air soft bb's

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Well, I dunno Josh. I don't think the fact that you put the BB's in your tires proves that it actually helped balance them. I mean, maybe it was just close to a net zero, and you didn't see anything bad happen. Got anything objective or even subjective, like a personal observation before/after?
Show me a bias ply swamper that doesn't need ANY weight to balance it and I will have the bb's removed from my tires just to prove it works.
 
LOOK.

I don't care how much you know about physics, or theory or whatever else...


this method works, period, end of story.

Any weight that can move around inside the tire produces the same effect, water, antifreeze, sand, BBs, golf balls etc

Obviously the smaller and more benign the substance the better. Therefore many use airsoft pellets, it is small, does not react to moisture, cheap, does not freeze.

I have run as much as a pound and a half in a tire to balance out nasty old swampers..

Go by the weights listed in the innovative tire balancing spreadsheet and you will be fine.

webwheelers :rolleyes:
 
No way Spike! Come up with an explaination by midnite or we're taking your BB's! :flipoff2:

Besides, I've already gotten VERY educated on the internet.
(never knew girls could do THAT:eek:)
 
I take it as you didn't read the info there.

It has info on how balancing medium "works by making use of centrifugal force to distribute the weight inside the tube to compensate for dynamic tire balance as it rotates".

IMHO that's a prime example of gobbledigook that doesn't mean anything...
 
e999 you are a head! you are making yourself look like a tool. How can you not understand it if you read it? Its not any more difficult than understanding how putting weights on your rims can balance your tires. Your tires are ever changing by wearing, and so is the internal balancing theory.

Mark, tech dogs drawing makes some sense. The weight will stay in the spot that is the lightest. Putting weight in the tire, far away from the hub is far more efficient than putting weight closer to the center of the hub.

It will not read as balanced if you try to put it on a balance machine.
Ive heard of a 4wheel parts guy that said it didnt work on his burban but that was 40's on 20's.=he was prolly a homo:D

Don't knock it till youve tried it. The concept could not get any more freshman.
 
e999 you are a head! you are making yourself look like a tool. How can you not understand it if you read it? Its not any more difficult than understanding how putting weights on your rims can balance your tires. Your tires are ever changing by wearing, and so is the internal balancing theory.

snip


Don't knock it till youve tried it. The concept could not get any more freshman.


excellent, please educate me and tell me what the statement above (the one I called "gobbledigook" actually means in light of the discussion above. Specifically, perhaps how the "centrifugal force" decides where to put the beads...? TIA


ah, while you're at it, please explain also to me the Innovative Balancing site explanation of how "centripetal" forces accomplish this....?
 
Instead of asking us to prove it, how about Googling the concept and perhaps you'll find some answers- either pro or con. 'Mud isn't the only place for information on the Internet. That's how I educated myself, and I was skeptical as well.

-Spike

Spike what type of weight and the amount are you using? Review?
 
I can't review it as I don't have enough miles, nor did I start with round tires. My bias-ply tires have about 5K on them, with quite a bit of rubber missing all around. They are primarily used in the rocks. When I got them (new) I had them balanced the traditional way, with lead weights held on the inner surface of the wheel with double-sided tape. They rode great. Then I tore them up, and the ride got progressively worse. I knew traditional balancing was only good for a short time, especially considering the abuse I give my tires. I wanted a set of Centramatic wheel balancers, but apparently they don't fit the front hubs on the 80. So I read up and found this method. Thought I'd try it. I put 10-12 ounces of .20 gram (heaviest I could find) Airsoft pellets in each tire, per a chart I found and several places that advised that more was better and not detrimental. (I took off 8, 12, 16, and 20 ounces of lead respectively before putting in the pellets.) I've run them on one wheeling trip, with about 120 highway miles. The ride was improved. I believe they work, but I'll have to put them in a new set of tires before I can 'prove' anything.

