Weird Engine Noise, Need Help Diagnosing.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 28, 2016
Threads
11
Messages
56
Location
Anchorage, AK
I just changed my oil and switched to Rotella 15w40. It also just dropped below 50*F here for the first time. Not sure these things are relevant, but a little background never hurt.

Since the oil change, Ive had these weird warbling noise coming from the engine. It almost sounds like pinging, but its more hollow. Its difficult to describe, but its present at all revs, including idle and throttle. I tried to snag a video of it, for some reason its easier to hear the noise on my phone than when I play it through my computer. Hopefully youll be able to hear it, and someone can let me know if this sound is a normal side effect of switching to a heavier oil, or if its something I should look into.


P.S. Truck has 158k miles. Ive also been chasing a front end grinding noise, that only comes at extremely low speeds. I doubt thats related but Ill throw it out regardless.
 
Oil pressure is normal, a little higher than before, but I figured that would be normal with a heavier oil. It sits at around the 1st quarter hash at idle.

It was running on 5w30 Mobile 1 synthetic before.
 
I haven't noticed any change when the rpms rise or fall. Can't hear it much when I really romp on it but granted at higher rpm the normal noise of the engine and the road could just be drowning it out.
 
I dont think thats what it is. Just from a quick impression being under the car, it sounds like its coming from the engine block itself, or possibly somewhere between there and the cats.
I appreciate the suggestions though. Anything helps.
 
Do you have a mechanics stethoscope?
 
I dont as of now. I was going to try to find one at Harbor Freight tomorrow. I was busy prepping to move with the 80, until I started chasing that front end grind. Now I have to try to figure this out as well. More unexpected funds coming out of the moving budget.
 
I've had the same issue intermittently for quite some time now. Good news is, (in my case at least) it wasn't a rod-bearing issue. Sorry for the long winded response, alot of context involved in my situation, lol.

My 268k 1FZ has always been noisy, but this noise really freaked me out when it first started. One super cold morning, (10-15*F) I cranked the 80 and it made a loud piston slap noise. Immediately shut it off. Cranked it later that morning after tossing some Lucas in the oil and the piston-slap noise was still audible, but not as loud. I thought the 15w40 Rotella I've always run was to thick for the December climate, so I threw on a new OEM oil filter and switched to 10w30. Sifted through the old oil for at least an hour only to come up with 3-4 metal shavings the size of salt granules. I never could confirm they were from the Cruiser or one of my other cars at the time. After a day or so of driving around running 10w30 I started to notice the noise in your video. I parked the truck and it sat for a few weeks. I finally couldn't take it anymore, the 80 wouldn't fit in my tiny garage, and I wasn't about to swap bearings in a foot of snow in the complex parking lot either... Towed my rig to my old shop in Wheat Ridge (Toyota Specialist shop, well versed with Cruisers) and had them check things out for me while I was out of town for work. My old service writer calls and tells me, bearings even at 241k (at the time) were perfect. Pulled upper/lower pans, valve and timing cover. Only found black-plastic chunks in my upper pan. Timing chain, tensioners, and everything inside the head was unscathed. While it was torn down, I had them swap my perfect original bearings out with new OEM bearings for peace of mind. I was out of town the entire time they had my rig, so I never saw the black-plastic shards.

We came to the conclusion that the PO had broken the old oil cap and pieces fell down into the oil-pan. Eventually a piece positioned it's self to where it was blocking the oil pick-up causing an intermittent oil-starvation. Cleaned pan, fresh rod-bearings, no random engine noise... I was content for the time-being. I eventually got sick of how much oil my 1FZ burned running 5w30. Switched to 10w30 for a cycle then back to 15w40. Every oil change over the last 25k + miles has been free of metal shavings. The noise came back in the last 5-6k miles, almost unnoticeable at first and got to the point where it's as noisy as yours, but hasn't gotten any louder. Oil pressure has been normal throughout, up until recently. I figured it's because I'm about due for an oil change anyway. I asked multiple Toyota/Cruiser buddies to listen to the noise, no one could put a finger on it either.

I recently asked a friend who works at very reputable Land Cruiser shop here in Atlanta and he said to re-torque my crankshaft pulley bolt, as it could have backed it's self loose slightly, improperly driving the oil pump. He suggested my destroyed exhaust, which has multiple leaks could be causing such a weird noise too. (Doubtful it's this)

So in short:

1) It's probably not a bottom-end knock

2) Try re-torquing your crankshaft pulley bolt.

