stateing in another thread how I was overheating and had to shut the AC off. He also said in Hot weather you loose most of the effective advantage of having the SC.
 
OK, I'm not trying to argue, but I am curious what the difference would be. I guess unless we were to dyno test a S/C'd 80 with both hot air and cold air going into the intake to see the difference in performance, we can't know what the actual output is. Last time I looked in my garage there wasn't a dyno machine laying around.;)

Having read Blarsen's thread about intercoolers, and his performance gains, it's hard to imagine that we aren't losing significant performace due to temperature. Have you done anything further with your hood scoop project?

Regardless, I think I will be in touch with Cdan shortly (or whenever we have less than 5 feet of snow on the ground) regarding the JDM fan. Thanks for the info!:cheers:

I have decided against the hood scoop for now. If I face it forward, I would get crap in it from offroading. It probably would be more effective backwards, just don't like the look of that.

I haven't dynod it.

In 2006 I was pulling my Jayco Popup up Eisenhower tunnel and at some points in the road, I could only do 35-40. Coming back up Vail pass, one point went as low as 30.

In 2007 with the supercharger, pulling the same load and actually a heavier truck with rear drawers full of spares, engle, subtank, dual batts and the SC I was able to maintain 60 up Eisenhower and 55 up Vail pass.

Also, in the high 95+ heat I still get a kick on the onramps to the highway. The Boost gauge still shows 7 psi of Boost and it is much much faster than without the SC. My daughteer calls me to remind me she doesn't have a SC and I need to slow down when she is following me.

Whats the actual horsepower delta in the 95+ day? I don't know but the SC is still there and giving SIGNIFICANT impact to performance. It's not just a seat of the pants comment.
 
Originally posted by LX_TREME
What is that small white dot all over? Is that winter salt?

That white dot looks like pitting corrosion on aluminum.
 
In 2006 I was pulling my Jayco Popup up Eisenhower tunnel and at some points in the road, I could only do 35-40. Coming back up Vail pass, one point went as low as 30.

Wow that SUCKS!!! After throwing all that money down on SC you are still dipping into the low 30's on Vail pass!!??!?!? I pull a similar setup and can pretty much do 30 up any hill, just depends how long I want to press the RPM'S in first gear.
 
Wow that SUCKS!!! After throwing all that money down on SC you are still dipping into the low 30's on Vail pass!!??!?!? I pull a similar setup and can pretty much do 30 up any hill, just depends how long I want to press the RPM'S in first gear.


That was without the supercharger

The 2007 says with the SC
 
Sorry I need to learn to completly read the replys a little better. :doh:

I would say that is probably worth the investment then. It would give me more of a reason to load up the Cruiser rather than the Duramax a little more often on those long trips. I think if I don't start taking her out more she might get mad at me and blow a gasket.
 
I have decided against the hood scoop for now. If I face it forward, I would get crap in it from offroading. It probably would be more effective backwards, just don't like the look of that.

I haven't dynod it.

In 2006 I was pulling my Jayco Popup up Eisenhower tunnel and at some points in the road, I could only do 35-40. Coming back up Vail pass, one point went as low as 30.

In 2007 with the supercharger, pulling the same load and actually a heavier truck with rear drawers full of spares, engle, subtank, dual batts and the SC I was able to maintain 60 up Eisenhower and 55 up Vail pass.

Also, in the high 95+ heat I still get a kick on the onramps to the highway. The Boost gauge still shows 7 psi of Boost and it is much much faster than without the SC. My daughteer calls me to remind me she doesn't have a SC and I need to slow down when she is following me.

Whats the actual horsepower delta in the 95+ day? I don't know but the SC is still there and giving SIGNIFICANT impact to performance. It's not just a seat of the pants comment.

I understand it's not a seat of the pants thing, but we don't have anything empirical to see what we are actually losing.

Thanks for the towing info though, that gives me an idea of expectations for pulling the popup this spring/summer.:) I forgot, do you have 4.88s?

As for the boost (psi), it shouldn't be affected by temperature. The difference is you will be boosting hotter (which I think we've established is relative;)), more expanded air.

Having driven numerous 80s w/ and w/o S/Cs, I know that they are all different. One of my good buddies here has a S/C'd 80 with 4.88s running 315s (as I do). His 80 has to be lighter than my new truck (he doesn't have drawers, sliders, skidplate, auxilary tank, and swing outs). However, his 80 is not as quick as mine (probably due to exhaust and my motor being bored out or because I'm just cooler:cool:.)

That setup is not working at all. Grossly inefficient.

:confused: What kind of temperature change would you expect?
 
Thanks for the towing info though, that gives me an idea of expectations for pulling the popup this spring/summer.:) I forgot, do you have 4.88s?

2006 - 4.11 gears BFG AT Ko 33's, no SC

2007 - 4.88 Gears Toyo 315's (Real heavy), SC and added rear drawers, sub tank, fridge, dual batts.

I am not disagreeing that heat diminshes the performance of the SC, thats why I got the snorkel to lower the intake temp and increase the air flow. I know it's performance is still less on a hot day, but then wouldn't a non SC'd truck be as well? Probably not by as much though.
 
:confused: What kind of temperature change would you expect?


Efficiency=Tin - Tout/Tin-Tambient

Where Tin= post compressor temp
Tout= intercooler outlet temp

Lets say Tin is 250F and your Tout of 235F(your 15* difference) with an ambient of 80F.

If you plug in the numbers you will see that E is = to 8.8%

60% and up are what I've seen to call it efficient.

A 102*F temperature drop would be an efficiency of 60% in this example.

***Disclaimer*** This is just an example, I have no co0llected any Real-Time numbers, these are just a plausabe example.
 
2006 - 4.11 gears BFG AT Ko 33's, no SC

2007 - 4.88 Gears Toyo 315's (Real heavy), SC and added rear drawers, sub tank, fridge, dual batts.

I am not disagreeing that heat diminshes the performance of the SC, thats why I got the snorkel to lower the intake temp and increase the air flow. I know it's performance is still less on a hot day, but then wouldn't a non SC'd truck be as well? Probably not by as much though.

A non SC'd truck could be improved by cutting holes in the floorboard so that you can Fred Flintstone the damn thing up a hill...:rolleyes:

Efficiency=Tin - Tout/Tin-Tambient

Where Tin= post compressor temp
Tout= intercooler outlet temp

Lets say Tin is 250F and your Tout of 235F(your 15* difference) with an ambient of 80F.

If you plug in the numbers you will see that E is = to 8.8%

60% and up are what I've seen to call it efficient.

A 102*F temperature drop would be an efficiency of 60% in this example.

***Disclaimer*** This is just an example, I have no co0llected any Real-Time numbers, these are just a plausabe example.

Thanks, I'll do some research so I can more fully understand what kind of "effeciency" could be expected from a homebrew system.
 
Back
Top Bottom