It was fairly easy to do and cost less than $20 at Walmart. The airsoft pellets don't rust, clump, or get wet, although I recently heard of them disintegrating (which I'm not sure affects the way they work). I'm pretty much sold on it, until something happens that I don't like. The only drawback I have noticed is the sound when they release from the tire- sounds like someone shaking pebbles in a tin can. It's not very loud and I quit noticing it pretty fast.

One thing- I would not use this method in street tires, for instance on my wife's 80 that never goes offroad. They don't balance immediately, you can feel some vibration for a quarter mile or so from a stop. They're good for my trail truck, because I'll deal with the slight vibration in order to have a good ride on the highway on the way to the trail. Once on the trail, the tires don't spin fast enough for balance to matter. If I had a trailer queen, I probably wouldn't bother with any balancing.

-Spike
 
Hi guys.

As a long time lover/collector of un-intuitive physics puzzlers, I'd like to join in on the "Is it valid" question. I'm pretty sure it is, and I think I can explain it in terms that hopefully won't sound like gobbledygook.

First of all, tech_dog's diagram isn't quite right for the situation: Except for very minutely, the tire doesn't "bulge" in the heavier direction; it stays round about the axle.

Now, lets get to the main issue: A wheel or disc wants to rotate around it's center of mass. With an unbalanced wheel, we're dealing with a disc whose center of mass is not the center of the disc: it's between the center of the disc and the heavy side. So (and I think this is the unintuitive part), with an unbalanced wheel, it's *not* the heavy side that's the furthest from the true axis of rotation (which is somewhere between the axle/center of the wheel and the wheel's center of mass), it's the *light* side. Therefore (this part *is* intuitive and is what tech_dog was demonstrating) the free weights move out as far as possible from the true axis of rotation, which (again) is the light side.


Feel free to question the above, but please keep it respectful so we can all have some fun with it.

Curtis
 
Thanks Spike for the review.

If your tires are out-of-round I dont think anything will help?

What do you guys think the results would be if someone tried to dynamic balance a tire with free weight inside? Would the balancer just freak out and not be able to read? If the balancer ask for more weight should you add more free weight? After adding weight and the balancer still wanted more weight then remove some?
 
What do you guys think the results would be if someone tried to dynamic balance a tire with free weight inside? Would the balancer just freak out and not be able to read? If the balancer ask for more weight should you add more free weight? After adding weight and the balancer still wanted more weight then remove some?

I have tried this twice, with my 35's and most recently with my new tires. It will not read accurately! The machine tries to say it is out of balance, because it cannot accurately measure when the weight is not static. You guess the weight by overall diameter/rim and weight of the tire

Curtis, obviously it will not bulge the tire out like in Techdogs simulation. It will fill in the light area whether it is small or big. I have balanced both sets of tires after trying the wheel weights first. The internal balancing seems to feel exactly the same maybe better especially at highway speeds.

To me the big advantage is after driving 1,000 miles, or 3,000, it still behaves like it was just balanced. Also, external weights get knocked off on the trail anyway. The bigger the tire the more the tire changes.:cheers:
 
I have 37x12.50x16 @ 120# mounted how much weight do I add?

Phil, you can call 4wheelparts and double check, but I think they will tell you 8-10oz.

I ran only 4oz in my 35bfg mt. and now run only 6oz in these 37 iroks. I could have def used more, but they spin fine for me now. I have always used Equal but have had trouble with it coming thru the valve stem when airing up and down with the 37's. I was going to use bb's but got scared thinking of heat build up when going 80 down the highway.

J
 
Curtis, obviously it will not bulge the tire out like in Techdogs simulation. It will fill in the light area whether it is small or big.

That was my point. The relevant part of his diagram is that the stuff will go as far as possible from the true axis of rotation. And, when you think it through, the light side (unintuitively) is furthest from this axis.

Cheers,

Curtis
 
I have 37x12.50x16 @ 120# mounted how much weight do I add?

There was another recent post here in the 80's section, a search for 'Airsoft pellets' should turn it up. There was a chart linked in that thread (by me) that gave you weight by size- height, width, and wheel width. I'm guessing it was around 10-12 oz. for 37's.

-Spike
 
Back
Top Bottom