3) Do you have any exhaust leaks? (still doubt this is the issue, just throwing it out there)

I'm going to shake my rig down when I change the oil this weekend. I might pull my upper/lower oil pans, timing cover and valve cover to inspect, they could use a re-seal anyway and re-torque my crank pulley bolt, and report back! Good luck, if you figure it out before I do, please shed some insight lol.
 
You can use a broom handle or rake. Anything with wood. Just press it against your ear and hold to area you want to check!
 
I've had the same issue intermittently for quite some time now. Good news is, (in my case at least) it wasn't a rod-bearing issue. Sorry for the long winded response, alot of context involved in my situation, lol.

My 268k 1FZ has always been noisy, but this noise really freaked me out when it first started. One super cold morning, (10-15*F) I cranked the 80 and it made a loud piston slap noise. Immediately shut it off. Cranked it later that morning after tossing some Lucas in the oil and the piston-slap noise was still audible, but not as loud. I thought the 15w40 Rotella I've always run was to thick for the December climate, so I threw on a new OEM oil filter and switched to 10w30. Sifted through the old oil for at least an hour only to come up with 3-4 metal shavings the size of salt granules. I never could confirm they were from the Cruiser or one of my other cars at the time. After a day or so of driving around running 10w30 I started to notice the noise in your video. I parked the truck and it sat for a few weeks. I finally couldn't take it anymore, the 80 wouldn't fit in my tiny garage, and I wasn't about to swap bearings in a foot of snow in the complex parking lot either... Towed my rig to my old shop in Wheat Ridge (Toyota Specialist shop, well versed with Cruisers) and had them check things out for me while I was out of town for work. My old service writer calls and tells me, bearings even at 241k (at the time) were perfect. Pulled upper/lower pans, valve and timing cover. Only found black-plastic chunks in my upper pan. Timing chain, tensioners, and everything inside the head was unscathed. While it was torn down, I had them swap my perfect original bearings out with new OEM bearings for peace of mind. I was out of town the entire time they had my rig, so I never saw the black-plastic shards.

We came to the conclusion that the PO had broken the old oil cap and pieces fell down into the oil-pan. Eventually a piece positioned it's self to where it was blocking the oil pick-up causing an intermittent oil-starvation. Cleaned pan, fresh rod-bearings, no random engine noise... I was content for the time-being. I eventually got sick of how much oil my 1FZ burned running 5w30. Switched to 10w30 for a cycle then back to 15w40. Every oil change over the last 25k + miles has been free of metal shavings. The noise came back in the last 5-6k miles, almost unnoticeable at first and got to the point where it's as noisy as yours, but hasn't gotten any louder. Oil pressure has been normal throughout, up until recently. I figured it's because I'm about due for an oil change anyway. I asked multiple Toyota/Cruiser buddies to listen to the noise, no one could put a finger on it either.

I recently asked a friend who works at very reputable Land Cruiser shop here in Atlanta and he said to re-torque my crankshaft pulley bolt, as it could have backed it's self loose slightly, improperly driving the oil pump. He suggested my destroyed exhaust, which has multiple leaks could be causing such a weird noise too. (Doubtful it's this)

So in short:

1) It's probably not a bottom-end knock

2) Try re-torquing your crankshaft pulley bolt.

3) Do you have any exhaust leaks? (still doubt this is the issue, just throwing it out there)

I'm going to shake my rig down when I change the oil this weekend. I might pull my upper/lower oil pans, timing cover and valve cover to inspect, they could use a re-seal anyway and re-torque my crank pulley bolt, and report back! Good luck, if you figure it out before I do, please shed some insight lol.

Thanks for the insights, glad to hear at least someone else out there has had a similar situation. Ill update if I can track anything down, in the mean time I will be trying out more diagnostics methods, and sending out my oil for analysis.
 
This is a noise that appears to be coming up alot.. I've had it for 5 or 6k miles. truck runs great and no problem with temps. the noise drives me nuts. As I increase rpms and engine heats up it appears to less noisy. I still have not figured it out. I've pulled belts, replaced ps pump and had two people look at it. hope you find an answer. Maybe this related to age of the cruisers? in the last 6 months at least 4 others have posted with a similar noise.
 
Try looking into the PAIR stuff. It can make some funny noises.

Yeah, I thought about removing it and blocking the ports off. Im going to be registering it in Utah, and I might hold off to see how strict their emissions testing is in Salt Lake. Dont want to screw myself and have it fail.
 
Back
Top Bottom