Determine which winch will work for my rigs configuration?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 15, 2005
Threads
105
Messages
1,486
Location
SoCal - westsiiiide
So, I have been searching & reading up on winch's these days (I know Poser says 8274-50 and be done with it), but I wonder if my rigs configuration would allow or preclude a certain winch and how to determine what you need (winch, winch plate, etc.)? As I see it, in my case, it is not just a mater of buying a winch and stickin it on, the rig has setup hurdles to overcome and I am not sure how to best determine what winch/mount and where/how to mount.

Here are details on my specific configuration:

-The PO had a winch, but kept it - never saw it or where/how it was mounted - so no reference to recall. BUT, this means I have a fairlead on the bumper and the bumper was cut to allow the cable to pass thorugh already.

- I do have a Saginaw PS box up front

- I do have a Chevy 350 and airflow over the radi (and not blocking it) is a concern. some setups I have seen ride so high and so far back.... they are right up in the grill blocking airflow.

- I do have KC lights up front

- I do have a brush guard up front

winch_area.jpg

BTW, check out the consecutive #'s on the springs
 
well, I do not NEED a winch at the moment. But, I want to be prepared. I would use it for what everyone else uses theirs for - but not likely in mud given where I live - but who knows? who ever knows?

either way, wouldn't rig configuration be more determinant of your winch selection versus what you might use said winch for? You could love the 8274-50, but if there is no room to mount it given my constraints, it seems configuration is a higher priority than its usage?
 
I would say rig configuration is important, but I would rather modify my rig to make room for the right winch than put one an inadequate one that fits. Yours looks like it has enough room if you move the lights.

Price is also a factor for most, as a new winch can cost a lot. I'd love to try a Warn 9500si MOSFET but I'm not paying $1300 for one. Technically I don't need one either, but eventually I'll drop one in as I suffer from MIBS like everyone else.

Good luck!
 
If you go with a reciever style you have the option of putting it in front or back, and only having it on board when you need it. I used this setup with the last rover I owned. It was a pain to lug it around but I could yank from either end (or your buddy's ride), and it came in handy for cutting firewood. My .02
 
I would purchase the best winch for my vehicle and intended application, and then make it work with my truck, and if I needed to install a different front bumper to keep the winch low out of the radiator air flow, or if I needed to modify a brush gaurd to make the winch fit I would do that, since the brush gaurd and lights are not integral to the fuction of the vehicle or winch.


It looks to me that no matter what winch you go with, you are going to need to modify things on the front of your truck to make it work.


The 8274-50 will work with Saginaw steering systems without issue...as may any of the planetary winches.


Good luck!

-Steve
 
Yes, I understand your points Benson and Poser, but there is only so much to 'modify' in this setup..... lights are easy to move, brush guard is not, PS box is not, chevy 350 is not, bumper I could...

but as I see it, what I have is nothing totally unique per se (chevy 350, Saginaw box, etc.), but it is not as 'generic' as a stock setup. I guess I was also assuming it would be clear I would not put on a weak winch (like a 1000 pounder), but one rated for my size vehicle.... so something in the 8-9000 pound range. In retrosepct, I should have made that need clear.

I was hoping, given the cross section of users on this board and variety of setups seen, someone would be able to see this setup, the issues to overcome and reccomend....

"ah, wantatlc you obviosuly need the low profile 9000 pound XXXX winch by XXXX and becuase of your Saginaw box you would need a plate made by XXXX and it would be best to mount it XXXX"

thnaks guys... I appreciate the info thus far
 
I would think width would be your major factor on getting something between the frame rails. I would start there first. But personally I would stick with the tried and true 8274 or 8274-50. If I can stuff all of this on the front you shouldn't have a problem. THough if your worried about cooling those lights are not going to help. I'd rather ditch the lights than opt for a different winch if it was my choice.

IMG_4860.jpg
 
Trollhole said:
I would think width would be your major factor on getting something between the frame rails. I would start there first. But personally I would stick with the tried and true 8274 or 8274-50. If I can stuff all of this on the front you shouldn't have a problem. THough if your worried about cooling those lights are not going to help. I'd rather ditch the lights than opt for a different winch if it was my choice.

if your referencing my lights, if you look at some of my head on photos (click my signature links), they are actually LOWER than the radi in-take area. no issue there.

but like in your setup, I would never run that is that is an example of right up in the grill I was talking about. I realize you have a pretty modified setup and yours is up on the 'bumper' (such that is is) and works for you. but I would be toast (or my engine would be I should say) :)

since the PO had a winch, and the bumper is cutout for one, there must be some good lower setup possible. I just do not know enough abuout mounting them (nor did I see his setup) to visualize how it was done.
 
okay - well the top photo from my first post shows the width, PS box, depth, bumper attachment to frame rails.

here are a few more of the top down, back side, head on bumper showing the brush guard mount, lights, the location of the fairlead, hole in the actual bumper, etc.

bumper_back.jpg


bumper_top.jpg


bumper_front.jpg


do these help shed light on where or what mount plate/winch might have been installed?
 
