I can't review it as I don't have enough miles, nor did I start with round tires. My bias-ply tires have about 5K on them, with quite a bit of rubber missing all around. They are primarily used in the rocks. When I got them (new) I had them balanced the traditional way, with lead weights held on the inner surface of the wheel with double-sided tape. They rode great. Then I tore them up, and the ride got progressively worse. I knew traditional balancing was only good for a short time, especially considering the abuse I give my tires. I wanted a set of Centramatic wheel balancers, but apparently they don't fit the front hubs on the 80. So I read up and found this method. Thought I'd try it. I put 10-12 ounces of .20 gram (heaviest I could find) Airsoft pellets in each tire, per a chart I found and several places that advised that more was better and not detrimental. (I took off 8, 12, 16, and 20 ounces of lead respectively before putting in the pellets.) I've run them on one wheeling trip, with about 120 highway miles. The ride was improved. I believe they work, but I'll have to put them in a new set of tires before I can 'prove' anything.
It was fairly easy to do and cost less than $20 at Walmart. The airsoft pellets don't rust, clump, or get wet, although I recently heard of them disintegrating (which I'm not sure affects the way they work). I'm pretty much sold on it, until something happens that I don't like. The only drawback I have noticed is the sound when they release from the tire- sounds like someone shaking pebbles in a tin can. It's not very loud and I quit noticing it pretty fast.
One thing- I would not use this method in street tires, for instance on my wife's 80 that never goes offroad. They don't balance immediately, you can feel some vibration for a quarter mile or so from a stop. They're good for my trail truck, because I'll deal with the slight vibration in order to have a good ride on the highway on the way to the trail. Once on the trail, the tires don't spin fast enough for balance to matter. If I had a trailer queen, I probably wouldn't bother with any balancing.
-Spike