Well,


No luck for you.....there was not an 8274 on there.



Are you SURE that there was a winch on there? Could this just be another tale from the punchbowl that the PO told you?


In the pictures that you have provided, I do not see where a winch could have been attached....and have the cable come out that front bumper....




If it were me, I would purchase an 8274-50 and find a bumper that you like, and bolt it up....there are ample available that will probably let you keep that brush gaurd if your heart is set on THAT ONE being on the front of your truck...



Good luck!


-Steve
 
Built my own back in 1995....

1/4" formed " C " channel 4" wide..... 3/8" thick winch mounting plate.....sits low between the frame rails...


Gilbert2-08.jpg




Here is a pic from the bottom showing that it clears that s***ty AGR steering gear, no problem.


ShopKam10-25-03-29.jpg
 
Poser said:
Are you SURE that there was a winch on there? Could this just be another tale from the punchbowl that the PO told you?

for sure it could be more BS from the PO. would be par for course with him. But, there is that fairlead and the hole in the bumper.... so I kind of believed it as why the hell else would those be there I was thinking? one must have been there..... but hey, I would not know for sure if it was a crap claim.

Poser said:
If it were me, I would purchase an 8274-50 and find a bumper that you like, and bolt it up....there are ample available that will probably let you keep that brush gaurd if your heart is set on THAT ONE being on the front of your truck...

yeah, kind of partial to THAT brush guard. first thing I did to the rig when I got it and I like the design and style, so I want it to stay... looks like I can work around from what Rusty shows
 
rusty_tlc said:
With a Saginaw box, below the grill. No problem.

Okay Rusty.... now we are talking.

so, is that a home made mount plate or did you buy it? can I get a picture from the bottom and top down so I can better understand how a wicnh mounts up?

curious, seeing that mount... is there another brand (or Warn winch) that is lower profile on that 8-9k wegiht class that would sit lower and is quality?

also, I notice that my bumper has those angeled gussetts/braces from the bumper to the frame rail. might have to cut the passenger inside one out of the way?
 
I didn't post a pic of mine to say it was what you should do but to show you a direction you could take.

This brings up a good question.

So you have a SBC that is pushing the limits of the cooling capacity. If you are wheeling in low and are using like 2000rpms pretty consitantly would your cruiser overheat? That being said would it overheat at 2k rpms sitting still?

If not then putting a winch 1 ft in front of the grill wouldn't effect the cooling ability. there is plenty of space for airflow.


Also has anyone with a saginaw ps mounted any other type of winch between the frame?

These pictures probably answer the question.
http://www.ih8mud.com/bumper/
 
wantatlc said:
Okay Rusty.... now we are talking.

so, is that a home made mount plate or did you buy it? can I get a picture from the bottom and top down so I can better understand how a wicnh mounts up?

curious, seeing that mount... is there another brand (or Warn winch) that is lower profile on that 8-9k wegiht class that would sit lower and is quality?

also, I notice that my bumper has those angeled gussetts/braces from the bumper to the frame rail. might have to cut the passenger inside one out of the way?
I bought the whole bumper with mounting plate. It's pretty much exactly what Poser described 1/4" C channel. I got it from Cool Cruisers of Texas, just do a search on CCOT HFS bumper. Not having a lot of mad fabbing skillz I decided it would be faster to just buy something off the shelf.

BTW HFS also makes a winch channel that mounts to factory holes between the frame rails.... just look at this page.

I also think Poser was spot on when he said you should first decide what you need a winch for, which winch to buy, then figure out how to make it work.
 
Trollhole said:
I didn't post a pic of mine to say it was what you should do but to show you a direction you could take.

yes, I know.... sorry if you thought I was rebuffing you.... I was just pointing out yours limitations on my setup....

Trollhole said:
This brings up a good question.

So you have a SBC that is pushing the limits of the cooling capacity. If you are wheeling in low and are using like 2000rpms pretty consitantly would your cruiser overheat? That being said would it overheat at 2k rpms sitting still?

If not then putting a winch 1 ft in front of the grill wouldn't effect the cooling ability. there is plenty of space for airflow.

no, the SBC does not push the limits of the cooling UNLESS I am crawling real slow in our inland hot desert. But, I hope to have solved that with my posts on here about installing an auxillary fan to push air when just slow crawling in SoCal desert heat.

Trollhole said:
That being said, it also does NOT overheat at 2k just sitting still. Only when slow crawling in summer in heat.

I would like to know this also...
 
Back
Top Bottom